The importance of filters...

Messages
277
Name
Jonty
Edit My Images
Yes
I had a terrible incident last night, where my camera dropped a foot onto the floor...

I looked and to my horror there was a monster crack on the end of the camera lens. My horror quickly turned to relief, when I found it was simply the UV filter that had taken the "crunch" rather than the actual lens.

So I need to buy a new one, but I am so grateful I just need to buy that one, rather than a new lens! I'll get a picture up to show you, but a useful reminder to all people to invest in filters to protect their lenses :)
 
I think you will find the drop will probably cause damage to the internals. Calibration getting knocked off etc.
 
front filters in uv or warm up as you found out can be cleaned and or replaced easily

i used to always use them but the digicams i have now need adaptors...which i wont buy

so i take the chance on having to replace the cams....only around 80 each
 
Hmm I suspect if the drop would have been hard enough to break the lens glass it would have regardless of whether a filter was attached or not. The filter broke because it is thin and more fragile than the front element methinks.
Hopefully the drop has not caused any internal damage :thumbs:
 
Gotta agree that if the front element of a lens is going to break, it is regardless of having a UV filter fitted or not if dropped from the "right" height. I've only had bad experiences with them so far and would only use one if there was lots of flying debris in the air. e.g. the beach?

Also I've heard a couple of stories of people saying when the same thing has happened to them, the little fragments of glass from the filter have actually scratched the front element of their lens. Bit too much trouble that they're worth imo. But, I realise for some people they need the "peace of mind" that they provide.

Tom N.
 
Well done Jonty, the filter did protect your lens as you say. It is a tough piece of glass and helped save the day. Just hope your internals are OK as well, which nothing can protect from shock of course.

Best regards

Chris
 
Well done Jonty, the filter did protect your lens as you say. It is a tough piece of glass and helped save the day. Just hope your internals are OK as well, which nothing can protect from shock of course.

Best regards

Chris
A lens hood would have prevented this, so jonty, put your lens hood on a become a photographer!!!!
 
Hi Steve,

I think we will have to disagree on that point. My filters are considerably tougher than a lens hood.

Best regards

Chrsi
 
Hi Steve,

I think we will have to disagree on that point. My filters are considerably tougher than a lens hood.

Best regards

Chrsi

Hmmm. I'd argue against that. A thick, toughened plastic hood is much stronger than thin glass surrounded by a thin rim of plastic.

Lens hoods are far tougher.

As some have said, it looks quite lucky. If a knock is hard enough to crack the front element, it will happen regardless of whether it has a filter attached as the shock travels down the lens barrel and its this that normally does the damage. Its rare that debris actually shatters a front element, 9 times out of 10 its the pure force of impact. Hoods are designed to absorb some of the shock, filters aren't.

This pretty much sums it up, from LensRentals;

http://www.photoimagesystems.com/imagemedic/library/files/The Myth of the UV Filter.pdf
 
Hi Jim,

A convincing argument for non use of filters. It is of course just one view, but nonetheless interesting.

I am obviously still not convinced but always interested in others views, so many thanks for putting the link up.

For me I have to use filters anyway as I use the Lee filter system which have an adaptor so you cannot get a hood on.

Best regards

Chris
 
I'd have to agree - that a hood and filter is the best insurance - I tried it out myself by falling into a six-foot ditch and landed on top of both cameras I was carrying.
Both hit lens-down and were propelled into the mud by the weight of me landing on top of them.
Both lens hoods were cracked and pushed up the lens barrels by the impact. On both lenses, the filters were scratched and pitted by the mud. I'd like to think that had the lens hoods not been there the damage would have been far worse. Had the filters not been there either, both lenses would have been written off... £3k's worth...

An impact onto a solid surface hard enough to break a filter, unless it was because of a direct impact on the glass itself, might indeed cause damage to the lens via transmitted shock, unless the impact was on the edge of the filter-ring and the resulting shock travelled across the filter causing the glass to crack.

Either way, glass UV/protection filters and lens hoods are primarily there to shield the lens from extraneous light and small surface damage; that they also add a measure of impact protection is a bonus as far as I'm concerned.
 
It's very much personal choice with "protection filters". Personally I started out using them but now prefer not to risk the possibility of any detrimental IQ effects.
I've also heard of a couple of incidents where lenses have had slight knocks which have cracked the filter which then scoured the lens :shrug:

Glad to see your lens is safe !!

Simon
 
OOps, I've not re-read this thread since I posted, and the good wife threw the broken filter away :( other pictures are coming out nice and sharp, so fingers crossed nothing too serious... appreciate all your support and advice - I think a hood may have to be used in the future, although I don't like them as they make you look like you're showing off the length of your "tool" for want of a better phrase :)
 
I think a hood may have to be used in the future, although I don't like them as they make you look like you're showing off the length of your "tool" for want of a better phrase :)

And for those of us that don't have big un's, they make what you do have look a little bigger, nothing wrong with that is there? :suspect:
 
Back
Top