Sports photography: Frame it there or crop it later?

Messages
837
Edit My Images
No
When shooting sports and AF set to continuous, I have a hell of a time trying to get a decent composition whilst the person I'm trying to focus on is in the selected AF point! I've got one or two decent shots, but usually I've found that I have to crop nearly all the sports shots I take to get a decent composition...is this standard practice? If not, how do people manage to fiddle with AF points AND keep the player in focus AND get a good composition?
 
When you say 'fiddle with AF points' are you settings the selected point manually? I am a Canon user however I assume Nikon will have a similar function, where you select the points you want or set it to automatic.

When I am doing my sports photography, I turn AF on the lens, select auto AF point selection, press the shutter half way down to focus and click click click - Not really seeing why you would have a problem, unless you are using manual AF selection.

Hope this helps.
 
Set the switch on the rear (which controls focus area selection) to the second or third setting so it uses a group of AF points rather than one. Also, go into the menu section that deals with AF and set the camera to deal with FPS + AF so it strikes a balance between firing off shots but makes sure they're in focus. Maybe set the focus area to wide (7-points) rather than the regular 11-points. That will lock onto subjects a bit better when you're panning around.

I'm no sports togger but the majority of my stuff is quick, grab stuff that I have to get in an instant. I tend to set it to group the AF points and then set the actual AF area tot he centre, although getting sued to making adjustments using the D-pad on the rear without looking at it is the key to quick adjustments.
 
For sport with the D3 I use 51 point 3D tracking - pick up the subject in the centre point and it stays with them while I fire a burst.
 
When taking photos, i make sure that i use the focus point that i think the composition will be the best.

Nothing worse than taking loads of photos and having to put in extra time to crop them all when i'm trying to get them online quicker than other people so i get first business.
 
For sport with the D3 I use 51 point 3D tracking - pick up the subject in the centre point and it stays with them while I fire a burst.

The 3D tracking on the D3 (and D700 and D300) is fabulous but it's not on the D200 :(.

On the D200 there is the Auto AF point selector (selector switch to the top IIRC, the opposite of Single point). However, you become reliant on the camera guessing correctly.
 
That's the thing, I'm not a huge fan of letting the camera do the guessing (i.e. closest subject/dynamic), so I have been using group focus on the D200. However, that still means that your composition has to be based upon the autofocus area roughly, and when the action is pretty fast and you're close by on the sidelines (5 a side football for example) usually the players fall outside of the AF area if you're trying to get a decent composition? Also, does anyone else with a d200 feel the selector is quite fiddly to use quickly when play is turning around in the other direction (so need to quickly shift from right AF group to left etc?!)

On another note I don't think that the D200's lock on really works at all, even with lock on on 'long' and af-c and dynamic group focus, it seems to focus on whatever the hell it wants almost immediately after moving off the subject with AF still held??
 
Maybe the D200 is just not the camera for fast action? You could get yoursel a D2Hs which was built for that sort of work for a very reasonable price now - if you can find one! They are first class.
 
I can't speak for how the D200 works for sports but for wildlife shots involving movement (birds flying or animals running) I've only ever found errors to be a fault of mine and not the camera's. I've no doubt the D3, D300 and D700 manage to track focus better but the D200 shouldn't be struggling with it.
 
I can't speak for how the D200 works for sports but for wildlife shots involving movement (birds flying or animals running) I've only ever found errors to be a fault of mine and not the camera's. I've no doubt the D3, D300 and D700 manage to track focus better but the D200 shouldn't be struggling with it.

I don't quite get how the lock on system and focus tracking is meant to work, perhaps you can explain? I've got 2 D200s so I know the problem isn't with them, it must be the way I'm going about trying to focus...?

Settings: Lock on - Normal or Long (not much difference it appears) - AF - AFC:

Area: With Dynamic Group (2nd one down) I can focus on a player but it only uses the centre point of that group still...and then it might keep focus as long as the group is on the player or for perhaps 1/2 a second (if I'm lucky) if I'm off it before it reaquires a new target.

With dynamic point (where apparently it's meant to start focus on the point I choose then track it within the 11 AF points) as soon as I move off the subject (say I start on the centre point), the camera will reacquire focus on whatever the centre point is pointing at, even if the player is now on a different AF point....surely thats not how its meant to work?

As you can imagine this doesn't help for composition....?
 
Have you got an example photo of where the tracking hasn't worked?

The way it functions is fairly complicated, and to be honest I don't fully understand all the options despite having found settings that work for me (I can't tell you them since I'm at uni and my camera is at home) so I found this link - linky
 
Back
Top