Should I shoot Landscapes At ISO 50? And Why Is Expanded ISO Hidden As A CFN?

Messages
5,450
Name
April 2008
Edit My Images
No
I'm just wondering if there is a reason why ISO 50 and 32,000 have to be 'turned on' as a custom function on my 5D? Seems daft, and I might as well always have this function turned on unless there's some reason not to.

Also...

Should I shoot landscapes at ISO 50. What would be the positives and negatives of doing so? Obviously I know shutterspeeds would need to increase, but given that most of my landscapes utilise longer shutterspeeds anyways, I don't really see this as a drawback.
 
I can only assume ISO 50 is there just incase it is too bright for you to get the required shutterspeed when shooting, say you're shooting something at f/1.4 in broad daylight at ISO 100 and the right exposure would have a shutter speed of over 1/8000s?
 
I'm just wondering if there is a reason why ISO 50 and 32,000 have to be 'turned on' as a custom function on my 5D? Seems daft, and I might as well always have this function turned on unless there's some reason not to.
That's because it's not really ISO 50.

It's just overexposing an ISO 100 shot by 1 stop. Same as 3,200 isn't really ISO 3,200.
 
That's because it's not really ISO 50.

It's just overexposing an ISO 100 shot by 1 stop. Same as 32,000 isn't really ISO 32,000.

So not really worth bothering with unless conditions demand it in order to get the required shutterspeed like AMP says (and vice versa 3,200 and low light)?
 
There's absolutely no point in using ISO 50 at all. All you could say is that it would allow you to use a slower shutter speed or wider aperture in certain situations, but there's no improvement in image quality. It doesn't seem to produce any less noise than ISO 100 and you're losing one stop of dynamic range into the bargain.

ISO 3,200 is a tricky one. I've never been in a situation that would require me to use that high an ISO but for certain low-light applications it could be seen as invaluable. It's still an ISO 1,600 image processed in-camera to ISO 3,200 but it might just give you the edge you need.
 
The question for ISO 3200 is whether exposing at that instead of 1600 would give a better noise profile than exposing at 1600 at 1 stop under and then forcing it with software. I assume forcing on the camera would be better?

Does anyone with a 5D have time to have a go? The same scene but one at 3200 and the other at the same shutter speed at 1600 then +1 stop exposure increase using software. I would be quite interested in the result.:)

The same with a more modern camera maybe as well? Maybe the Mk II?
 
Does anyone with a 5D have time to have a go? The same scene but one at 3200 and the other at the same shutter speed at 1600 then +1 stop exposure increase using software. I would be quite interested in the result.:)
Sure, what sort of scene did you have in mind?
 
I seem to remember reading somewhere that the expanded ISO options are turned off by default, because they lead to a limited dynamic range. I can't remember where I might have read it, though.
 
Sure, what sort of scene did you have in mind?

I guess any would be ok, although maybe with a highish dynamic range as there sems to be talk of a problem there?:)
 
according to my magic lantern book ,its to do with the best base setting for the camera in my case iso200. if you use one of the +iso or- iso your playing with the dynamic range of the sensor, thats how i understood it anyway hth
also ive read that you should use the lowest possible iso for best results.(no image noise)
 
Back
Top