Standard of wedding photography?

Messages
369
Edit My Images
Yes
Now this may be opening a can of worms :bonk: and if so I'm sorry. But I'm curious and as the saying goes the only stupid question is the question that isn't asked :)

I was bored on Sunday evening so decided to have a look at this wedding photography malarkey and see what is involved for you crazy people who do do it.

Anyway as a part of my research I decided to have a look at the photography section of a wedding forum that came up on google to see what the women there were talking about and get their side of the story (actually if I'm honest I was just looking for funny stories of inept togs or laughing and the demands of some bridezillas). While browsing I came across a thread along the lines of "show us your best photos", I thought that this would be inspiring and maybe help me with some portrait ideas.... oh how wrong I was, I was presented by a barrage of some of the most dull, unimaginative and weak examples of photos I'd ever seen. There were some diamonds among the rough but they were few and far between. I'm not saying I could do any better but a lot of what I saw would have been left out of the final album if not deleted if was the photographer. Maybe I'm too critical and set my standards too high or am expecting too much from someone who is doing what must be a difficult and stressful job.

Now I know looking at one forum isn't representative of all wedding photographers, the photos may have been the bride's favourite for reasons other than the quality of the photo but I was still left underwhelmed.

If you don't have the patience to read all the above here are my questions...

I know that there are a number of very good wedding photographers here and was just wondering that if their quality of work was the exception or the norm? has anyone else noticed a large number of poor quality wedding photographers? or was I just unlucky on my fact finding mission to come across this particular wedding forum?

Also if I'm not the only one who has noticed this and that forum was representative of the norm, why is the standard so low? Is it because it's so easy to pick up a DSLR and pretend to be a photographer?

I'm not going to mention the forum I came across mainly because I can't remember which one it was :lol: but I also wouldn't like to point out the work of anyone on here if they happened to have taken some of the photos (which I doubt as you're all so great here :thumbs:)
 
Well without being able to see the photos for ourselves it's impossible to say if they are the norm, good bad or terrible.
Theres websites and websites, pick a forum with some of the better names in the business posting and the standard is probably going to be higher then another forum where beginners are posting trying to get brides attention and work. Wayne
 
B******s can somebody show me the links to the other thread(s) if it's been asked before? :D
 
Also if I'm not the only one who has noticed this and that forum was representative of the norm, why is the standard so low? Is it because it's so easy to pick up a DSLR and pretend to be a photographer?

Answered in one I think...........:thumbs:

I spent ages making mistakes,learning, then making different mistakes to be as crap as I am now.........:D
 
Well without being able to see the photos for ourselves it's impossible to say if they are the norm, good bad or terrible.
Theres websites and websites, pick a forum with some of the better names in the business posting and the standard is probably going to be higher then another forum where beginners are posting trying to get brides attention and work. Wayne
Hi, it wasn't photographers posting it was brides posting their favourite photos :)

Answered in one I think...........:thumbs:

I spent ages making mistakes,learning, then making different mistakes to be as crap as I am now.........:D
Tell me about it, I've had a SLR for nigh on 15 years and half my life but I still wouldn't sell my photos to anyone. :)
 
Hardly representative of the photographers best work then is it, you don't know who's photos they are posting, they could be uncle Alberts for all you know, and they are the brides favorite, not the togs best work.
Wayne
 
As an example just 2 guys who work in Prague that I'd call very good
http://praguephotographer.net/weddingslideshow.aspx
http://www.kurtvinion.com/weddings/

Most of these are what I'm talking about earlier in the OP, I don't think this is the forum that I was talking about though it seems different but it acts as a good example of the point in my OP http://www.weddingchaos.co.uk/wedding-forum/index.php?showtopic=17196

edit: mods if linking to that forum isn't considered fair play feel free to snip it out :)
 
Hardly representative of the photographers best work then is it, you don't know who's photos they are posting, they could be uncle Alberts for all you know, and they are the brides favorite, not the togs best work.
Wayne
I seem pretty sure they were from the hired photographers, but you're right maybe some of them were from relatives or the like but you'd expect the majority of people's favourite photos to come from the pro after all that's what you're paying for :D
 
They are not representative of most of the pros I know, most of those look very amateur to me. Wayne
 
Now this may be opening a can of worms :bonk:

Probably will but some sense may spill out with all the mess. :lol:

From my own personal experience, I've always thought that the vast majority of wedding images are poor, flat, dull and show no passion from the snapper at all.

Which just makes the truly talented and insipred folks easier to spot. :)
 
At the risk of stating the obvious, if the brides were happy with the pictures, isnt that more important than our opinions?
 
Having spent the weekend at a wedding fair with family (the same people that asked me to do their wedding which I turned down) I can say that some photographers are plain cr@p.

There was one gentleman who had several albums and photobooks on show - in one of these examples (so presumably work he's happy with) there wasn't a single formal shot where he hadn't cut off the top of someone's head or lost a shoulder and arm. Another album had the white balance totally off, all the people were coming out orange (even the 4 and 5 year olds running around) and I do mean ALL, it wasn't a Dale Winton fake tan!

There was another chap who had taken more contemporary shots, and were generally very nice, but some of them needed a tad PP to work. He'd taken a really nice shot of three bridesmaids (all under 7) looking out of a window over a beatiful garden but he hadn't levelled the horizon (which was the case in most of his shots) but for this photo it was so close to level it really did need doing, it was too close to pass off that it wasn't meant to be level

The number of wedding photographers who's candit shots are just the formal poses and then telling everyone to jump up or turn and talk to each other is through the roof - can they not think of anything else or is it the case that those are the photos selected by the bride ad groom to be put into the album?
 
Last year I went to a wedding of some family friends who hired a professional wedding photographer to cover the day. He was well presented and professional and seemed to be getting all the right shots, but when I saw the pictures later that month I was astounded!

The quality of the pictures was terrible, and they had paid quite a lot (in my opinion) for his services. The images were mostly wonky or poorly framed, especially the church shots which were at a pretty extreme wonk! And for the majority and generic sepia tone had been placed over them and it wasn't well done.

He was also charging an absolute fortune for 6x4 prints, I found it pretty cheeky.

But, the B&G were overjoyed with their finished wedding album and commented on how well presented and punctual he was. And that seems to be the way it is for many wedding togs - they produce pictures which in the eye of a fellow photographer are diabolical, but if the couple are happy then the business continues.

If/when I get married, I will know exactly what to look for! I certainly wouldn't put up with any wonky pictures ;)
 
Last year I went to a wedding of some family friends who hired a professional wedding photographer to cover the day. He was well presented and professional and seemed to be getting all the right shots, but when I saw the pictures later that month I was astounded!

A similar situation occurred at my own wedding. The final shots were very poor but as our parents had organised everything I didn't get a chance to see them until they were all paid for. Maybe I'm just extra critical as I've had experience with photography but there were far too many shots that were poorly framed, badly composed and some were just plain out of focus... I was shocked that it had cost so much. And this was someone making their living from wedding photography! To be honest it was quite upsetting, as we couldn't exactly go back and do the day again. :shake:
 
Have to agree with the above comments. Me and my other half were at a wedding show last weekend and I saw some poor work! Plenty of flash alloy heavy albums, but open them up and there were some very noisy and out of focus pictures. Fortunatly we have picked our photographer for our wedding and they never attend wedding shows, as they dont need to! Very very impressive work. The good ones are out there but as has already been mentioned, its very easy to play ' Im a photographer ' with a DSLR now and earn anything up to 2k a go!
 
weve done a few wedding fairs(as togs) in the past.
most of the "competition" have been very good, but the odd one has been "interesting" to say the least.
average to poor photographs in well worn albums. and attitudes that wouldnt sell water in a desert.
if a client shows interest, we tell them what they need to know, and encourage them to look at our website as well.
and other peoples too.
often raises an eyebrow when suggested, but often gets us work.
and our previous clients feed us in more work in recomendations.
i wouldnt say a lot of wedding togs i have come across , are poor.
but there are a few.
fortunately for us, my mrs is such a pain in the a*** perfectionist, that i know we'll never get listed in with the poor ones.
 
Most wedding photographers are average. It's a statistical certainty :D
 
TAKE COVER!

I ain't getting involved in this one, my only comment would be that my £300 wedding tog at my wedding was no worse than the £1500 tog my mate hired.
 
It's an interesting topic ,Col. I've found myself in the same situation, recently. I've been looking around at various wedding sites and galleries, and quite often just ended up rolling my eyes and thinking "you cannot be charging for that!" But I think Selkie hit on the head with this:

Selkie said:
But, the B&G were overjoyed with their finished wedding album and commented on how well presented and punctual he was. And that seems to be the way it is for many wedding togs - they produce pictures which in the eye of a fellow photographer are diabolical, but if the couple are happy then the business continues.

I now feel that some of the images that I saw and felt were, to be frank, crap, might well have been perfectly fine in the eyes of the photographer and his clients. In fact the photographers must have been happy with them because they included them in their online galleries. There are a couple of good examples in one of the links posted above. This image could easily have been taken by a guest with a P & S. And I think most people here would have been embarrassed to charge for this. Yet the bride listed these as amongst her favourites for the whole day.

I think it's easy to forget that for many people, photography is not a large part of their lives. What they want from their wedding images is a record of the day. For them, content towers over form in importance. If they have Aunty Flow and Uncle George beaming at the camera, who cares if it's a little soft, or their limbs are cropped?

On a similar note, I've had a look at a few sites offering training for would-be Wedding photographers. They're all run along the same lines: no experience necessary, you don't need to be an experienced photographer. Come along for a few days training which will be split between teaching business practices and showing you how to take pictures, then go away and set up your wedding business. Again, I felt myself thinking, "that's just crazy". But now, I dunno ... I guess that I feel that as long as you show your prospective clients a genuinely representative gallery of your work, then if people are willing to hire you based on that, good luck to you.
 
I'd be very wary of sites who say that you don't need any experience at all. I've been on a couple of training courses with very experienced trainers and with both of them there was an expectation that you know your camera inside out, otherwise you will soon be left behind. The occasional question is fine, there will always be something you are unfamiliar with especially charting new territories but inexperience? Not a chance.

Training is important in any job and wedding photography is no exception. Not only are you a photographer, you are your own PR, Marketing, Sales, Accounting and production line. You had better know how to do the lot! :)
 
I've just had a look on the forum that was posted above and following links came across this. http://www.photographers4charity.co.uk/ quite a noble cause I know, but would you trust such an important day to some one that does it for free so to speak?
 
keith.l
just looked at the two links you posted.
erm. not nice.
the arm coming from out of shot on the first one , was a real treat. ...
it is sadly a fact , that a lot of customers wouldnt recognise a good shot from a bad one.
ah well. we do our very best, and hope they apreciate the quality.
 
At the risk of stating the obvious, if the brides were happy with the pictures, isnt that more important than our opinions?

Not really Dave, They're looking at pictures of their own day. They will be somewhat "clouded" in their opinions.

We're a photographic forum possibly aimed at improving the standard and name of photography across the UK/globe through collective critique and feedback.

It's like every aspect of photography.

Photography has become so accessible to the masses which means you do get a whole raft of people who don't really have the eye, experience, equipment knowledge, basic nouse etc etc but do have bounding enthusiasm for finding something new. They then set themselves up as wedding photographers because it's seen as the most lucrative form of photography, and a family member happened to say they took a good picture of their cat once.

The growing majority of clients want to pay the least they can for photos (even more so if these times of recession) so the two very often collide.

Not rocket science really to see why it's happening (i.e. larger quantities of images on your wedding forum don't seem that "professional") , but as I say, common in all aspects of photography, not just weddings.

It's been said in other threads, but you really do have to walk before you run if you're going to take on something as specialist as weddings, but a free market doesn't stop those who are full of enthusiasm.
 
I've just had a look on the forum that was posted above and following links came across this. http://www.photographers4charity.co.uk/ quite a noble cause I know, but would you trust such an important day to some one that does it for free so to speak?
I have had a look at that site, it seems to be linked to SWPP which is a wedding photography society. Just checked out 2 links this one andthis one and they look (to me) to be pretty good photographers, so yes I would trust one of these. It looks as if each photographer is donating their time for the wedding and the bride and groom donate to cancer research. If I have understood it correctly I think its a great idea and well done to them to organising it.
 
so come on then post your wedding shots and lets all decide who's good and who's bad

anyone want to go first or shall i :D
 
keith.l
just looked at the two links you posted.
erm. not nice.
the arm coming from out of shot on the first one , was a real treat. ...
And the autofocus made a nice job of the feather on the second one :)

it is sadly a fact , that a lot of customers wouldnt recognise a good shot from a bad one.
ah well. we do our very best, and hope they apreciate the quality.
But, on the other hand, I guess you could argue that it's her wedding so she's the one to say what's a good shot and what isn't. And I think that's why there is a market for the lower priced guys. I think for quite a lot of people, what's important about the pictures is simply who is in them, their expressions, and what they're doing. They're not too worried about photographic techniques or subtleties. Near enough is good enough. And on that basis, anyone with a DSLR on auto is going to be able to provide them with a reasonable number of the type of images they're after.
 
I'd be very wary of sites who say that you don't need any experience at all. I've been on a couple of training courses with very experienced trainers and with both of them there was an expectation that you know your camera inside out, otherwise you will soon be left behind.

And that's the kind of thing I would be looking for, Ali. Do you have any specific recommendations?

Here's an example of a from-beginner-to-expert site. And they're not fly-by-night people either. They're a very big franchise.

They claim "When you have finished your wedding/portrait course, your first wedding/portrait will look like you have been taking weddings/portraits for 10 years." The training consists of around 5 days face-to-face and 20 modules of distance learning, spread over 4 months. So, not exactly overnight, but still a pretty tall claim, imo. I'd be interested to hear what you make of them. One major plus point is they (kind of) offer opportunity to work as a second to a working pro. But they're pretty vague on the details.
 
Yep, I joined the SWPP and we now have a little regional meet and there is access to a whole load of training material there.

Damien Lovegrove comes recommended.
Martin Graham Dunn also comes highly recommended.

Personally I've been on courses with Mark Cleghorn and Brett Harkness and found them both to be very useful. Mark is my favourite trainer because he just communicates the way than suits me best. Have a look at his wedding photography book, it's the best resource I've found.

The £2K package there is kind of modelled on the Annabel Williams model which is £8K and takes a year so I suppose it's not bad value. I really don't like the assumptions that you will be turned into a pro who can take photos like a 10 year pro in 5 days. Yeah right. My dad had a saying "You only get one year's experience in a year" He was right, you can't replicate all the challenges of 10 years in 5 days and in any other field would you expect to?

"Cook like a Michelin pro chef in just 5 days" Hmmmmm.

If that's their example of a selling technique I'd run a mile personally.

I think you can get better training but you would have to go to different sources for it. Local business startup will provide business training, your bank can offer advice.

I come from a sales/marketing background so I'm fortunate in that respect but that can be sourced through SWPP and both Mark and Brett offer that kind of advice.

Hope that helps
 
I think it's all summed up quite simply in the strap line of Freddy Corrales who posts in the G&N forum here:
"Beauty is in the eye of the beholder"
( Margaret Wolfe Hungerford)
 
My dad had a saying "You only get one year's experience in a year"

Exactly!

I come from a sales/marketing background so I'm fortunate in that respect but that can be sourced through SWPP and both Mark and Brett offer that kind of advice.

That's a lot of what I'm looking for. I'm pretty comfortable with my photography, but I need to learn more about sales and marketing. And also the mechanics of wedding shoot - the standard shots, the critical moments, the timings etc. I also think if you find a good trainer, a lot of the really good stuff comes in the asides and the meal breaks.

Hope that helps
Very much, thanks. I'll check out the resources you mentioned.
 
And also the mechanics of wedding shoot - the standard shots, the critical moments, the timings etc. I also think if you find a good trainer, a lot of the really good stuff comes in the asides and the meal breaks.

Now for the actual process I'd recommend Mark's book on Wedding Photography. It takes you right through the day in the right order, with the shots and ideas on how to do them well.

I do find time with a good trainer to be invaluable. It's an investment.

I did tell my partner I had found the perfect training course for me tonight............in the Bahamas and it was only $425......Bargain! :D
 
Now for the actual process I'd recommend Mark's book on Wedding Photography. It takes you right through the day in the right order, with the shots and ideas on how to do them well.
Cool, I check it out.

I did tell my partner I had found the perfect training course for me tonight............in the Bahamas and it was only $425......Bargain! :D

Training is tax-deductible - go for it!
 
There's been some good food for thought here.

I can appreciate that if the bride is happy then that's all that matters and I have to totally agree, but that doesn't stop the little voice in the back of my head saying "that's a boring shot" :) I guess I just have to look it from their POV, the photo is a moment of their day frozen in time for eternity and can trigger memories and emotions, even if the photo is awful.

Wedding photography for me is a strange beast, on one hand it interests me greatly but on the other hand I'm not sure if it's something that's right for me. Some day I may see if I can second shoot a wedding just for the experience, that'll be a while yet.
 
Looking at it from another angle, if the B+G have paid £600 - £1500 for a photographer for their big day, is their pride likely to allow them to admint to people that they were rubbish?
They will be telling all and sundry that the the tog was brilliant, even if that is not how they describe them between themselves.

If there's one thing I learnt during the two years that alll my friends seemed to get married, it's that there's a rather (un)healthy sense of competition between them all.
 
Looking at it from another angle, if the B+G have paid £600 - £1500 for a photographer for their big day, is their pride likely to allow them to admint to people that they were rubbish?
They will be telling all and sundry that the the tog was brilliant, even if that is not how they describe them between themselves.

If there's one thing I learnt during the two years that alll my friends seemed to get married, it's that there's a rather (un)healthy sense of competition between them all.

Ah, "Keeping up with the Jones's".............

But as we say in Yorkshur, "You Can't polish a t**d" and no matter how a B&G may "big-up" the shots for the purposes of "Jonsey-ism", if they're not good shots even the most untrained eye can sometimes tell and I hazard a guess the photographer will soon find out that his stuff's not up to expectation. Put it this way, people don't have £600-£1500 to throw away nowadays so I doubt they'll sit back and keep shtum if they're not happy.
 
I got married last August and spent months researching photographers. In the end the one we picked turned out to be fantastic and the finished albums superb. My wife and I had a pretty good idea of what we wanted and we got that. However, my brother in law had a photographer that I would call 'basic' the pics are fine but it cost not far off what ours did and in fairness anyone competent with a camera and basic editing could have done the job.
 
Put it this way, people don't have £600-£1500 to throw away nowadays so I doubt they'll sit back and keep shtum if they're not happy.

Don't they :thinking:

Then my diary must be full of imaginary £1000-£2000 bookings this year
 
As an example just 2 guys who work in Prague that I'd call very good
http://praguephotographer.net/weddingslideshow.aspx
http://www.kurtvinion.com/weddings/

Most of these are what I'm talking about earlier in the OP, I don't think this is the forum that I was talking about though it seems different but it acts as a good example of the point in my OP http://www.weddingchaos.co.uk/wedding-forum/index.php?showtopic=17196

edit: mods if linking to that forum isn't considered fair play feel free to snip it out :)

Thanks for your kind words about my photography (I'm the first link). I know Kurt Vinion as well and we've both been in the wedding photo game a while. We both agreed (while talking shop over beer) that too many amateurs with the latest gear are pretending to be photographers. They have a credit card and no experience. The sad reality is that regardless of the current global climate, people do not seem to value wedding photography as much as they used to. Kurt told me that we should not be cheaper than the damn cake n flowers. I agree. I've seen a drop off in Prague as a destination wedding photography hot spot mainly because Prague has become very expensive and people want to cut corners. With a ton of photographers in Prague (most of whom are not really photographers, just posers, pardon the pun) willing to undercut each other to survive, the bridezillas win.

Just found this forum by accident and joined. I will be following it and posting soon.
 
Back
Top