Not trying to pick any fights here but I see the same sort of argument as shooting in colour as opposed to black and white even if you know you want the finished product in B&W.
I'd have thought by having a "mask" in place you could potentially limit yourself shoot wise but applying the shape/pattern in PP you have more scope.
What an odd post..
Life's too short to PP shapes into bokeh when you can achieve it so easily with a shaped insert.
And there are very good reasons for shooting in colour (digitally) and converting to black and white later (e.g. controlling the luminance of individual colours, or are you using coloured filters on the lens?).
You should try these things sometime![]()
Russ, using a card with a shape cut out doesn't make the whole image look shaped (i.e. as in a heart) it only affects the bokeh in the background, making what would have been a circle into whatever shape the cut-out is. The 'shape' of the image is still a rectangle as normal. Cheap and easy to try. Give it a go.
Found these by searching Google
http://www.flickr.com/photos/bagdadcafe/440697861/
http://x0d.xanga.com/e6af856137434269693955/b215120664.jpg
There are tutorials on the internet about making a shaped 'vignette' around an image (eg the wedding couple inside a heart). Don't confuse the two things, they are different.
What aperture did you use? In this context I think 'wide open' means max aperture not minimum focal length.DuncanDisorderly said:All I got was a vignette the same shape as the hole I placed in front of the lens.
I read the 'how to' features and couldn't see what I was doing wrong so gave up.
(tried with a 24-105 on a 5DII, wide open at 24mm)
Check out this amazing video that makes creative use of custom bokeh.
It got me inspired enough to give it a go - but...
All I got was a vignette the same shape as the hole I placed in front of the lens.
I read the 'how to' features and couldn't see what I was doing wrong so gave up.
(tried with a 24-105 on a 5DII, wide open at 24mm)
I can see why you get the vignette; same reason you shouldn't stack filters (they clip the corners).
Maybe it is something to do with focal length???
At 24mm the DOF is pretty big even at F/4, so you aren't going to get the bokeh effect, try 105mm at F/4 and that should work well.