Slightly upset, paper used photograph but didn't credit

KayJay

Give us a Tena
Messages
5,783
Edit My Images
Yes
So a national paper today used a photograph I had shot for an NGO and printed. I specifically stated what the credit was in an email and fired the shots off to them. Then today I see the photo printed but there's no credit.

I shoot for NGOs and normally don't charge but on this occasion I'm seriously considering taking legal advice in this case. Makes you feel less sympathetic toward the media these days when they're struggling to make money they begin resorting to things like this. It seems like a small thing but I busted my balls off getting that shot to them before a deadline on the understanding that they'd credit me. Money wasn't an issue because I just want a little bit of exposure but given they've used the shot and not even given me a credit is a kick in the balls frankly. Should I get used to this kind of thing or should I stick up for myself?
 
Happens to me all the time - as long as they pay me on time, I take a pragmatic approach...

However in this case I'd fire off an email 'snot-o-gram' to the PicEd.
Same thing happened to me last week. The Times ran one of my older shots from Afghanistan and although the paper edition carried all the right info, the online version seemed to credit their staff photographer...
Two emails later and it was all sorted...
 
Thanks for the advice Rob. Much appreciated. Will speak to them soon. I have the contact details for one of their main photographers who I spoke to on the night also.
 
Thanks for the advice Rob. Much appreciated. Will speak to them soon. I have the contact details for one of their main photographers who I spoke to on the night also.

Don't talk to their photographers - often they work in different areas in the newspaper office.

Which paper was it? You could pursue legal action, but it's unlikely that you'd get far.
 
Sorry, they're not national, it's a Glasgow news paper.

herald?

in any event

1 did you get paid...yes
2 then suggest a credit would be in order to secure your next shots
 
herald?

in any event

1 did you get paid...yes
2 then suggest a credit would be in order to secure your next shots

Nationals see in excess of 5,000 pictures per day - they probably don't have time to worry about your credit.

Anyway, not many people actually look at the bylines on images...
 
Did you get it in writing that they would give you a byline? If not then, basically, tough. I didn't get a byline for the last lot of mine that were published, but then I knew in advance that I wouldn't...
 
If your byline credit was not placed in the IPTC file information on the photograph it is very unlikely that the sub editor would pic it up and credit you.

Cheers Rob
 
Nationals see in excess of 5,000 pictures per day - they probably don't have time to worry about your credit.

Anyway, not many people actually look at the bylines on images...

What looks great on a Portfolio though? A plain image, or an image with your name underneath in a newspaper?
 
Nationals see in excess of 5,000 pictures per day - they probably don't have time to worry about your credit.

Anyway, not many people actually look at the bylines on images...


That's not the point. If you are good at something you don't do it for free, unless it's charitable causes and certainly not for a commercial newspaper. All I was looking for in this case was a credit. If they give staff credit for their shots then why not anyone that submits and gets a photo published.
 
If your byline credit was not placed in the IPTC file information on the photograph it is very unlikely that the sub editor would pic it up and credit you.

Cheers Rob

I always have my IPTC information complete on all photos I take as habit. I even stated what the credit was in the email.
 
Did you get it in writing that they would give you a byline? If not then, basically, tough. I didn't get a byline for the last lot of mine that were published, but then I knew in advance that I wouldn't...

That's the key question. Which you haven't answered.

It's not usually editorial policy to credit every picture, so, unless they had a specific agreement with you in this case, in writing... :shrug:

Either way, it doesn't stop you putting it in your portfolio :thumbs:
 
That's the key question. Which you haven't answered.

It's not usually editorial policy to credit every picture, so, unless they had a specific agreement with you in this case, in writing... :shrug:

Either way, it doesn't stop you putting it in your portfolio :thumbs:

I don't have it in writing. But then they don't have it in writing that the image was for publication either. I will pursue this. Quite surprised by the amount of apathy among some photographers that think it's ok for people, who make money from content, to use their intellectual property without the very least a credit.
 
Nothing will stop me from putting it in my folio. It's my shot taken legitimately by myself.
 
Nothing will stop me from putting it in my folio. It's my shot taken legitimately by myself.

This WAS one good thing about film... you could put the newspaper picture in the portfolio, alongside the negative strip and contact sheet, and not worry about the byline :shrug: Try doing that with a series of 0's and 1's...
 
I don't have it in writing. But then they don't have it in writing that the image was for publication either. I will pursue this. Quite surprised by the amount of apathy among some photographers that think it's ok for people, who make money from content, to use their intellectual property without the very least a credit.

Why did you send it to them then?

If it wasn't in writing, and it's not general policy to credit every picture, then the chances of your request failing to communicate along the way is quite high.

It's just how things are in busy production departments. Nothing malicious.

Don't let indignation get the better of common sense, or your name will get known, for the wrong reasons. Mud sticks.

Edit: it's not apathy, it just doesn't matter that much to most professionals. They know it's their picture, and you can be sure that everybody else that matters will also know it's theirs. Some might even say that credits are only vanity for amateurs.
 
Pah. Thankfully I'm not one for vanity. Just trying to protect my work. It's good to hear points from both sides though and if I get more published in future I guess it's all part of the learning process.
 
Thats a rather harsh comment to make isnt it?

Your saying the guy who took the photo and sent it to a national newspaper, expecting a credit, who is obviously not happy that the editor didint follow standard procedure, is some how causing problems and as such, his name is now mud for wanting recognition for his work? Ok, boot on other foot, you go to work for "X" amount of hours and dont get paid for anything you do because your boss/payroll "FORGOT" to pay you for the work you put in. lets see you kick up a fuss.....your name is now mud for complaining about it.
 
Nationals see in excess of 5,000 pictures per day - they probably don't have time to worry about your credit.

Anyway, not many people actually look at the bylines on images...

Actually they do - this sort of thing is taken very seriously - see my earlier post above.
Two emails to The Times PicEd over a free-for-use Crown Copyright image they'd had since 2006, and they still emailed me back to make sure I was happy they'd taken care of it quickly enough.

And an email to the Photographer is a good move also - if you let-on that you know the other guys working for them on a regular basis it helps establish your bona fides as one of the regular gang, rather than some random togger who got lucky once.

All Photographers and Picture Editors look at the bylines... and it's the PicEds we need to keep in the loop all the time...make them aware we're still pushing out current material.
 
Actually they do - this sort of thing is taken very seriously - see my earlier post above.
Two emails to The Times PicEd over a free-for-use Crown Copyright image they'd had since 2006, and they still emailed me back to make sure I was happy they'd taken care of it quickly enough.

And an email to the Photographer is a good move also - if you let-on that you know the other guys working for them on a regular basis it helps establish your bona fides as one of the regular gang, rather than some random togger who got lucky once.

All Photographers and Picture Editors look at the bylines... and it's the PicEds we need to keep in the loop all the time...make them aware we're still pushing out current material.

I suppose, but what I meant is that at the time of production, when deadlines are tight, it can often be difficult to fit in credits when there is little time. Of course, the problem can be remedied afterward.
 
Not really - appending bylines is a legal copyright requirement, not a 'nice to have'...if the info is there, they're obliged to publish it.
 
Not really - appending bylines is a legal copyright requirement, not a 'nice to have'...if the info is there, they're obliged to publish it.

I'm not sure you're correct there.

Isn't the right to a credit a moral right, which doesn't apply to newspapers?

In any case, its easy to get annoyed about not getting a credit, and I would be, but I would be more annoyed about a newspaper using my work for free.

A newspaper is not a good cause!
 
If you've correctly appended the copyright information to your image it is. It applies to everyone. that's the whole point.
Newspapers very often recieve images with no information appended, or incorrectly labelled.
If you talk to the various PicEds, it's the one thing that bugs them most about photographers - lack of proper captions and byline info - some even forget to include payment details.

The copyright 'Circled-C' appears next to the image name if the correct copyright info is tagged in the metadata sections provided in (for example) Photoshop-CS and above. Also include your relevant copyright url in the box provided.

As someone else pointed out, many use drop-box email sytems that strip away the email text and drop the image attachment onto the PicEds screen, so it's no use including your details or caption in the message section of the email. It must go in the File-Info sections of the image itself.
 
Not really - appending bylines is a legal copyright requirement, not a 'nice to have'...if the info is there, they're obliged to publish it.

There is no legal right to a credit.

It's just an accepted practise. Or not.
 
If you've correctly appended the copyright information to your image it is. It applies to everyone. that's the whole point.
Newspapers very often recieve images with no information appended, or incorrectly labelled.
If you talk to the various PicEds, it's the one thing that bugs them most about photographers - lack of proper captions and byline info - some even forget to include payment details.

The copyright 'Circled-C' appears next to the image name if the correct copyright info is tagged in the metadata sections provided in (for example) Photoshop-CS and above. Also include your relevant copyright url in the box provided.

As someone else pointed out, many use drop-box email sytems that strip away the email text and drop the image attachment onto the PicEds screen, so it's no use including your details or caption in the message section of the email. It must go in the File-Info sections of the image itself.

Some excellent sense here from Rob, who clearly deals with PicEds on a regular basis, and like those of us that do...actually speaks to them before and after submitting.

You can do all you like with your images, but if the desk is doing something strange with them (like the drop-box system) then you'll start wondering why you're not paid on time or various things are incorrect. Unless you phone and speak to someone, it's never going to get sorted.

As for the requirement to credit...I'm not sure, I know a lot of the nationals have a deal with the agencies to credit, but sometimes its just not done for whatever reason. I'm sure I remember reading something about one of the unions trying to agree with the publishers that all images would be credited properly...but I can't recall the details.
 
I've received an apology from the newspaper. Seems as though the folk in that dept are using new software and the byline seemed to have disappeared in transition. The photographer I spoke to told me that he had requested that the editors ensure I received my credit but it just went AWOL. I'll be leaving it there.
 
Did you get it in writing that they would give you a byline? If not then, basically, tough. I didn't get a byline for the last lot of mine that were published, but then I knew in advance that I wouldn't...
Actually, there's a fair amount you can do. Unless you have agreed before hand that you won't get credit, it is your moral right (under Copyright law) to be correctly attributed as the author of the works. (Section 77(4) of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act)

Send them an e-mail. If the license you gave them was something along the lines of "You can use this picture as long as you credit me" then actually, they are in breach of copyright and I would be putting in an invoice.

::EDIT::
See you got it sorted, never mind!

sal (at) salshuel co uk is a good person to talk to on the issue. She's written a good guide on copyright which is on her website as well.
 
they don't have it in writing that the image was for publication either.

Why did you send it to them then?

Pah. Thankfully I'm not one for vanity.


I still don't get why you would send a photograph to a newspaper if you didn't want it published. The only reason I can fathom for doing so would be to see it in print.

The fact that your main gripe is that you didn't get your name appended to it, I'm afraid suggests that vanity was a factor, otherwise you'd just be happy (as I was with mine) that the cause for which you took the image got some free publicity....
 
I still don't get why you would send a photograph to a newspaper if you didn't want it published. The only reason I can fathom for doing so would be to see it in print.

The fact that your main gripe is that you didn't get your name appended to it, I'm afraid suggests that vanity was a factor, otherwise you'd just be happy (as I was with mine) that the cause for which you took the image got some free publicity....

No, vanity wasn't the reason I sent it in. The reason I sent it in was because the NGO I was shooting for asked for it to be sent in. Of course it's nice to get a photo printed but that wasn't MY aim. It was the NGO. It was the first time I've ever sent an image to a publication before.

It's obvious from some of the posts on this thread the folk that value their work and who don't. I'm not in the latter. By not giving an appropriate byline the paper is giving the impression that the work is theirs and not mine. Shouldn't be that difficult to understand.
 
I mean, the fact that I received an apology shows that the newspaper acknowledges that it was in the wrong.
 
No, vanity wasn't the reason I sent it in. The reason I sent it in was because the NGO I was shooting for asked for it to be sent in. Of course it's nice to get a photo printed but that wasn't MY aim. It was the NGO. It was the first time I've ever sent an image to a publication before.

It's obvious from some of the posts on this thread the folk that value their work and who don't. I'm not in the latter. By not giving an appropriate byline the paper is giving the impression that the work is theirs and not mine. Shouldn't be that difficult to understand.


I'm still puzzled, you sent it in on behalf of an NGO, so effectively it was just a PR item, attached (I assume) to a press release, in which case I can't see what the problem is. You can't expect to get credited for stuff like that.

If, on the other hand it was something newsworthy, then, yes, I can see why you would be upset at not getting credited, but not for something like this.
 
It wasn't a press release.

You're completely missing the point, and I can't be arsed clarifying any more... there's not much else I can tell you to make it any clearer. :bang:
 
Back
Top