Tamron 24-75mm 2.8 poor autofocus or poor photographer???

Messages
2,079
Edit My Images
Yes
Hello folks. I have a Nikon D5000 at present and invested in 24-75mm Tamron 2.8 lens. It can be incredibly sharp and is a definite step up from a kit lens, and the best I could afford as Nikon glass is fantastic but costly. Unfortunately, it seems to struggle to get accurate focus when wide open, especially with shots of my kids in decent or poor outdoor light. I understand that the DOF will be shallow, but it always seems to focus on t-shirts and dresses etc so the face always seems to be soft. It locks on very quickly but then when I shoot, it seems soft, yet the clothes of the subject are pin sharp. Is it a lens issue, for example the lens locking on to higher contrast in the clothing, or is it a fault of mine, as in moving once having locked focus. It would seem to be a lens issue to me, as the plane of focus always seems to be locked on the clothing, ie behind the face. I could shoot with a smaller aperture, but there are times when I want a softer smoother background bokeh. Will smaller apertures help with focus as well as DOF?

Please help.
 
using a smaller aperture won't make a difference becausethe focus is done with the lens wide open, only stopping down for the duration of the exposure.

shooting wide open needs accurate focussing, small movements on either your part or your subject will cause the focal plan to deviate from where you want it to be.
 
Are you using multi focus points or a single focus point? It sounds like the former. Try picking the point nearest to the subject eyes. High contrast away from a selected point should not interfere. HTH
 
Shallow DoF portraits are notorious for user focusing errors. The subject moves, the camera moves, even focus-recompose technique which usually means redirecting the camera slightly will result in small errors (triangulation distance change). So it could be that. Or the lens could be misfocusing slightly.

Either way, you need to check it against a flat, static target, camera fixed/tripod. See recent threads on how to do it easily, like this one http://www.talkphotography.co.uk/forums/showthread.php?t=323443
 
I had the same lens - and got terrific results with it - razor sharp, however as you are aware 2.8 can be very easily made oof if you are recomposing and moving a little.
 
Kieth, same as me; a d5000, I'm bloody useless with it wide open as well! Practice practice practice, easier said than done but it's not a bad lens (provided you don't simply have a duffer!) just needs lots of practice. Could try af-c focusing as well although I'm not entirely sure this would make a difference compensating for such small errors in focus distance.
Think I'll try myself tomorrow an see.
 
I use this lens on my D90 and now get some great results but when I first started using it I was convinced it was back focussing. This was, of course, operator error - I had a tendency to lean forward slightly just before releasing the shutter. This was noticed by a fellow camera club member during a studio shoot and correcting that trait has resulted in getting much better results.

This is now my favoured portrait lens when working in small spaces, like someones living room, where I don't have room to back off and use the 70-200.

Persevere with it and the Tamron will give you great pictures :)
 
Thanks for the advice guys. I think it is indeed operator error. I tried to do a couple of shots wide open and stand as still as possible and it seemed to focus just fine. Practice practice i guess. It's a pin sharp lens and I use it most of the time. The only time I find it frustrating is at about 55mm as I don't find it as sharp wide open at this focal length at all.
 
Make sure you have continuous focus set, so it constantly refocuses to what is in the centre of the viewfinder.
 
Thanks for the advice guys. I think it is indeed operator error. I tried to do a couple of shots wide open and stand as still as possible and it seemed to focus just fine. Practice practice i guess. It's a pin sharp lens and I use it most of the time. The only time I find it frustrating is at about 55mm as I don't find it as sharp wide open at this focal length at all.

Well at least you are half way to sorting the issue!

How do you find the Tammy in general? They seem to get pretty sound write ups on the t'net.
 
Back
Top