The Digital Economy Bill - Your Voice Being Heard

Messages
559
Edit My Images
No
Actual photo:

debill.png
 
Fantastic, my tax-pounds hard at work as always...
 
Got kicked out though didn't it?

Will need to be re-heard when Parliament reforms ...
 
Looking at that pic, makes me think Parliament shouldn't be allowed to discuss anything at all without a quorum of say 33% of the members of each of the main parties.

With an election coming up, perhaps we should be looking at our local MP's attendance record!

Jean

I agree entirely with that. They earn enough - they should debate every single law passed, and earn their money.
 
How can 16 people decide the fate of millions?
 
How can 16 people decide the fate of millions?

On any three line whip bill which is not going to be close a system known as "pairing" operates where an MP from the governing party and one from an opposition pary are "paired" and they both don't vote at a particular division thereby cancelling out the effect of each other.

Believe it or not, ordinary MPs spend quite a lot of time chasing after various ministers on behalf of their constituents and in meetings while they are in Westminister rather than in the chamber of the house during debates and only come in to vote, I thought this was common knowledge.

The commons is not the place where legislation gets revised, it tends to happen in the Lords which since the members are there for life and so aren't at risk of deselection by their parties they tend to be more willing to vote against their party and amend government bills. Whether or not the commons accepts ammendments from the Lords is another matter of course.
 
Was the bill passed?
Makes a mockery of our government and the publics choices, doesn't it?

On a random note, it adds fuel to the fire for inetrnet trolls on forums such as parenting and pregnancy forums, where it is sadly, a common occurance, for trolls to use pictures of random children and scan images and pass them off as their own, if the bill was passed.
 
Bill was slatted for for Committee stage and Report stage today. It then has two further stages before receiving Royal Assent.

Not sure if it will get through on the "Wash up" prior to dissolution.
 
According to the Guardian it will be voted on tonight around 10.35 pm
 
On any three line whip bill which is not going to be close a system known as "pairing" operates where an MP from the governing party and one from an opposition pary are "paired" and they both don't vote at a particular division thereby cancelling out the effect of each other.

Believe it or not, ordinary MPs spend quite a lot of time chasing after various ministers on behalf of their constituents and in meetings while they are in Westminister rather than in the chamber of the house during debates and only come in to vote, I thought this was common knowledge.

The commons is not the place where legislation gets revised, it tends to happen in the Lords which since the members are there for life and so aren't at risk of deselection by their parties they tend to be more willing to vote against their party and amend government bills. Whether or not the commons accepts ammendments from the Lords is another matter of course.

I take your point, but if you've listened to, and/or taken part in the debate where pros and cons are aired, you might be in a better position to cast your vote sensibly, unless of course, you're not allowed to vote across party lines, which is, I presume, what happens when there's a 3-line whip. :)

Jean
 
I take your point, but if you've listened to, and/or taken part in the debate where pros and cons are aired, you might be in a better position to cast your vote sensibly, unless of course, you're not allowed to vote across party lines, which is, I presume, what happens when there's a 3-line whip. :)

Jean

In principle I agree, listen to the arguments and decide, however this is not a parliament of independents ...

For a 3 line whip, vote against your party and your chances of getting even a very junior government post in future are drastically reduced as the party leader is unlikely to promote you - backbench MPs in the main parties are basically lobby fodder and vote as they are told.

Now there is a certain amount of justification for this, if they have stood for election as a representative of a party and a particular piece of legislation is included in the party manifestio (which always forms part of the individual candidate's manifesto) then for them to vote against that legislation is to go against what they stated they would do when they asked people to vote for them. They would have a very hard time justifying that to their electorate and their constituency association.

Bizarrely, this is why the house of Lords in its current form works as a revising chamber, they are not afraid to vote against their parties and will amend what they consider bad legislation.
 
This is absolutely brilliant news!

it is regarding clause 43. ;-)

The rest of the bill should of been dropped though. It always worries me when you have a politician saying ' no, we'd never use it like that' about clauses. If you don't want to use a bill badly write it well in the first place...simples
 
From the stop43.org group on facebook and released yesterday:

We have spent this afternoon biting our nails hoping that the news that the Labour and Conservatives had agreed to drop Clause 43 was actually going to happen. It was by no means a forgone conclusion. Indeed the LibDems could still have scuppered it. We sat on the news and didn’t pre-empt the outcome which has just been confirmed. A huge thank you for the messages of support during this campaign, but above all for all your tireless efforts writing, emailing, Facebooking and Twittering your MPs. It is these efforts, above everything else, that have achieved this.

It’s been hard work but also an honour to have been part of so much unified support.

Today, I can say I am proud to be a UK photographer. Today we achieved something memorable and outstanding for our future rights and the representation of photographers in the UK.... See more

Well done and congratulations to everyone and your efforts. The number of people who ran this campaign was small and I came to the party later than the rest, organising the Facebook group. However, I have constantly been impressed by the integrity, sense of duty and knowledge by all involved.

WE WON!!!


Regards

Chris
 
It was good to see clause 43 was binned, but the whole DE Bill was a complete and utter joke. Thats the worst, misguided, uninformed construction of UK law I've ever seen and a perfect example of the will of the people being trampled all over by big business using their cheque books to buy government favours.

Disgusting.

Worse still was that it was quite apparent that it wasn't something you could blame one party for, they were all there noses in the trough stupidly hoovering up the pound notes.

At least its narrowed down the decision of who to vote for... "none of the above" sounds like a winner to me.
 
Worse still was that it was quite apparent that it wasn't something you could blame one party for, they were all there noses in the trough stupidly hoovering up the pound notes.

At least its narrowed down the decision of who to vote for... "none of the above" sounds like a winner to me.
The Lib Dems as they were against it but had no ability to affect the back-room stitch up between the other two which meant it could be effectively waved it through with only a few decent MP's voicing their dissent against the whips.

The 'wash-up' process for legislation is disgusting. This bill flawed and dangerous.

Edit - I'm not the only one calling it a stich-up! - Anger about digital stitch-up - BBC News
 
I've just had a response from my MP, John Grogan;

John Grogan said:
Thank you very much for your email regarding the Digital Economy Bill.

I very much shared your position and did my best with others to raise the issue in the House. I attach the proceedings from the Second Reading on Tuesday -

http://www.publications.parliament....100406/debtext/100406-0018.htm#10040641000097

The subsequent stages which were taken last night. This is available from the Parliamentary website here:
http://www.publications.parliament....100407/debtext/100407-0027.htm#10040767000196

At the time of writing the Lords are yet to consider the Government and Conservative amendment which lays down rules for website blocking. I am afraid the best that we can hope for now is that this new clause is resisted in the Lords later tonight and has to be dropped. Here's hoping for this success at least.

Once again, thanks for getting in touch.

Yours Sincerely,

What a shame he isn't re-standing at this election... He's done quite a bit for my wife and I. There are some decent MP's left!
 
I've just had a response from my MP, John Grogan;



What a shame he isn't re-standing at this election... He's done quite a bit for my wife and I. There are some decent MP's left!

At least you got a reply!! All I got from my MP Ronnie Campbell, Blyth (and what a job I had trcking his email address down) was an automated reply saying the House Of commons had recieved it. Mind - I doubt Ronnie would have understood the bill to be honest!!
 
Well thank goodness they got it through in the end. I was feeling very vulnerable and now I am protected.

Not really!

You're only as protected as you were last week. What could have happened is that you became hardly protected at all!

s43 could have meant that copyright became virtually meaningless.

The general concensus is that the whole subject of copyright will be looked at again early in the next parliament - especially if the T****s get in.

Not that I'm being rude. It was because the Tories came out aginst s43 that it got no further.

Now, hopefully, the idea that copyright is a good thing has been re-inforced in MP's minds.
 
Not really!

You're only as protected as you were last week. What could have happened is that you became hardly protected at all!

s43 could have meant that copyright became virtually meaningless.

The general concensus is that the whole subject of copyright will be looked at again early in the next parliament - especially if the T****s get in.

Not that I'm being rude. It was because the Tories came out aginst s43 that it got no further.

Now, hopefully, the idea that copyright is a good thing has been re-inforced in MP's minds.


I think you may have missed the sarcasm in Myky D's post. :)
 
One thing that struck me from seeing parts of the debate on the Tuesday evening was how important they felt copyright, intellectual property and the creative industries were.

Other than when it concerns photography, that is.

Hopefully it will have been drummed into politicians' minds that photographers are also creatives, and their intellectual property deserves protection as well.

I hope you don't mind me repeating myself, but ther people behind stop43.org put in a massive amount of unpaid time to make sure s43 didn't go through.
 
Probably the best thing you can do currently is that if anyone wants to ask you about voting for them is to beat them over the head with this debacle - Labs or Tories!

The next few weeks is when the buggers will actually listen to you, so give them hell!
 
Probably the best thing you can do currently is that if anyone wants to ask you about voting for them is to beat them over the head with this debacle - Labs or Tories!

The next few weeks is when the buggers will actually listen to you, so give them hell!

My guess is that many MP's and most prospective MP's will never have heard of Orphan Works or Section 43.

The truth is, until a few weeks ago, I hadn't either, and if I hadn't been on another email list I may still not have done.
 
At least you got a reply!! All I got from my MP Ronnie Campbell, Blyth (and what a job I had trcking his email address down) was an automated reply saying the House Of commons had recieved it. Mind - I doubt Ronnie would have understood the bill to be honest!!


As I understand it if sent to the correct email or postal address your MP has a legal duty to reply with a non-automated response.

My MP wrote back to me explaining that may other constituents had been in touch with him and he'd contacted Mandelson over the matter, he enclosed a photocopy of the letter he sent to Mandleson.
 
I got this pinged to me by a friend...

Is this still up to date and current?

First Paragraph:-

The end game is now in sight. The Digital Economy Bill is now expected to become law within the next 6 weeks. It introduces orphan works usage rights, which - unless amended, which HMG says it will not - will allow the commercial use of any photograph whose author cannot be identified through a suitably negligent search. That is potentially about 90% of the photos on the internet.

The Digital Economy Bill

Cheers
MIP
 
No, a bit out of date that...
 
Back
Top