Sigma 120-400mm V Canon 100-400mm.

Messages
2,466
Name
Well Dawn of course!
Edit My Images
Yes
Always appreciative of the help I get on here, Im here again asking for more!:D

A lens I hired and was very impressed with was the Canon 100-400 L IS, and from then have wanted one, but funds stop me from buying this. So having recently read a couple of reviews of the Sigma 120-400mm OS, Im seriously thinking this lens may be as good, one Canon mag rates it 2% higher than the canon! So, at literally half the price, your thoughts please.

May I draw your attention to this thread:
http://www.talkphotography.co.uk/forums/showthread.php?t=63890&highlight=sigma+120-400mm

Im assuming this does not apply now?

Here are the two lenses:
http://www.canon.co.uk/For_Home/Pro...Lenses/EF100_400mm_f4.5-5.6L_IS_USM/index.asp

http://www.sigma-imaging-uk.com/lenses/telezoom/120-400mm.htm

Any images taken with the Sigma would be appreciated.
 
I've tested both the 120-400 OS and the 150-500 OS and neither came close to the quality of image that I get from my 100-400. I have three friends who have bought these Sigma OS zooms and all three of them have since px'ed them against Canon 100-400s. The Sigma 120-400 is clearly better value, but IMO the Canon 100-400 is better in all other respects. If you do decide to go for the Sigma make sure you try one first...
 
Hi, if you do take the sigma route I would go for the 150-500 rather than the 400, still cheaper than the canon but with a bit extra reach for not much more money.
If you can afford it the canon lens is worth it, it all depends on if you think the extra cost is worth that bit extra quality.
(ps I went through this dilema picked the canon and am very happy with it)
 
Thanks for the advice, Im still researching but am inclined to go for it as I can never see me affording the Canon. Ive read 4 favourable reviews to date.
 
Dawn, I own one and am more than happy with it. For the cash I don't think you can argue with the image quality, and the IS system is a huge bonus. Check my Flickr for images taken with the lens, the vast majority of my motorsport shots since November 2008 are using the Sigma 120-400mm and an EOS 40D. I would get the 120-400 over the 150-500mm, the longer lens tends to be a bit softer, and is only f6.3 at the long end.

Edit to say, I knew of the issues with frame rate. I bought my lens in November 08 and have never had a problem with getting the full 6.6fps from my camera.
 
Another vote for the 100-400, why not consider a used copy? These things are built like tanks and used ones often appear on here for sale.
 
another for the canon100-400 love mine to little bits:banana::beer:
Shut up!:D I cant afford one!
Dawn, I own one and am more than happy with it. For the cash I don't think you can argue with the image quality, and the IS system is a huge bonus. Check my Flickr for images taken with the lens, the vast majority of my motorsport shots since November 2008 are using the Sigma 120-400mm and an EOS 40D. I would get the 120-400 over the 150-500mm, the longer lens tends to be a bit softer, and is only f6.3 at the long end.

Edit to say, I knew of the issues with frame rate. I bought my lens in November 08 and have never had a problem with getting the full 6.6fps from my camera.
Thanks, I have a 40d so your review is particularly useful, Ill go and look at your photos just now.:)

Another vote for the 100-400, why not consider a used copy? These things are built like tanks and used ones often appear on here for sale.

I have considered a used one Glen, but at over £700 for one at least 5yrs old (two on here recently) I feel the cost is a little unjustified. I did pm one seller and say I could only afford £600 but it was a definite no go, quite rightly I think, but I just havent got any more to spend. Yes I could save, but as most of my stuff is nature, Im struggling for length all the time.
 
I do have a few wildlife/bird type shots in there somewhere Dawn, if that is more what you're interested in.
 
Had a look Richard, EXCELLENT, Id be more than happy with results like those!! Yes seen those too, you've done it, Im ordering one!
 
You won't be disappointed. The only thing to watch is that, at 400mm wide open, it's not the sharpest thing in the world. Stop it down to f6.3 or f7.1 and it improves massively. I know sometimes that isn't an option, but I always keep it in mind if I can get away with it.
 
Cheers Richard, Ill certainly bare that in mind.
 
Back
Top