The value of IS/VR to panning shots

tbm

Messages
459
Name
Mike
Edit My Images
Yes
This stems from a discussion on another forum regarding the usefulness of image stabilisation technologies to panning; primarily motorsport.

I'm aware that some forms of IS don't take kindly to panning, so please assume that we're talking about "panning friendly" varieties.

One party reckons that IS would be a boon to the panning photographer on account of the low shutter speeds required (usually with a tele lens) to get suitable background motion blur.

The other thinks that whilst it might offer a small benefit, successful shots are more down to technique, that panned shots are less susceptable to vertical oscillation than static ones, and that IS is of more use when subjects are very slow moving or static.

Would anyone with any experience of this type of photography with such lenses care to comment? ;)
 
I use a Nikon 70-300 VR when shooting motorsport and panning and find it works very well. I've tried turning the VR off to see how much difference it makes and turned it back on PDQ. Yes, succesful panning is to a large extent technique but VR does help a fair bit too.
 
if it helps great :thumbs: if it doesnt :thumbsdown: resort to technique:thumbs:

someone will be along to give more accurate reasons im sure:p
 
From my experience...

The Sigma 150-500mm has OS (Optical Stabilisation) and it has two switchable modes. One where both horizontal and vertical shake are compensated, and a panning mode where only the vertical component is removed.

The Nikon 70-200 VRII also has two modes, however they work differently from the Sigma. The first mode removes horiz/vert shake, but it also dynamically recognises smooth panning movements which are much greater than horizontal shake, and under those circumstances it removes only the vertical shake. The other mode is for use on vehicles where the vibration is much higher in magnitude, panning detection does not apply in this mode.

Both versions, Sigma and Nikon, work for me, but you have to be aware of what VR/IS/OS is doing and the differences even within a manufacturer's range.

I would not be without such technology as I mostly do handheld shots of motorsport and panning quality is noticeably improved.

Ed
 
if your hand holding whilst panning turn vr off. there is a version on some lenses that woks whilst panning on a mono/tripod but even then i would turn it off.
 
Personally when I am panning I switch to mode 2 on my Canon lens which is designed for, well, panning. My reasoning is it will still help the image stay stable on the vertical plane and will also compliment my panning technique.

if your hand holding whilst panning turn vr off. there is a version on some lenses that woks whilst panning on a mono/tripod but even then i would turn it off.

OP already said he was only referring to lenses with 'panning freindly' IS - and the panning is not limited to tripod/monopod use but designed to turn off the IS correction on one plane.

Please can you give your reasons for turning it off? Would help greatly to understand why
 
Please can you give your reasons for turning it off? Would help greatly to understand why

Let me hand you the tin opener so those worms can get out....
 
Back
Top