Standard Focal Length On 1.6 Crop Sensor Not As Expected

Messages
1,310
Name
Amir
Edit My Images
Yes
Hi,

I have read that the standard focal length on a 35mm camera is 50mm. Based on this I assumed that on a 1.6 camera the standard focal length is 50/1.6 which is 31.25mm.

Today I conducted an experiment with my Canon 50d (1.6 crop) camera which had a Canon 17-55 2.8 lens fitted to it. I looked through the viewfinder with my right eye but i kept my left eye open. This meant i was viewing the scene through the lens with my right eye and naturally with my left eye. I adjusted my zoom until the images from each eye matched up in size. I checked my settings by then viewing only through the eyepiece and only naturally from the same position and indeed the two images seemed to be very similar in size. This should provide me with the standard focal length for my camera.

The problem is the focal length i got to with my experiment was 46mm (equivalent to 73.6mm on a 35mm camera). This is nowhere near the 31.25mm i calculated it to be. In case you are wondering why I care, it is for an assignment on my photography course. I am worried by my results as other people got results much closer to the expected ones. I wonder if anyone can tell me what i am doing wrong? Below is the scene I was doing this all against in case it gives you any hints.


ISO 100, 46mm, f/8, 1/5s
 
Last edited:
The term 'normal' doesn't refer to things being the same size, it refers to the field of view.
 
If its of any value, 50mm on my D700 is nothing like my eyes see.
I'd say my field of view is much wider than the field of view the 50mm gives.
 
were you have put 50/1.6=31.25mm you should times by 1.6 so 50mmx1.6=80mm so as you got yours to 48mm its 48x1.6=76.8 does this come closer to your findings?

No, he's doing it in reverse to find the equivalent of a 50mm lens on a 35mm format camera.
 
No, he's doing it in reverse to find the equivalent of a 50mm lens on a 35mm format camera.

Think im getting myself confused now :lol: I have yet to do this as im doing the same course I have seen somewhere that you can measure from a certain point on your camera to the front where your lens mounts would that be true ? would this give you the standard focal lengh
 
Last edited:
Hi,

I have read that the standard focal length on a 35mm camera is 50mm. Based on this I assumed that on a 1.6 camera the standard focal length is 50/1.6 which is 31.25mm.

Today I conducted an experiment with my Canon 50d (1.6 crop) camera which had a Canon 17-55 2.8 lens fitted to it. I looked through the viewfinder with my right eye but i kept my left eye open. This meant i was viewing the scene through the lens with my right eye and naturally with my left eye. I adjusted my zoom until the images from each eye matched up in size. I checked my settings by then viewing only through the eyepiece and only naturally from the same position and indeed the two images seemed to be very similar in size. This should provide me with the standard focal length for my camera.

The problem is the focal length i got to with my experiment was 46mm (equivalent to 73.6mm on a 35mm camera). This is nowhere near the 31.25mm i calculated it to be. In case you are wondering why I care, it is for an assignment on my photography course. I am worried by my results as other people got results much closer to the expected ones. I wonder if anyone can tell me what i am doing wrong? Below is the scene I was doing this all against in case it gives you any hints.

...

The 40D has 0.95x viewfinder magnification @ 50mm (at infinity).

52.6mm would be the setting that would technically give 1:1 magnification in the viewfinder.
 
Whilst 50mm is considered the standard for 35mm cameras the human eye doesn't behave like a camera being infinitely variable in it's focal length, if you spot a bird in a tree you focus in on it to the exclusion of surrrounding distractions the brain carring out the 'in camera' processing, yet the actual scene visible remains the same. If you relax your field of vision left to right is about 180 degrees, focus on something and it seems narrower.

So going back to your requirement, a focal length of around 35mm will approximate the standard 50mm
 
The term 'normal' doesn't refer to things being the same size, it refers to the field of view.

Technically, that's all there is to it - works out around 45 degrees-ish. Nothing to do with the size of the viewfinder image, or any of the other things relating to the human eye that folks sometimes attribute to it.

In terms of focal length, it is taken as the diagonal of the sensor, approximately.
 
HoppyUK said:
Technically, that's all there is to it - works out around 45 degrees-ish. Nothing to do with the size of the viewfinder image, or any of the other things relating to the human eye that folks sometimes attribute to it.

In terms of focal length, it is taken as the diagonal of the sensor, approximately.

I guess the exercise i have just done for the OAC course I am doing has it wrong then. I was told to match up the image from the viewfinder with the image my other eye was seeing and that this was the standard focal length. It ranges between 46-50mm on the 50d by the way.
 
I guess the exercise i have just done for the OAC course I am doing has it wrong then. I was told to match up the image from the viewfinder with the image my other eye was seeing and that this was the standard focal length. It ranges between 46-50mm on the 50d by the way.

The viewfinder image size is not really a good way to judge what is "normal".

I have tried this test with the D700 and a 50mm lens and the image is a fair bit smaller (about 75% I think) to what i see with my own eye yet 50mm is defined as "normal".
 
It might be more appropriate to consider that a 50mm lens on a 35mm camera gives approx the same sense of perspective (ie things getting smaller as they are further away)
as the human eye.

Longer lengths compress this perspective a d shortet lengths exagerate it.
 
It might be more appropriate to consider that a 50mm lens on a 35mm camera gives approx the same sense of perspective (ie things getting smaller as they are further away)
as the human eye.

Longer lengths compress this perspective a d shortet lengths exagerate it.

Exactly, 50mm on FX = perfection (or 35/30mm on nikon/canon crop)
 
It might be more appropriate to consider that a 50mm lens on a 35mm camera gives approx the same sense of perspective (ie things getting smaller as they are further away)
as the human eye.

Longer lengths compress this perspective a d shortet lengths exagerate it.

That's not a bad generalisation, and it's the reason why Cartier-Bresson tended to use a 50mm lens for his street reportage - things 'look' kind of normal.

But perspective is a function of subject distance, and is not an inherant function of the lens. What happens with a 'standard' lens or whatever you want to call it, is that you tend to shoot from a normal kind of distance, so the perspective (the size relationship between near and far objects) usually looks normal-ish.

Wide angles can produce exagerated perspective because they allow you to shoot from abnormally close range, and still get everything in. Longer lenses tend to flatten perspective, because you usually use them from a greater distance.

Simple test - shoot the same scene from the same position with a wide angle, standard lens, and a telephoto, and then enlarge the centre section of the wide angle and standard lens shots to match the field of view of the telephoto. In terms of perspective, they will be identical.
 
If its of any value, 50mm on my D700 is nothing like my eyes see.
I'd say my field of view is much wider than the field of view the 50mm gives.

Likewise, I find my eyes are more like 19 or 21mm FF lens for total field of view, but the bit I'm actually concentrating on does seem pretty close to 50mm.
 
Back
Top