The Philisolophy Of Photographying

Messages
559
Edit My Images
No
So how many of you now take pictures thinking "I'll sort it out when I get home in Photoshop"?

I'm thinking of the kind of thoughts "I know that sky's bad - I'll bring it right out when I get home/The colours haven't come out quite how I liked, but I'll up the saturation on them" etc.
 
And how is it now any different to what the darkroom guys used to, and for many still, do ???

Much of what Photoshop et al do is mimic the techniques used in the darkroom - they even copied the same names of those techniques

So yes, sometimes you do have to apply vision to see what can be achieved later if you can't capture it at the time - it has always been so

DD
 
Even the best shot can be improved with a little tickle or a light cloning in PS!
 
And how is it now any different to what the darkroom guys used to, and for many still, do ???

Much of what Photoshop et al do is mimic the techniques used in the darkroom - they even copied the same names of those techniques

So yes, sometimes you do have to apply vision to see what can be achieved later if you can't capture it at the time - it has always been so

DD

No need to be defensive - I'm just interested. I took a pic today and know I'm going to have to replace the sky.

But then again - I see Photoshop as a means to being able to appear skillful in lieu of having any actual talent.
 
No need to be defensive - I'm just interested. I took a pic today and know I'm going to have to replace the sky.

But then again - I see Photoshop as a means to being able to appear skillful in lieu of having any actual talent.

Not being defensive m8 - just asked what I thought was a pertinent and simple question to make a point

Many newbies (no idea if you're one) have only experienced Photoshop and hence think PP is somehow new and amazing - but it's not

It is easier now though, and can be done anywhere rather than a smelly old room in the dark

What I was trying to say was - we have all had times, whether in film or digital, where PP can help make the shot. The skill is in realising what's needed and how to shoot then PP it :)

DD
 
I do as much at the time of shutter release and then improve with post processing. Can't think the last time I did not post process... but I am from the old school where film cost money so tend to take very few photo's in a session, all of which have had a time and thought put into them.
 
I go in with a view to getting as much right as I can on Camera.

Shooting RAW I am bound to use PS a little in the conversion but I try to do as little as possible. Mainly because I find it boring compared to being out with the Camera!

That said if it needs doing to acheive what I'm after I'll do it.

I guess it depends what look your after and also what light/effects are available at the time of shooting. :shrug:

At the end of the day, your philosophy is likely to change depending on your shoot and circumstances I would imagine.

I struggle with the argument that "PS-ing" is not photography, as DD said, what were dark rooms used for? Post Processing and developing.
At the end of they day, IMO, if a camera was used to take the origional image, surely its photography?! :shrug:

Just my thoughts at the end of the day, I'm sure we all have varying opinions.
 
And how is it now any different to what the darkroom guys used to, and for many still, do ???

Whilst a lot of the techniques are similar, there are two major differences:

1. Photoshop allows processing to be done to a greater extent than the darkroom does. Unfortunately, it is often overdone.

2. It is much more accessable now so a lot of people don't think about their shots enough at the taking time thinking that they can just sort it out later.

Twenty years ago, the majority of films were sent out for processing and printing and the prints were returned with no post processing. Now the majority of people do some post processing on their own images.

Obviously there are exceptions to all of these observations.


Steve.
 
true in some respects but you can still do a shed load in photoshop lol

And how is it now any different to what the darkroom guys used to, and for many still, do ???

Much of what Photoshop et al do is mimic the techniques used in the darkroom - they even copied the same names of those techniques

So yes, sometimes you do have to apply vision to see what can be achieved later if you can't capture it at the time - it has always been so

DD
 
Not being defensive m8 - just asked what I thought was a pertinent and simple question to make a point

Many newbies (no idea if you're one) have only experienced Photoshop and hence think PP is somehow new and amazing - but it's not

It is easier now though, and can be done anywhere rather than a smelly old room in the dark

What I was trying to say was - we have all had times, whether in film or digital, where PP can help make the shot. The skill is in realising what's needed and how to shoot then PP it :)

DD

Oh yeah.

I have the battle with my father all the time.

His take is that he's got 30 years experience on me, and he's got to the location in time, in the right conditions, with the right gear, on the right settings, and finally got the image he's been waiting years to capture.

I can turn up there with my pnc and get it in 5 minutes with PS.

HOWEVER

Hahahaha

He's got one pic on his wall that his mate did, and it's a lovely pic of a tree in autumn - beautiful red leaves against lush green background grass and bushes. He said "I'm not happy about that. Apparently she played about with it in Photoshop. So I don't approve. Having said that, I'd be quite happy to get the same effect using several filters."

Hahaha
 
So how many of you now take pictures thinking "I'll sort it out when I get home in Photoshop"?

I'm thinking of the kind of thoughts "I know that sky's bad - I'll bring it right out when I get home/The colours haven't come out quite how I liked, but I'll up the saturation on them" etc.

For me it's only 'The last resort'.

I began contemplating this when a situation occasionally reoccurred while working for the same client, and left me feeling a similar way each time....

Miserable and upset.

"We need the absolute best, no question, no doubt, the apex of excellence without the sniff of imperfection......You have 2 minutes', GO!"

I simply could not do what I needed to get the job done in my usual and thorough manner, the manner that I owe all the wonderful opportunities I have experienced so far.

Not a nice situation to be in with a respected and valued client.

Gentle and logical advice got me nowhere and in most cases deviations to the schedule were deemed impossible.

Enter, 'I'm going to have to fix that in photoshop'.
(For my own personal projects or for those moments where I wish to employ unreality and use my imagination, then photoshop turns into a playground festooned with brushes and paints. :D)

Anyway, the clients who want the world in a gap that contests the speed of light, continue to hire me, I get such nice compliments and recommendations but despite my protests that they could have an even better result if they could just allow more time, they will not deviate.

They are happy and while I feel grateful, I also feel uncomfortable.
 
"Twenty years ago, the majority of films were sent out for processing and printing and the prints were returned with no post processing."

Sorry, but the printing machines did/do automatic post processing of exposure... quite annoying sometimes.

If you send digital images off for printing now the machines still perform post processing in the form of exposure adjustments and sharpening etc...
 
I referred to 'darkroom guys' to mean those capable of manipulating their own images in their darkroom - not the greater population that posted them all away

The OP seemed to me to be asking about a problem with a flat, boring sky and lack of saturation - both of which are easily done in a darkroom. There aren't a great many PP techniques I use that a good 'wet' guy couldn't do as I try to keep images looking something like reality (most of the time ;))

But I agree PP on a computer is far easier, more accessible and largely less skilled too - though knowing what & when to apply something is a skill in itself - as is when not to

DD
 
But I agree PP on a computer is far easier, more accessible and largely less skilled too - though knowing what & when to apply something is a skill in itself - as is when not to
DD

Easier in terms of the absence of chemicals maybe, less skilled? Maybe the basics, but advanced post production :nono:
 
I referred to 'darkroom guys' to mean those capable of manipulating their own images in their darkroom - not the greater population that posted them all away

I appreciate that, but the percentage of photographers who consider themselves to be proficient to do their own post processing (whether they are or not) is much larger now than the percentage of film photographers who did their own processing and printing when film was the only option.



Steve.
 
But then again - I see Photoshop as a means to being able to appear skillful in lieu of having any actual talent.

Let's be clear Myky - you appear to have a bee in your bonnet about anyone who uses post processing to improve their images. Even though everyone from Louis Daguerre and William Fox Talbot to (insert your favourite photographer here) has used some form of post processing to achieve the best results.

Yes getting things right in camera will make your life so much easier and we should all take the time to learn that particular craft. But this backlash against photoshop is just silly.

If you went to a restaurant would you rather the chef slop your food on the plate or arrange it in an attractive fashion? It would taste the same - but the presentation (the post-processing) is part of the art of cooking.

What matters above all else is, have you created an image that is interesting or beautiful? Does it capture your imagination when you look at it. To be annoyed because none photographers can't tell the difference between something shot in camera and something that is heavily photoshopped is pointless.

The end result is what matters - everything else is just shop-talk.
 
Let's be clear Myky - you appear to have a bee in your bonnet about anyone who uses post processing to improve their images. Even though everyone from Louis Daguerre and William Fox Talbot to (insert your favourite photographer here) has used some form of post processing to achieve the best results.

Yes getting things right in camera will make your life so much easier and we should all take the time to learn that particular craft. But this backlash against photoshop is just silly.

If you went to a restaurant would you rather the chef slop your food on the plate or arrange it in an attractive fashion? It would taste the same - but the presentation (the post-processing) is part of the art of cooking.

What matters above all else is, have you created an image that is interesting or beautiful? Does it capture your imagination when you look at it. To be annoyed because none photographers can't tell the difference between something shot in camera and something that is heavily photoshopped is pointless.

The end result is what matters - everything else is just shop-talk.

Erm ... please, boss - if you're going to make accusations about me, do your research first. Have you actually seen the work I do?

You may wish to visit my Flickr account before you apologise wholeheartedly and completely retract that.

Thanks awfully.
 
Erm ... please, boss - if you're going to make accusations about me, do your research first. Have you actually seen the work I do?
You may wish to visit my Flickr account before you apologise wholeheartedly and completely retract that.

Nope - sorry but you stated that "I see Photoshop as a means to being able to appear skillful in lieu of having any actual talent."

So I stand by my comments as I am not judging your work - just discussing your argument which appears to be somewhat in contradiction to your images on flickr.

So to clarify... are you saying that you photoshopped some of your images to compensate for a lack of talent?

Don't misunderstand this as a personal attack - I know nothing about you and quite liked some of your images (in particular some of the Graphic Novel set and also "Central") but if you're going to throw out controversial comments like the one I referenced above - you have to stand behind your argument - not side-step it by saying that you actually use a lot of photoshop!

So no apology necessary from me - but feel free to clarify your comments if it will help with the debate
 
I took a pic today and know I'm going to have to replace the sky.

I have to say that this is something that I personally would never consider. If the sky isn't right, I will try and make the most of what was available with some dodging and burning, but to actually replace a whole sky isn't really what photography is about for me.
 
Well what do you understand by the sentence "I see Photoshop as a means to being able to appear skillful in lieu of having any actual talent."?

I understand it to mean that people with no actual talent at photography can use photoshop on their mediocre images to make them appear to be skillful photographers.

I doubt I'm alone in coming to that conclusion - so I guess the real question is... what do YOU understand it to mean?
 
I understand it to mean that people with no actual talent at photography can use photoshop on their mediocre images to make them appear to be skillful photographers.

I doubt I'm alone in coming to that conclusion - so I guess the real question is... what do YOU understand it to mean?

Ah. Clearly we have a reading comprehension issue.

Let's start with the first person - "I".

Do you want to try it again?

"I see Photoshop as a means to being able to appear skillful in lieu of having any actual talent."

No - actually - if I go on like this all the sensitive types will report me to the moderators again - Nigel - now that you've had a look at my images, and seen how much I use Photoshop - which is clearly an awful lot, how can you come to the conclusion that I have any "bee in my bonnet" or am riding a "backlash against" Photoshop?! Really?!

I'd honestly be interested to know.
 
Quick response as it's the end of lunchtime for me and they don't really pay me to spend all day on this forum (shame really)

I'm afraid I don't understand your distinction and whilst I'm more than happy to discuss photography all day long - I won't waste my time over semantics.

So this debate will have to be continued by others - have fun.
 
Quick response as it's the end of lunchtime for me and they don't really pay me to spend all day on this forum (shame really)

I'm afraid I don't understand your distinction and whilst I'm more than happy to discuss photography all day long - I won't waste my time over semantics.

So this debate will have to be continued by others - have fun.

OK. Thanks for playing.
 
Twenty years ago, the majority of films were sent out for processing and printing and the prints were returned with no post processing. Now the majority of people do some post processing on their own images.

I'd be prepared to bet lots of money on that statment not being true, 99% of the digital pictures taken today are either on p&s or mobile phones 99% of which will never be post processed.

Back on topic, this discussion comes up once a month on here some people are convinced that photoshop makes it easier which make togs lazier and others just say it's a tool to use. Personally I couldn't care what camera and filters you used or how much post processing you did it's the image that counts and if I like it I like it if I don't I don't.
 
I'd be prepared to bet lots of money on that statment not being true, 99% of the digital pictures taken today are either on p&s or mobile phones 99% of which will never be post processed.

Back on topic, this discussion comes up once a month on here some people are convinced that photoshop makes it easier which make togs lazier and others just say it's a tool to use. Personally I couldn't care what camera and filters you used or how much post processing you did it's the image that counts and if I like it I like it if I don't I don't.


Hahahaha HEAR HEAR!

"Photoshop muddy funster - DO YOU SPEAK IT?!"
 
Most of the time you can "fix it in post" but its so much easier to get it right the in camera than messing about in photoshop. In video there is a saying "we can fix it in post, but it'll cost you!"
 
Back
Top