The BBC’s fundamental misunderstanding of copyright

Messages
2,650
Edit My Images
Yes
Is the BBC taking the mickey or what. The following is cut and pasted from the following site should you not want to click on the link.

http://pigsonthewing.org.uk/bbc-fundamental-misunderstanding-copyright/?utm_source=rickmans.me&utm_medium=twitter&utm_campaign=social

The BBC’s fundamental misunderstanding of copyright
Posted on August 13, 2011 by Andy Mabbett

On 6 August, I sent a complaint to the BBC:

Your reporting of this evening’s riot in Tottenham included photographs which you said, were “from Twitter”.

You may have found them via that website but they would have been hosted elsewhere and taken by other photographers, whom you did not name and whose copyright you may have breached.

You have done this with other recent news stories such as the Oslo attacks.

This is not acceptable.

In future, please give proper credit to photographers.

Here’s their reply, with my annotations and emboldening:

Dear Mr MABBETT [I've no idea why thay capitalised that — AM]

Reference CAS-918869-HR7W5Y

Thank you for your contact.

I understand you were unhappy that pictures from Twitter are used on BBC programmes as you feel it may be a breach of copyright.

Twitter is a social network platform which is available to most people who have a computer and therefore any content on it is not subject to the same copyright laws as it is already in the public domain. The BBC is aware of copyright issues and is careful to abide by these laws.

I appreciate you feel the BBC shouldn’t be using pictures from Twitter [I didn't say that — AM] and so I’ve registered your comment on our audience log. This is a daily report of audience feedback that’s made available to many BBC staff, including members of the BBC Executive Board, channel controllers and other senior managers as well as the programme makers and producers of ‘BBC News’.

The audience logs are seen as important documents that can help shape decisions about future programming and content.

Thanks again for taking the time to contact us.

I’m speechless.
 
Just read the terms on places like Twitpic:

To publish another Twitpic user’s content for any commercial purpose or for distribution beyond the acceptable Twitter "retweet" which links back to the original user’s content page on Twitpic, whether online, in print publication, television, or any other format, you are required to obtain permission from Twitpic in advance of said usage and attribute credit to Twitpic as the source where you have obtained the content.

You retain all ownership rights to Content uploaded to Twitpic. However, by submitting Content to Twitpic, you hereby grant Twitpic a worldwide, non-exclusive, royalty-free, sublicenseable and transferable license to use, reproduce, distribute, prepare derivative works of, display, and perform the Content in connection with the Service and Twitpic's (and its successors' and affiliates') business, including without limitation for promoting and redistributing part or all of the Service (and derivative works thereof) in any media formats and through any media channels.

Basically you own the copyright but you give them free reign to do what they like with it. I imagine the BBC etc all have a deal with twitpic to use the pics as and when they like.
 
It sounds like a very grey area tbh. The BBC, as above, may well have a deal and using these pictures legally.

If anything, unless they own the copyright themselves, you could argue that it is the 'tweeter' in breach, and the BBC have taken the photographs in good faith.

Morally wrong, perhaps. But legally...

And good luck to anyone trying to claim compensation from some kid sat in his bedroom on twitter!
 
Does this mean that anyone that owns a TV can capture broadcasts from the BBC and use them as they see fit. They are in the public domain after all.
 
Does this mean that anyone that owns a TV can capture broadcasts from the BBC and use them as they see fit. They are in the public domain after all.

You're intentionally twisting things around and misunderstanding the processes behind them. An organisation like the BBC creates their own content and exhibits it through their own channels, along with a very clearly defined copyright model.

People uploading photos to sites like twitpic and others generally do so without bothering to read the fineprint with regards to publication rights. As someone posted above, while the photographer may retain the copyright, they do surrender exclusivity and control with regards to publication of those images (and this is the same with many sites - from twitpic to Facebook to others).

BBC are simply using this to their advantage. There is no fundamental misunderstanding of copyright on their side here at all; on the contrary, their actions are completely in line, legally. If you don't want people using your images without your permission, don't upload them to sites like twitpic. Simples.
 
Last edited:
You were certainly correct in your first point, I was putting an intentional twist on things. I also accept the points that you make in the rest of your response simply because I know no different.

But I do know that companies cannot impose T's & C's that are at odds with common law and I would guess (I don't know for sure) that an organisation could not impose terms that gives them ownership of, or the right to use your property, simply because you sign up to their service.
 
No-one is claiming ownership though. But the right to publish is commonly found throughout the media world, and does not contravene common law.

For example, I work in the film industry. To find new jobs, I need to create a portfolio of work that I've done on films over the years. I don't own this content, as it remains the property of the film studio, whether it's Universal, or New Line, or whomever, but I do have the right to distribute and publish that work in order to promote myself. Imagine if I didn't have that right - I'd never be able to demonstrate my work to anyone.

This issue with twitpics and other sites works along a similar line. They don't (and cannot) claim ownership of your images, but by using their service to host and display your work, you do give them publishing rights, and this is very clearly stipulated in the user agreement which you agree to upon signing up for an account. The problem is that people just click the Agree button without bother to read and/or understand what they're agreeing to.
 
I agree that the BBC, or whoever, can use the picture but I feel that they should credit the photographer, be that by their twitter name or proper name. That is all that Andy Mabbett was asking for, to be credited.
 
They might be able to use under the Twitpic T&Cs but they would have to credit Twitpic unless they have some special agreement. But leaving that aside the BBCs public domain argument doesn't stand up - this is from the copyright service top 10 myths page here:
http://www.copyrightservice.co.uk/copyright/copyright_myths

4. Everything on the Internet ‘public domain’ and free to use

This highlights a common misunderstanding about what is meant by ‘public domain’ when referring to copyright work.
A work will fall into the public domain once copyright expires, this will typically be many years after the author’s death.
While work published on the Internet may be publicly accessible, it is certainly not in the public domain.

I imagine the reply from the beeb was made up on the spot rather than being supplied by an in-house copyright expert.
 
I imagine the reply from the beeb was made up on the spot rather than being supplied by an in-house copyright expert.

I'm not sure. Having known someone who worked in the BBC and knew their complaint response procedure very well, I would not be surprised if they did actually check with a lawyer before responding. But since the person actually writing the reply was not a lawyer, it's possible they may have explained it incorrectly.

Using Twitpic does seem to give them publishing rights. Even still, the BBC should be crediting the Twitter users that they are getting the photos from. I would doubt that the BBC had a special agreement with Twitpic, although it's not impossible. I suspect the BBC is working here on the principle that since they're using the photos taken by amateur photographers, it's okay. Which, it isn't, of course. Maybe I'm being unfair on them.

I think they were legally entitled to show the images, but should have shown some sort of credit, at the very least, to the Twitter user who tweeted the images.
 
Sounds like the public domain bit may well be incorrect. As it usually is when people cite it as a defence. They would be OK to use them if they were hosted on Twitpic though, as has been well publicised lately, they do have a pretty shocking set of T&Cs.

Of course not every picture linked through Twitter is hosted on Twitpic.
 
To me the problem seems to be that people don't read the T&C's fully before uploading pictures.

Reminds me of a story a while ago where a computer game retailer (I think it was Game, though I'm not 100%) put something in their T&C's for customers purchasing on line stating that by agreeing to the sale the customer transferred to Game the ownership of their soul!!

Not one customer apparently noticed.

Now the ownership of the soul was not serious (obviously!) but it was done to highlight the fact that no-one appeared to actually read the T&C's

I must admit its not something I do either - but through this site I am aware of the issues of uploading to sites like Facebook and Twitter and the problems it can bring!

Neil
 
The BBC have used copyrighted material without consent. That's the argument, which I don't think the have any right to. If they have a deal with whoever hosted the images is one thing, depending on the terms and conditions with the host company, then the copyright owner may have surrendered certain rights. But there was no mention of that from the BBC. :shrug: We have had threads on here about Newspapers using images sourced from the internet when they have known that they shouldn't, but then pay buttons if they are caught. The BBC aren't even admitting they have done anything wrong, and by the sound of it, not even 'buttons' will be forthcoming. They have done wrong

And just because you have a picture online, be it a photo hosting site or social network, it does not make it available to be freely copied and used (unless in this case, you sign the pics over to be Public Domain and copyright free in the Twitter T&C, though I think at least one person would have noticed if that was the case ;)). If the shoe was on the other foot and someone was using BBC copyrighted content from their website, I doubt they would have the same point of view. I mean their site 'is available to most people who have a computer'. :shrug:

Being a social network site does not change copyright law as far as I'm aware.
 
The BBC have used copyrighted material without consent. That's the argument, which I don't think the have any right to. If they have a deal with whoever hosted the images is one thing, depending on the terms and conditions with the host company, then the copyright owner may have surrendered certain rights. But there was no mention of that from the BBC.

But that's nevertheless the case. Read the twitpic user agreement posted earlier in the thread.

And just because you have a picture online, be it a photo hosting site or social network, it does not make it available to be freely copied and used (unless in this case, you sign the pics over to be Public Domain and copyright free in the Twitter T&C, though I think at least one person would have noticed if that was the case ;)).

Again, read the user agreement above.

Honestly, it astounds me how people just click Agree, Agree, Agree to all these sites without bothering to read what they're actually agreeing to, and then they moan when stuff is done which is absolutely in accordance to the agreement they made.

If you don't want people using your stuff, host it on your own personal website.
 
The problem I see, is how often in these instances do the tweeters own the copyright to give away? In cases like the riots and the like, you have many people capturing images, and they'll post to Facebook, forums, blogs, their own website or whatever. Someone will then come across that image, and before you know 20 different people have popped it up on Twitter. None of which own copyright.

In which case, should the BBC make some effort to contact the copyright holder of that image?

Would their opinion be the same if I took one of their programmes from YouTube and broadcast it on my own TV station?
 
But that's nevertheless the case. Read the twitpic user agreement posted earlier in the thread.

Again, read the user agreement above.

Honestly, it astounds me how people just click Agree, Agree, Agree to all these sites without bothering to read what they're actually agreeing to, and then they moan when stuff is done which is absolutely in accordance to the agreement they made.

OK then did the BBC get permission to publish the pics? Because according to that agreement they
are required to obtain permission from Twitpic in advance of said usage and attribute credit to Twitpic as the source where you have obtained the content.
. You don't get the impression from their letter of reply that they did. :shrug: All they would have to have said 'we got permission off Twitter', that they didn't and instead talk of images being
in the public domain
would lead me to think they are not playing within, or indeed understanding, the rules. :shrug:


And I agree that people should read any agreements they sign, but for a lot of the time the language used is not clear (some say deliberately), and they are very long. It normally takes someone with a bit of legal knowledge/experience to point out problems.
 
OK then did the BBC get permission to publish the pics? Because according to that agreement they . You don't get the impression from their letter of reply that they did. :shrug:

I don't get the impression that they didn't. The overall impression I get of the letter is that it's written by someone in their complaints department who isn't actually familiar with the intricacies of the laws at play here.

I would be very, very surprised indeed if the BBC just randomly took images off the internet to use in their stories. They'll have a huge legal team who provides guidelines for them to abide by.
 
Twitter now has it's own "add photo" feature.

Take a look at the terms:
http://BANNED/tos

You retain your rights to any Content you submit, post or display on or through the Services. By submitting, posting or displaying Content on or through the Services, you grant us a worldwide, non-exclusive, royalty-free license (with the right to sublicense) to use, copy, reproduce, process, adapt, modify, publish, transmit, display and distribute such Content in any and all media or distribution methods (now known or later developed).
 
Like the MPs had guidelines for expenses? Guidelines didn't stop them abusing the system.
 
If Twitter is like sites like faceache, flickr and airliners.net, then there's no point in quoting common law, or the UK copyright acts.
The applicable law is that of the USA.
The BBC aren't daft, but are tight fisted. They wouldn't be leaving themselves open to proceedings, which because they would have to happen in the USA, would be silly money, without being reasonably sure of their ground. Thats why they employ lawyers. Those lawyers are very good with copyright, an example was the failed attempt by the Met police to sue over use of the Tardis in Dr Who.
 
The photographer owns copyright, except when:

a) you never owned it in the first place,
b) it's been assigned to somebody else,
c) you can't control it

In relation to c)...

<snip>

If you don't want people using your stuff, host it on your own personal website.

I don't know why people keep complaining about stuff being lifted from public websites. Of course this happens. Most people don't understand copyright, don't give a damn anyway, and if you explained the current legal position to them, they would say it was a bit daft, contrary to common sense and natural justice a lot of the time, and just plain impractical.

When you go out, you lock your house, right? Putting stuff up in the public domain is like going on holiday and not just leaving the house wide open, but putting your valuables out on the front lawn with a big notice saying come and have a look. Only a fool would expect to find everything in place when they got home.

This is just how it is on the 'free' web, get used to it. Making a fuss about it is like that old proverb invloving a runaway horse and a stable door.
 
I can't believe this is still on going. Twit pics terms of service say that for using their service you grant them the right to distribute to their partners, one of which recently signed in may was wenn who distribute news pictures. One of the image partners the BBC use.

Did you really think you'd get something for nothing? Someone has to pay for those services and the users have signed to say they allow it to be done that way.
 
BBC have distanced themselves from the initial response to the complaint, so it looks like it's nothing to do with Twitpic or Twitter's T&Cs.

http://www.amateurphotographer.co.u...over_Twitter_pics_update_7pm_news_309149.html

AP said:
The issue has since prompted a response from BBC News Social Media Editor Chris Hamilton who suggests that the email Mabbett received was not the BBC's official line.

'We're checking out the complaint response quoted but, on the face of it, it's wrong and isn't the position of BBC News,' commented Hamilton in a blog posting dated 13 August.

'In fact, we make every effort to contact people, as copyright holders, who've taken photos we want to use in our coverage,' added Hamilton who confirmed to Amateur Photographer (AP) the remarks he had made on the photographer's website.
 
So the BBC admit they did wrong, sort of, and the chap who replied was wrong. ;)

While they say they 'may' use a photo without permission and attribution in the future, there is no mention of payment or rectifying the attribution situation when time is no longer a problem. :shrug:

From the replies in the link Almost_Invisible posted, it seems that the situation of getting pics like this may not be an unusual thing for BBC reporters to do. Probably because some of them are of the same mind and and mistaken belief that pics on the internet are "not subject to the same copyright laws as it is already in the public domain".
 
Back
Top