This stems from a discussion on another forum regarding the usefulness of image stabilisation technologies to panning; primarily motorsport.
I'm aware that some forms of IS don't take kindly to panning, so please assume that we're talking about "panning friendly" varieties.
One party reckons that IS would be a boon to the panning photographer on account of the low shutter speeds required (usually with a tele lens) to get suitable background motion blur.
The other thinks that whilst it might offer a small benefit, successful shots are more down to technique, that panned shots are less susceptable to vertical oscillation than static ones, and that IS is of more use when subjects are very slow moving or static.
Would anyone with any experience of this type of photography with such lenses care to comment?
I'm aware that some forms of IS don't take kindly to panning, so please assume that we're talking about "panning friendly" varieties.
One party reckons that IS would be a boon to the panning photographer on account of the low shutter speeds required (usually with a tele lens) to get suitable background motion blur.
The other thinks that whilst it might offer a small benefit, successful shots are more down to technique, that panned shots are less susceptable to vertical oscillation than static ones, and that IS is of more use when subjects are very slow moving or static.
Would anyone with any experience of this type of photography with such lenses care to comment?