So my 40D won't focus the right way, but will in the wrong way!

Messages
117
Name
Harry
Edit My Images
Yes
This has me baffled. When I set the metering mode to evaluative and use all the sensors, the picture is blurry. I have to set it to Center weighted average and only use the center sensor to get my images sharp. Is this normal or is it because I use the Tokina 11-16mm lens? Also use the Canon 430ex2 Flashgun.

I hope someone can solve this for me.
 
posting from work but Ive got the same setup 40d tokina 11-16 and you shouldn't have a problem with any of the metering modes are you on about the focusing lights in the viewfinder as i use the middle one primarily instead of all 9. The other point i can think of is do you have the focus ring set to auto on the lens sorry be of more help ill see what you've posted when i finish work and try to help some more if i can
 
Are you looking to check it's actually focusing on the right thing? If you've got it set to use all points it'll pick one or a few itself and what it thinks it should be focusing on doesn't always match what you want it to focus on.

What's the maximum aperture of the lens and are you trying this in good light outdoors?
 
posting from work but Ive got the same setup 40d tokina 11-16 and you shouldn't have a problem with any of the metering modes are you on about the focusing lights in the viewfinder as i use the middle one primarily instead of all 9. The other point i can think of is do you have the focus ring set to auto on the lens sorry be of more help ill see what you've posted when i finish work and try to help some more if i can

Yes mate, everything is in auto mode apart from the camera, which is in manual.
 
Are you looking to check it's actually focusing on the right thing? If you've got it set to use all points it'll pick one or a few itself and what it thinks it should be focusing on doesn't always match what you want it to focus on.

What's the maximum aperture of the lens and are you trying this in good light outdoors?

I use it mainly for nightclub photography, so it's dark! F2.8-f22 mate. Thing is though, my mate works in the same place, with the same camera but different lens. He uses evaluative and full frame but he gets crystal clear shots!:thinking:
 
Not being rude here, but the blurry backgrounds are most likely due to the selected aperture

Sounds more like user error rather than equipment problems and i'm assuming the multi point is picking a focus point other than that which you require

If its dark and you are using f/2.8 very little will be in focus apart from the main focussed on subject, try it on something like f/8 and see what happens, would have to up the iso a fair bit though to get a respectable shutter speed
 
Last edited:
If all focus points are enabled, the 40D selects the focus point that is on the item closest to the camera. As the centre focus point is the most accurate (the only f/2.8 sensor of the nine available), any other focus point will struggle in low light. Definitely sounds like a user error that can be fixed with improved technique.
 
2 images just to clarify what I'm on about

1st, evaluative with all sensors selected. Two lit up and they were on their bodies. F4
Nothing is in focus.
IMG_8387.jpg


Just clicked it over to center spot average at F4 and
IMG_8388.jpg
 
Not being rude here, but the blurry backgrounds are most likely due to the selected aperture

Sounds more like user error rather than equipment problems and i'm assuming the multi point is picking a focus point other than that which you require

If its dark and you are using f/2.8 very little will be in focus apart from the main focussed on subject, try it on something like f/8 and see what happens, would have to up the iso a fair bit though to get a respectable shutter speed

Fair enough mate, I know what you mean, but have a look at the images. No settings changed, only the focus point and metering mode. I get great images all the time using the center spot, but I've been told that i would get better exposure if i used full frame and evaluative metering.
 
Its not the metering mode but the focus point that makes the difference, also not sure what you mean by full frame?

Evaluative and centre focus point would work just as well, no doubt whatever the focus point is on in the first pic will be ok, just not sure where or what it was
 
Last edited:
Hi,
Forgive me if i'm being silly here, only trying to help, but it occurs to me that exposure and focussing are two seperate things. As already pointed out, only the centre focus point is 2.8 which is what you need at these light levels and this would the give the out of focus background.

If you select the centre focus point, it shouldn't make any difference which exposure mode you chose, it should still be in focus. Try selecting centre focus and crank in more ISO to see if that helps.

If that helps, fine, if not, forive me, i've had a flaggon or two!!!
 
Its not the metering mode but the focus point that makes the difference, also not sure what you mean by full frame?

Evaluative and centre focus point would work just as well, no doubt whatever the focus point is on in the first pic will be ok, just not sure where or what it was

Sorry, full frame(selected all focus points), two lit up on their bodies in the first pic, but it's still out of focus. I'm trying to figure out if it's a problem with the camera, as it won't focus properly on what it focuses on when in evaluative and all sensors selected.
 
Hi,
Forgive me if i'm being silly here, only trying to help, but it occurs to me that exposure and focussing are two seperate things. As already pointed out, only the centre focus point is 2.8 which is what you need at these light levels and this would the give the out of focus background.

If you select the centre focus point, it shouldn't make any difference which exposure mode you chose, it should still be in focus. Try selecting centre focus and crank in more ISO to see if that helps.

If that helps, fine, if not, forive me, i've had a flaggon or two!!!

It's OK mate. I know it's two different things. ISO is always on 1600, shutter speed at 8 and the aperture ranging from F4-F5.6, depending on how many people are in the frame.
 
It's OK mate. I know it's two different things. ISO is always on 1600, shutter speed at 8 and the aperture ranging from F4-F5.6, depending on how many people are in the frame.

Just to clarify the details across your posts.. you're taking nightclub photos with a 40D and a 430EXii attached, you're sticking at ISO1600, you've previously mentioned that you're using f/2.9-f/22, or perhaps f/4-f/5.6? And you're always shooting at 1/8th?
 
Seems likely to be user error/understanding settings etc. to me, from the info. provided.
 
Just to clarify the details across your posts.. you're taking nightclub photos with a 40D and a 430EXii attached, you're sticking at ISO1600, you've previously mentioned that you're using f/2.9-f/22, or perhaps f/4-f/5.6? And you're always shooting at 1/8th?

NOOOOOOOOO lol, not F2.8-F22. He was just asking the specs of the lens. I only shoot F3.5-F5.6 for portraits at ISO 1600, Shutter 1/8th normally. I will only change the shutter speed depending where I am working, cause you know that different clubs have different lighting setups. I will also change the shutter speed for crowd shots and when people are dancing/artists performing, etc. My main concern is that there is a problem with my camera. I am happy shooting with the center sensor, but need to find out exactly why it doesn't want to do it on my model.
 
Hi Harry

Not sure if this helps or not?....... But..... those girlie's are lovely, out of focus or not! :D
 
NOOOOOOOOO lol, not F2.8-F22. He was just asking the specs of the lens. I only shoot F3.5-F5.6 for portraits at ISO 1600, Shutter 1/8th normally. I will only change the shutter speed depending where I am working, cause you know that different clubs have different lighting setups. I will also change the shutter speed for crowd shots and when people are dancing/artists performing, etc. My main concern is that there is a problem with my camera. I am happy shooting with the center sensor, but need to find out exactly why it doesn't want to do it on my model.

With the flash attached I'd be in Av mode, shutter speed at 1/250 (or 1/200) unless going for specific effect, and ISO100. Perhaps ISO200. But I wouldn't be at ISO1600 with flash, nor anywhere near 1/8th.

Edit: for the type of shot you've posted as an example..
 
Last edited:
Right out of work and home.

So from reading all the above I'd safely say its not a metering issue metering and focus have no connection at all and having spot over evaluative at all.

Id personally suggest using such lens that you manually set the middle focus point to be the only one the camera uses its the most accurate when diving to F2.8 and should fix your problem.



If you want to try and pin point what's going on set up a tripod and try to replicate the issues your having with a subject that doesn't move and see what the lens is saying regarding to focusing as it should stay at a set range regardless of metering mode.
 
If you always shoot at 1/8 surely it's slight camera shake making the images appear out of focus?
 
Right out of work and home.

So from reading all the above I'd safely say its not a metering issue metering and focus have no connection at all and having spot over evaluative at all.

Id personally suggest using such lens that you manually set the middle focus point to be the only one the camera uses its the most accurate when diving to F2.8 and should fix your problem.



If you want to try and pin point what's going on set up a tripod and try to replicate the issues your having with a subject that doesn't move and see what the lens is saying regarding to focusing as it should stay at a set range regardless of metering mode.

So just keep on doing what I'm doing? Use the middle as the only focusing point?
 
I mainly use the middle as the focusing point as that's the way I tend to shoot or I choose one of the other points I don't think I've ever used them on auto (all of them) since I've owned the camera, its up to you tbh experiment with them.
 
If you always shoot at 1/8 surely it's slight camera shake making the images appear out of focus?

Nope Leslie, not at all. It stays sharp at all times, even at 1/4.

The flash burst is so short that the effective shutter speed is much faster than 1/8. To capture the full flash burst requires 1/250th (that's the fastest the 40D will synch with flash), leaving the shutter open any longer is just capturing ambient - which ISO1600 is suggesting is very minimal.

But why are you choosing ISO1600 and 1/8th for a static flash-lit portrait?
 
The flash burst is so short that the effective shutter speed is much faster than 1/8. To capture the full flash burst requires 1/250th (that's the fastest the 40D will synch with flash), leaving the shutter open any longer is just capturing ambient - which ISO1600 is suggesting is very minimal.

But why are you choosing ISO1600 and 1/8th for a static flash-lit portrait?
Iso 1600, Shutter speed ranges from 0"5 to 1/20


315673_10150310427313837_122037758836_8019818_2106615613_n.jpg

316529_10150318610283837_122037758836_8070242_1265560866_n.jpg

316777_10150318602108837_122037758836_8070130_1045586514_n.jpg

318647_10150327158218837_122037758836_8119312_1166549981_n.jpg

319260_10150310428903837_122037758836_8019846_1438621805_n.jpg

IMG_4661.jpg
 
I'd be on board saying your shutter speed is far too low. Especially for moving people. The flash will freeze the motion mostly, but any other light in the pictures is becoming streaked due to the long shutter speed.

Now, if you didn't use a flash at those speeds you'd jus have a blurry mess. As it stands the blurry image just looks like a misfocussed image. 40D might be struggling in the low light conditions.
 
As far as mis-focus is concerned I think it's been pretty well covered and focus and metering are two separate things.

Definitely use on AF point and make sure that it's on a part of the subject with sufficient detail to lock focus on and that everything is in the same plane. If for example you get part of the subject's cheek and part of the background within the AF spot the system doesn't know which it's supposed to focus on and a blurry shot is the result.

If you use Canon DPP for your processing you can choose to show the active AF spot in your images in DPP and I'm sure it will show up any focusing errors if you do that, although you'll need to take a screen shot for them to show up here.
 
Does it do the same thing in good light? or only in low light?, wondering if the flash focus beam thingy only works in one of the modes.
 
I was wondering about the AF Assist lamp Wayne..

Ok, this could be the problem.. switch to One Shot focus mode. The AF Assist beam on Canon flash units will not work in continuous or servo focus modes. And make sure that AF Assist is enabled in the custom menu on the 40D.

The 430EXii should send out an AF Assist pattern that will cover all 9 AF points on the 40D.
 
I was wondering about the AF Assist lamp Wayne..

Ok, this could be the problem.. switch to One Shot focus mode. The AF Assist beam on Canon flash units will not work in continuous or servo focus modes. And make sure that AF Assist is enabled in the custom menu on the 40D.

The 430EXii should send out an AF Assist pattern that will cover all 9 AF points on the 40D.

It does fire the beam. Think I will swap flashes to see if it makes any difference. As you can see with the attached pics,I only get about 5 out of a 100 blurry by using only the center af point.
 
As I think you've now found out you were demanding too much of the camera. In such low light conditions you're likely to need to use the centre point only for its sensitivity.

Was there any particular reason you were using the camera set to use all focus points? If you map the focus points to the multi-controller you can manually set any of the nine focus points very quickly which bypasses the possibility of the camera getting it wrong.

To do that:
Turn the camera on and press the menu button,
Go to the second last tab (it has an orange icon with a picture of a camera in it),
Select "C. Fn II: Auto Focus/Drive",
Go to setting 3 "AF point selection method",
Choose "1 :Multi-controller direct" - the text should now be blue,
Half press the shutter button to close the menus.

You will now be able to set your AF point manually and quickly using the multi-controller which is the thing that looks like a stubby joystick above the dial on the back of the camera. It might feel odd at first but when you're used to it you'll have your AF point selected before you've even got the camera up to your eye.
One thing to look out for is that if you knock the AF point select button it'll set the camera to use all focus points. Also you can't wake the camera from standby using the multi-controller so it's best to half press the shutter button before trying to set the AF point unless you're absolutely sure the camera is "awake".

With the flash attached I'd be in Av mode, shutter speed at 1/250 (or 1/200) unless going for specific effect, and ISO100. Perhaps ISO200. But I wouldn't be at ISO1600 with flash, nor anywhere near 1/8th.
If you always shoot at 1/8 surely it's slight camera shake making the images appear out of focus?
I'd be on board saying your shutter speed is far too low.

He needs the low shutter speed for atmosphere, if he uses a fast one close to the camera's sync speed he'll only get the flash exposure and the photos will look awful. Whether he can use a faster one obviously depends on the exact amount of light and the depth of field he needs. If anything the background is a little underexposed in the first examples he posted, though he could have gone with a wider aperture looking at the amount of depth of field there is.
 
Last edited:
Like Daz said, it makes it more vibrant using a slow shutter speed. I have come to the conclusion that the 40D struggles to focus in low light, so I'm only using the center AF point. from now on. CT confirmed why the whole pic was out of focus. Tried it on the wekend and it all adds up. Thanks for all your input. Much appreciated.
 
Back
Top