Suspicion of entered pics in a competition.

Messages
698
Name
John
Edit My Images
Yes
If you ran a monthly competition on a forum, what sort of software could be used to check if entrants are 'using' pics off of the web?

I've been using Tineye but I don't think it has ever found anything. Even my own pics that I know are on other sites.


Cheers guys.
 
No such thing.. if someone was going to cheat they would be able to do it undetected.
 
A lot of my pictures are hosted on my own website. How would any such software distinguish if photos that I might enter in to a competition were legitimately mine to enter, or were just being lifted from my site?
 
i guess if the photos were entered for a comp with a prize you could ask to see proof of the raw image as a pre requisite, as most people only post edited jpgs on websites. Woudl be very difficult to be 100% certain someone hadnt taken an image from the web, unless they were particulalry silly and left the original owners info in the exif ;) could also make it a pre req that all EXIF info must be visible in the image, that way it can show Serial number of the camera used to take the image etc. Very manual admittedly, but if you want to be as certain as you can be these may help. Like i said would only be worth the hassle if a prize/prizes were involved.
 
Very manual admittedly, but if you want to be as certain as you can be these may help. Like i said would only be worth the hassle if a prize/prizes were involved.

I think something half-way would be better? State in the rules that the above info must be made available.
Should someone win, then you would need to see something tie-ing the image, i.e. exif serial number to the person who took the photo.
 
You can also embed your name and copyright into exif on download. Might be worth making it a condition of entry. Could just put off anyone likely to chance their arm?
 
DPChallenge, for instance, insists that the original, unedited image direct from the camera be uploaded by the contest winners.
 
What if you've shot in JPEG, there will be no raw image!

What if you open an image, select all, copy, File/New, paste image into new file, flatten all the layers, save as a new JPEG.

I don't think you could be able to detect someone trying to cheat!

There is also a post on this site about someone using a tame wolf to jump over a fence, in the rules it states wildlife so his submission is under review until the judges make a decision! This also shows how difficult a time judges have when hosting competitions!

Glad I don't take part!!!!!

Carl.
 
What if you've shot in JPEG, there will be no raw image!

What if you open an image, select all, copy, File/New, paste image into new file, flatten all the layers, save as a new JPEG.

I don't think you could be able to detect someone trying to cheat!

There is also a post on this site about someone using a tame wolf to jump over a fence, in the rules it states wildlife so his submission is under review until the judges make a decision! This also shows how difficult a time judges have when hosting competitions!

Glad I don't take part!!!!!

Carl.

The original, unedited JPEG would be you 'raw' file then. Surely folk who don't shoot raw keep those?
 
i keep all my raws that i dont bin straight away for out of focus etc, what if i want to edit a shot to print A3 and i only have a 700 pixel wide JPG saved for web ? guess it depends on your editing routine really.
 
i can't believe anyone would have the audacity to try and pass off someone else's pic as their own... imagine the embarrassment if you got found out!!

i think the criteria for any competition would be that you must be able to verify it's your own pic should you win, with either original unedited image or raw file.
 
Back
Top