Thoughts on D3S Review in Professional Photographer

Messages
395
Edit My Images
No
Hello all!
After reading my copy of Professional Photographer (Feb '10 Edition) I noticed their review of the Nikon D3S seemed quite biased.

Now I'm not bashing the camera, the D3S is quite simply stunning especially in it's handling of high ISO images. But things kept cropping up in the article, things like "The Nikon D3S is the first pro level camera to feature a 100k+ ISO range", I don't believe it is, the Canon 1D Mk IV came out on the same day if I remember correctly and has the same extended ISO range.

The other gripe I have is that when comparing the high range ISO performance of the D3S with other offerings, they compared a top of the range pro level DSLR with, what I would consider, two semi pro DSLR bodies. Just looking at the cost of the bodies you can see that they are not even in the same range, 5D Mk II being <£1800, D300 being roughly the same as that and the D3S being ~£4000. Would it not have been fairer to compare the D3S to the Canon 1D Mk IV?

Also they kept referring to other bodies as "competitors offering", which whilst true, makes it sound more like an advert in my opinion.

Am I just being crazy? Is there merit to my gripes?

Thoughts please :)
Mike
 
arn't all these reviews just written to please the principle advertisers?
 
I presume so, I would have expected an unbiased review though, I guess I'm wrong in thinking that?
 
I presume so, I would have expected an unbiased review though, I guess I'm wrong in thinking that?

The D3s is probably one of the best camera's on the market at the moment, had they panned it I would have called that bias.

However I seriously doubt that you will find any of these magazine reviews tear the camera (any make) to pieces, one because of how we have become a litigation society, and two because of the advertising revenue they would lose.

To be honest it is why I never bother buying any of the magazines, or stand in the library supermarket reading them
 
I haven't read the article but you make good points. Always glad to meet a critical reader. :thumbs:
 
I've not read the article as I got fed up with Professional Photographer's lack of any real content a while ago.

According to Wiki the D3S was announced a week earlier than the MKIV (14th Oct vs 20th Oct) so it could be argued that the statement about it being the first is true. I'm guessing they couldn't compare the 1D Mk IV as they didn't have a copy to try. There is benefit to the magazine to get the first review published in terms of extra sales and therefore competition to get the first hands on from the manufacturers so a good review will naturally help a magazine get the jump on the next few releases.

The other thing to keep in mind Magazines make their money from adverts otherwise the cost of each issue would be prohibitive to the consumer and manufacturers usually have big expensive adverts on the back cover. So a magazine will want to keep their big clients happy - I'm not suggesting they would claim brilliance when a product is far from it, but unnecessarily mentioning the alternatives is unlikely to win friends at the manufacturers.

Anyway from what I've seen on the web of direct comparisons the D3S is clearly more capable at high ISOs so perhaps Canon wouldn't let them do a direct comparison.
 
I've handled a D3s and seen a huge (b/w) print taken at 128,000ISO and it was truly amazing - but then how often do you need to shoot at those levels - if the lightquantity is that bad then the likelyhood is the light quality will also be bad for pictures
 
Anyway from what I've seen on the web of direct comparisons the D3S is clearly more capable at high ISOs so perhaps Canon wouldn't let them do a direct comparison.

I've seen one picture purportedly from a pre-production 1D Mk IV, I wasn't the least bit impressed, however, at least it's the same level as the D3S and in roughly the same price bracket. However, you might well be right in that Canon didn't want them to publish a direct comparison.
 
I haven't seen it either, but working in the editorial area I can offer another possibility. Your observations are perfectly valid, so don't think I am decrying them.

Journalists have to find an angle to hang the feature on, a straight review is boring so they have to find a few comparions. MAYBE those mid priced cameras were chosen to give an idea of just how far ahead of the field these new crop of cameras are. Using the mid priced (and therefore quite commonplace and not aspirational) cameras as a metaphor rather than a direct comparison.

This happens a lot in all fields of reporting, just to make the statement stand out more.

I work mostly in the marine worldd and you try and get two or more boats to go head to head.....nobody will in case they come out the loser. Look at the multi bike tests, none ever LOSES, just one will better at one thing and another at something else.

Having seen and used a D3s it is awesome, imagine a working ISO of 12,500, it will make those dark and dingy December wedding nigtmares a thing of the past (even in rain when you can't use flash very well) - but I am not upgrading, Iwouldn't make any more money than I do now by doing so and I don't need video. 9FPS is fast enough for what I need and I rarely go over 400 ISO. Interesting to keep up with what is out there though.
 
I think I've read about ten reviews this week thanks to Dougie and his minions sending me all the Photo press on a monthly basis...
The trend is fairly positive, but at least one reviewer wasn't as star-struck as you'd imagine - thought it was good but not worth the £4k price-tag - or rather, he commented on the fact that when the D3 came out two (was it, or three?) years ago, one of the major advantages it had over the competition was the £3k price tag, which has now risen to £4k+ with the D3s, thus negating that advantage...

Also he thought the much-hyped uber-ISO capability wasn't really 'all that' - yes it goes very high, but at the Hi 1&2 settings, was only really suitable for Press users (as you'd expect), as the quality was a bit streaky and horrible...
 
Actually, i think you will fnd that although announced on the same date, the Nikon was "Available" a lot earlier. The first one delivered to a member on here was this week.

People got their D3s early december. The Mk4 has been delayed and delayed and delayed.

Perhaps that's the reason, Professional Photographer couldnt get one?
 
I don't think the price of the cameras is relevant in the comparisons. I haven't seen the article but comparing two full frame cameras against each other would seem reasonable to me, especially when it comes down to picture quality.

Things like handling, durability etc are another issue.
 
To go back to the OP - Professional Photographer is a comic. Don't read it.

The only worthwhile camera reviews (UK-wise) seem to be in Amateur Photographer and British Journal of Photography. And even then I'd still bear in mind who they're writing for, how long they had the camera etc.

Mind you BJP did have some shots from a night-time walkabout from the D3s and I have to say I thought that they were flat and lifeless. Fine for reporting but not for anything else. Still - that's their market after all and as I'm unlikely to ever want to get one I doubt they care for my opinion.
 
The reviews I've read have been pretty fair I think. I certainly read more Canon biased articles than the other way around. In terms of Professional Photographer mag I wouuldn't get too excited about their reviews - they tend to be very nice to the major brands and are rarely particularly critical about anything. The main aim of these mags is to get "D3s review inside" on the front cover. The fact that the reviewer has only spent a couple of days with the thing hardly seems to matter.

As Ginger Jon said there are better magazines to read for reviews - mainly Amateur Photographer imo.

Even better reviews might be from actual users who are shooting in the real world. In terms of comparing noise the Canon mk IV is the best to compare it too - especially as the sames types of tog will be using one or the other. However the 5Dmk II is more likely to be used by Canon wedding togs and in that respect the D3s is a valid comparison. Either way the ultra high ISOs are a bit mad. For me I think 6400 is about my preferred limit for the D3s. That's 4 stops under the maximum!

HTH
 
Mind you BJP did have some shots from a night-time walkabout from the D3s and I have to say I thought that they were flat and lifeless. Fine for reporting but not for anything else. Still - that's their market after all and as I'm unlikely to ever want to get one I doubt they care for my opinion.

If they were straight out of the camera it's hardly surprising they looked a bit flat is it?
 
If they were straight out of the camera it's hardly surprising they looked a bit flat is it?

I presumed they'd done some processing on them before sticking them in the mag. They weren't presented as unprocessed raw/jpeg files.

I'm assuming from your camera list that you disagree - but those are so far the only shots I've seen (to my knowledge) at the highest ISO on a D3s and, like I say, I wasn't as impressed as I thought I would be.
 
I presumed they'd done some processing on them before sticking them in the mag. They weren't presented as unprocessed raw/jpeg files.

Good point. Although I always assumed that with reviews, the images printed were unprocessed. Otherwise it defeats the object of a review doesn't it?

I'm assuming from your camera list that you disagree - but those are so far the only shots I've seen (to my knowledge) at the highest ISO on a D3s and, like I say, I wasn't as impressed as I thought I would be.

I'm not sure what you think I'm disagreeing with. But if it's high ISO then as I said already - I think the "hi" settings are pretty useless for the type of work I do. But I thought this image at 25,600 was pretty good. (SOOC)

4252057352_83ece05028_o.jpg
 
Good point. Although I always assumed that with reviews, the images printed were unprocessed. Otherwise it defeats the object of a review doesn't it?

It does to an extent but given that pretty much any image is going to go through some software before being published it's a bit of a falsehood to just show unprocessed images as well.

I don't have the magazine in question now anyway so can't check.



I'm not sure what you think I'm disagreeing with. But if it's high ISO then as I said already - I think the "hi" settings are pretty useless for the type of work I do. But I thought this image at 25,600 was pretty good.

Sorry about that - I did read your post before but then managed to block it out when replying to your other one.

That image is good - and a good example of what can be achieved at what were previously impossible ISOs.

I think we are actually in agreement though!
 
They probably couldn't get a 1DIV to test it against :D
 
D3s announced - 14/10/09

1D IV announced - 21/10/09

I stand corrected. Thanks for all the input guys, even though I don't normally read the reviews section in these mags, because I know what they're like, I do like some of the articles that are written in them.
 
I don't think anyone has actually got their hands on the Canon mk 4 yet, have they? I bet it will be ages before we see good, believable reviews from folk who have had real hands-on tryouts......and by then Nikon may well have bought out another camera! :lol:
 
A couple of the guys here have 'em and I think their opinions are as valid as any. Check out the sports threads (or equipment)
 
I would imagine the reason that they have not compared is so that next month they have the exclusive 1D mk4 review, then the month after the head to head. I really like professional photographer, I take any mag review with a piece of salt, but amateur photographer doesn't do it for me and BJOP seems expensive for what it is.

Any magazine will never risk giving a bad review to an advertiser, none of them dare risk it. So take mag reviews with a pinch of salt and ask people on here who have them, they will give you a better, non biased, real world test.

Have to say the preview of the Leica in Professional Photographer was a joke. One tiny shot in the mag, as the test cam iso had a max of 320 and the guy reviewing it doesnt use flash lighting, therore couldn't get a usable shutter speed. So instead we got a load of him holding it shot by his assistant.
 
Back
Top