Should a photographer be a "Jack of all Trades"?

If I wanted to take a really good pic I would highlight its features. But I think it would simply be a product style shot. Nice depth of field, highlighting the typography and book design. But its just a book, a nicely made on and all but I can't connect with it like a person or a landscape or oddly a building. ... Honestly I'm not sure I can really answer that. Why is a book any different to a building? Lighting, clouds, design? Its just an object. I seem to be able to photograph boats well enough and they're just an object. I guess, quite simply, it doesn't inspire me. I guess thats it. I go the extra length to photograph what I see as inspiring. If I see something that makes me go "Wow" then I'm going to want people to do the same when they see the photo.
 
You don't feel any emotion for what your book represents? Get away from the idea of a product on a set and put the book in a context that means something to you - seeing someone browsing through it in Waterstones or reading it over lunch down by the dock. What about someone standing where you took the shot on the page they have open??
 
Yer in that context it works. Its not a book, a product. Its something. I guess in that context its like my photos in my exhibition. They're not just prints. But then it comes back, in some ways, to what I photography. People. Their reaction and relationship to the book.
 
Yup and that, for me, is the key. Find the relationship between the subject and yourself and show it in the shot.

Instead of their reaction to the book, but the reaction the book causes that's the real subject matter. It's a subtle difference but the shot is then about the book not the person.
 
I know we've gone a little off topic there but its really made me think.
 
So my question is this, can you be the best photographer at something such as portraits, but be total crap at everything else? Or do you have to be proficient in every subject to truly call yourself a photographer?

Ok, so this is just my few pence worth.......................
I think you have to "have a go" at everything to find out what you are good at, and it doesn't hurt to know how to photograph different sujects.

I gues once people find a subject they excel at they tend to shoot more of that, leaving other subject to the side.

Years ago when I was disscussing my photography (with my now ex) and what to shoot etc..............he came out with the saying "Jack of all trade, master of none".

I guess that has kinda stuck with me and even as a not very good amature tog I am on a path to "find my subject". Once I find it I will still shoot everything else in an attempt to improve my skills.

I think in the end it is how you feel, if your subject is enouh than great but if you have a wide subject base that is just as good. Neither make one more of a photographer than another in my eyes.

Hope that makes sense as I feel I have started to ramble :bonk:
 
I dunno. Not really inspired these days to photograph a bowl of bananas or a flower but I am inspired to photograph a person. A banana is a banana. A person has a story, emotion, history, a life, a moment, a tear, a connection to every other person on the planet.

There are so many things you can do with your banana, is it alone or in a bunch, clothed or peeled, whole or half eaten, smothered in cream (sundae) or dried into chips?

Add a banana with a prop such as a person or parrot eating it and you have a lot more options

I feel I need to try as many different types of photography as I can as what I learn with one will often be useful for others.
 
Don't get me wrong, I know what you can do. I said "these days" for a reason.

painting-with-light-006.jpg


I did that about 4/5 years ago. But like I said, they were my early days. The days when I played with various things until I found out who I am. People and places. As pxl8 pointed out, if I was photographing something with a person I'd photograph the interaction and emotion relating to it.
 
Just to add my 2c

One comment springs to mind:
"Jack of all trades, master of none!"

How true this is about photography, i dont know. Maybe the enjoyment factor of one type of photography makes us excel at that, and we have to work harder at others.

I really enjoy shooting live music (well, most of the time) so its something that i think i have excelled at, were as i dont have alot of time and patience with landscapes and its something that i need to work on more.

When i invited a friend of mine to my wedding, he said "Hell yeah ill be there, i love a good wedding" and while he isnt a photographer, maybe wedding togs feel like that.

Another point is does it matter if some people excel in one field, or if some people are good at all photography? If you excel in one field, good for you, make the most of it and enjoy it. If you want to learn more, then do so, its your choice! It's not like you would shoot still life if you didnt enjoy it, so why worry about if you know about shooting it?

regardless of if photography for you is a business or a hobby, to me its a matter of enjoyment! So.....ENJOY!!!!! :D

EDIT* How many times can a man use the word "excel" in a post? :lol:
 
My worst nightmare in photography is people. I have no interest in studio work but would like to do candid/outdoor ‘character’ or work related shots. That does not mean that I can’t appreciate others talent in this field.

There are other forms of photography that are out-of-bounds to me due to the restrictions of my current equipment.

That said, I find immense enjoyment in what I do. I do not even attempt to be the best at what I do as I know I can’t be. I do try new things, some will inevitably work whilst some won’t. Even when a shoot subsequently goes horribly wrong when I open them up in PS, and yes I’m usually gutted, I do remember that at the time I enjoyed myself and hopefully learnt something to remember next time.

‘Jack of all trades, master of none’? If you don’t rely on it for a living then why not, what have you got to loose?

Diversify, practice, hone your skills, but above all enjoy it.

To the many on here that take better photographs than me, (that will be most of you), I thank you. You give me something to aspire to.
 
I do not even attempt to be the best at what I do as I know I can’t be.

Well, you won't be if you think like that. :bang:

I take pics of anything and everything because i DO want to be the best at taking shots of something.

I just haven't found what it is yet. :D
 
I do, the fella seems to think Ill be shooting celeb weddings in 10 years, bless him :D

If you're the best, you may as well give up as you will never get any better, always strive to be better :D
 
I like to think i'm fairly good at taking landscapes shots at night, especially long exposure stuff, but come day-time i'm nowhere near.

At the minute, i've found my strengths with Automotive, Low-Light Landscapes, Portrait/People and Animal Portraits. I just need to concentrate on each one now and progress.

I'm crap at shooting buildings, architecture (sp) etc, crap at shooting flowers/plants, amongst other things.

So yes, I think that you find the subject(s) you're happy/good at, and then progress.
 
I've got a blog post in draft that covers this very same topic! I like to take photographs in a variety of different genres, but I probably get the most from taking landscapes.
 
I dunno. Not really inspired these days to photograph a bowl of bananas or a flower but I am inspired to photograph a person. A banana is a banana. A person has a story, emotion, history, a life, a moment, a tear, a connection to every other person on the planet.

In July 07, Irving Penn gave an interview for Vogue, in it he describes an old lamp that he picked up off the street in 1942 someone had chucked out, he liked it so he took it back to his studio, and it sits on his bedside cabinet today.
When his wife died in the early 90's, (she was a model he photographed, Lisa Fonssagrives) he decided the lamp was his only friend, and wanted to take its portrait in celebration of their friendship...:shrug:...

Quote-
"It was like making a portrait of an apple. It's not a human quality I find-I look for the still-life quality, the object itself, the thingness of the thing. I like the little snapper. I like that you can read that the bulb is made in China."

later in the interview he says-
"For all those years," he said, "I turned my head and the lamp was there. That's my lamp! This picture is a love letter." *talking about the portrait he took of it*

Ok, so he was emotional at the time but, there's something about that attitude and approach to a simple still life..
 
Even though I focus on motorsports as well, I'd like to think that I am proficient in other types too. It's something I'd explore for sure, and will keep at it until I'm convinced it's really not for me.

Still life for example, bores me quite a bit, so I stopped trying a long time ago :p
 
Yer if I connected emotionally with the object then I might think different but right now I'm not that emotionally invested in a banana :) I used to play with still life but its not my thing now.
 
Back
Top