Toreside Reservoir..can't decide :) Edit of #2 added.

[posiview]

Afternoon, I've been up since 03:50 so may be a bit frazzled, can't decide which I prefer.

I like the splash of red in #1 but the cleanness of #2

Thoughts?

1a by aNdy sHeader, on Flickr

1b by aNdy sHeader, on Flickr

 

[rick448]

Second one for me.

 

[sirch]

I agree, second one but hard to say why.

 

[Tringa]

The second one for me, too. I find it an interesting image but I'd also like to see more.

Dave

 

[Phil-D]

2nd one Andy, 'cos there's no red card in any of mine!

 

[dod]

#2. The card looks out of place

 

[posiview]

Second one for me.

I agree, second one but hard to say why.

The second one for me, too. I find it an interesting image but I'd also like to see more.

Dave

2nd one Andy, 'cos there's no red card in any of mine!

#2. The card looks out of place

#1 for me. Mysterious. Wonder what's in the book (or whateveritis )

Yeah, Phil, it must have been washed away before you got your camera out One for a cloudless night !!

Cheers.

 

[stevenelawson]

Really like the abstractness of the second one. What's that red shape in the first one?

 

[viv1969]

Second for me, Andy... Lovely abstract.
I'll be honest, the red in the first isn't sufficient to be anything other than something I want to wipe off.

 

[Bobsyeruncle]

Second for me.

 

[AllFallD0wn]

Number two for me. Great capture! Whereabouts do you park to get to this place? Go past Woodhead quite often and I've never figured out exactly where this spot is!

 

[Dale.]

Number 2 for sure. The red square is all I see in the first image once I've seen it.

 

[chuckles]

2nd for me too - however, had it been red, as opposed to nearly pink, I think it would alter things considerably!

 

[posiview]

Really like the abstractness of the second one. What's that red shape in the first one?

Second for me, Andy... Lovely abstract.
I'll be honest, the red in the first isn't sufficient to be anything other than something I want to wipe off.

Second for me.

Number two for me. Great capture! Whereabouts do you park to get to this place? Go past Woodhead quite often and I've never figured out exactly where this spot is!

Number 2 for sure. The red square is all I see in the first image once I've seen it.

2nd for me too - however, had it been red, as opposed to nearly pink, I think it would alter things considerably!

Thanks, all, not sure what it is.

Edit below

Project Red by aNdy sHeader, on Flickr

 

[stevenelawson]

Thanks, all, not sure what it is.

Edit below

Project Red by aNdy sHeader, on Flickr

Nope. Still bugs me [emoji16]

 

[chuckles]

Nope. Still bugs me [emoji16]

Adds more impetus though? Not certain it's better than without but an improvement on pink

 

[stevenelawson]

It's so incongruous and spoils the lovely balance of the picture [emoji3]

 

[posiview]

Number two for me. Great capture! Whereabouts do you park to get to this place? Go past Woodhead quite often and I've never figured out exactly where this spot is!

We parked here. There were no 'visible' No parking signs

It's so incongruous and spoils the lovely balance of the picture [emoji3]

I think thats why I like it

Cheers.

 

[chuckles]

I think thats why I like it

Me too - which is why I wondered having it 'shockingly' red might improve it,

 

[Craig_85]

I like the second, I'm not really into abstract but it is a strong shot.

 

[MrDrizz]

The second one as the red sign in the first just draws the eye right to it.