So one of my images has been published, but ..

Messages
1,176
Name
Amin
Edit My Images
Yes
I wonder if the PR team of Butterfly World Project, for whom I took this picture for, could have insisted on a credit for my image published on this.
 
Last edited:
Unfortunately for you, there's no obligation to print a credit when reporting news.

Papers seem even less inclined to do so when it's a PR handout.
 
Unfortunately for you, there's no obligation to print a credit when reporting news.

Papers seem even less inclined to do so when it's a PR handout.

Oh that answers it then.
Thanks for clarifying that. Doesn't make me less annoyed though but it certainly helps.
What would you suggest, just out of interest, as a way to feel compensated, renegotiate a deal with the PR company? Would be keen on hearing the views of you more experienced ones in these matters. I am having a lot more images published and would like to sit down with them and work out a deal.
Some include famous celebrities in the world of show business and high profile figures and they will all end up in newspapers magazines, local and regional ones etc.

Thanks
 
get something down on paper

Hm, does this work the other way around too? As I haven't got anything down on paper do I still retain the copyright of any images used until now, or taken already and are being used?
 
Oh that answers it then.
Thanks for clarifying that. Doesn't make me less annoyed though but it certainly helps.
What would you suggest, just out of interest, as a way to feel compensated, renegotiate a deal with the PR company? Would be keen on hearing the views of you more experienced ones in these matters. I am having a lot more images published and would like to sit down with them and work out a deal.
Some include famous celebrities in the world of show business and high profile figures and they will all end up in newspapers magazines, local and regional ones etc.

Thanks

Get paid for them.

Someone will be making money for the shots at some stage down the line.
 
Hm, does this work the other way around too? As I haven't got anything down on paper do I still retain the copyright of any images used until now, or taken already and are being used?

You do still own the copyright unless there is a written agreement stating otherwise.

Did they pay you to take the pictures in the first place? If so did you have anything in writing regarding usage etc?

If you're doing celebrities etc, they could be worth a fair bit of cash. I would suggest doing some research on licencing images, fees, etc, before doing any more such work.
 
Slightly different but another story re Daily Mail and images they use...

The other week when a house blew up in a gas explosion, Clacton I think it was, they had published a 'before' image of the house, which was a Google street view image. They had credited it to a local photographer/press agency.

Are the Daily Mail really going to pay an agency the fees to cover a Google streetview image or is the agency just trying it on with them???
 
You can demand a print credit. I used a news agency once which had an image of mine in the Mail, Mirror etc and the papers largely didn't credit. I hassled the agency & they got it done. Worth a try for online media.
 
You can demand a print credit. I used a news agency once which had an image of mine in the Mail, Mirror etc and the papers largely didn't credit. I hassled the agency & they got it done. Worth a try for online media.

No you can't. You can ask, but not demand - unless you want to pull your photo that is.
 
Appreciate it's a different jurisdiction, but in France there exists a droit de paternité, a moral right enshrined in law such that the author of a work is entitled to a credit whenever his work is reproduced.

Along with other moral rights, such as the right not to have your work modified by others, this right is inalienable - i.e. it cannot be ceded by contract and any contract terms which attempt to do so that are null and void in French law. An author can choose to remain anonymous, but they can change their mind at a later date. Moral rights in France are held by the author in perpetuity.

A case from 2009 where a photographer was awarded €10,000 from Google Image, who failed to make the proper accreditation, separate from an additional €10,000 fine for infringement of his copyright.

http://www.juriscom.net/actu/visu.php?ID=1184

[a rather more succint summary in French :http://droit-des-ntic.net/tag/droit-de-paternite-photo/ ]

Similar rights exist in both the Berne Convention, derived from French droit moral.

Consequently, as the UK is a signatory of the Berne Convention, it is to be found in English law in ss77-79 of the Copyright Designs and Patents Act 1988. However, this provides a specific exception where the right does not apply to publication in "a newspaper, magazine or similar periodical". It also expires with normal copyright.

Despite the USA also being a signatory of the Berne Convention, it has never ratified the sections of the treaty relating to moral rights and they do not exist in American law.
 
You forgot the other exception in Sect 79(5):

(5)The right does not apply in relation to any work made for the purpose of reporting current events.
 
I wonder if the PR team of Butterfly World Project, for whom I took this picture for, could have insisted on a credit for my image published on this.

It looks as though the photo is syndicated, it says Mail on line at top of page not Butterfly World?
If you are new to having photos published you need to start taking to the mail and whoever you submitted the photo to.Normal syndication fee is 50% for you.
 
kestral said:
It looks as though the photo is syndicated, it says Mail on line at top of page not Butterfly World?
If you are new to having photos published you need to start taking to the mail and whoever you submitted the photo to.Normal syndication fee is 50% for you.

Not wishing to be overly rude, but if you don't know what you're talking about, why are you handing out advice?
 
Not wishing to be overly rude, but if you don't know what you're talking about, why are you handing out advice?

Can you explain why I don't know what I am talking about.I can tell that you know lots more than me you are real clever.:lol:
 
It looks as though the photo is syndicated, it says Mail on line at top of page not Butterfly World?
If you are new to having photos published you need to start taking to the mail and whoever you submitted the photo to.Normal syndication fee is 50% for you.



Can you explain why I don't know what I am talking about.I can tell that you know lots more than me you are real clever.:lol:

Certainly...

The picture has been pushed out via an agency, but the header at the top of the page has nothing to do with that; it's the Mail Online's mast head. Amin linked to the Mail's website, so why would it say Butterfly World?

There'd be little point in talking to the Mail, as they'll just refer you back to the agency, who in turn would refer you back to Butterfly World's PR Dept who pushed the photo out in the first place.

There's no such thing as a standard syndication fee; each agency will have or offer it's own rate.

Amin needs to sort out his relationship with Butterfly World before chasing round the houses.
 
It looks as though the photo is syndicated, it says Mail on line at top of page not Butterfly World?
If you are new to having photos published you need to start taking to the mail and whoever you submitted the photo to.Normal syndication fee is 50% for you.

Sorry, yes I am new to having photos published and also can you explain what syndication means in this case?
Thanks
Amin
 
Certainly...

The picture has been pushed out via an agency, but the header at the top of the page has nothing to do with that; it's the Mail Online's mast head. Amin linked to the Mail's website, so why would it say Butterfly World?

There'd be little point in talking to the Mail, as they'll just refer you back to the agency, who in turn would refer you back to Butterfly World's PR Dept who pushed the photo out in the first place.

There's no such thing as a standard syndication fee; each agency will have or offer it's own rate.

Amin needs to sort out his relationship with Butterfly World before chasing round the houses.

Mark, seems you are spot on in this.
Definitely BW are the ones I need to sit down and have a chat with.

The verbal agreement we had entered into a few months ago was that they would find a way to compensate me which it would in turn translate into monetary payments directly or partially indirectly through them. There were many ways put forward and explored to generate revenues that would become part of payment for my services. This I know is a clever way of companies getting away paying for services like this. I gave it a go but its not working to my satisfaction. So now having my images published and not being credited just adds an extra added issue for me which I will sit down and put a stop to it unless I am compensated.

I have been doing a lot of big names and celebrities and a lot more to come through the year including a lot of macro work that goes into their social media and websites.

Thank you all for your help in this.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top