Tripod Head

Messages
822
Name
John
Edit My Images
Yes
Hi
Am thinking of getting a 'L' bracket for my D800 and have seen a Kirk one which I like. This won't go on my Manfrotto head (804 RC2) so I want to change that for a suitable one. I mainly use the tripod for landscape/night shots, so, what Arca Swiss system head would people recommend, I am also going to attach the 'L' bracket.
Thanks
JohnyT
 
The options are pretty much endless.

What is your budget and what tripod is it likely to be attached to.

I run an Acratech GV2 on my 3 series Gitzo legs for the weight and a cheap Red Snapper head on my 1542T legs as it's so light and never used with anything heavier than a 27-70 and D800E.
 
No complaints with my Markins M10, think it's called the Q10 now

Also have a Photoclam 33NS on my lighter tripod, essentially a Markins copy and also very good for the price
 
I recently made the same switch. I had been using the Manfrotto QR system for years but never used an L bracket, I tried the Manfroto L bracket but found it to be clumsy, heavy and inelegant. So I switched to Kirk L brackets which stay on the cameras 24/7, I don't mind the slight extra bulk and really like the feel of them in my hand. I use a monopod a lot more now too which isn't a bad thing I suppose!

I went through the whole research thing for heads and settled an a Markins Q10 for my monopod and an Arca-Swiss Z1 for the tripod. I'd wholeheartedly recommend either of them if they fit your needs/budget. The Markins is smaller but well made and intuitive to use, it sits well on a monopod. The Z1 is beautifully engineered and a joy to use... but quite expensive. There are loads of other options though so a good idea to research them all I guess.

The other decision to make is what type of release mechanism you want... I went for the lever release on both systems (Arca call it 'Fliplock') as opposed to the screw in type. I think I'm in the minority and most go for the screw in but I prefer the speed and convenience of the levers, it largely depends on your style of photography I think. There are two possible downsides to the levers though... Firstly there's always the remote chance of catching the levers and releasing them accidentally, this is almost impossible on the Arca Fliplock as it has a two stage 'lock' to prevent accidental release but on the Markins there is no backup safety like this so if you accidentally release it your camera will tumble to the ground! I use the Markins on a monopod so rarely let go of the camera anyway and it isn't an issue but if you use it on a tripod then this should be a consideration. Secondly, the lever locks need a one time adjustment to precisely fit the plate you are using, so if you have multiple bodies you need the same make of bracket on each body as the fit varies slightly between manufacturers... not a big issue but may be worth bearing in mind.

Hope that helps.
 
If you're doing landscape stuff I'd recommend a geared head, either the Manfrotto 410, 405 (which is bigger than the 410 and heavier) or if you win the Euromillions on Friday an Arca Cube.

They're not natively Arca compatible so you'll need the Hejnar conversion which is a 5 minute job and costs around £60.

Alternatively if you're happy with your current head you can lock the existing QR plate down tight and fix a Kirk Arca clamp to the top of it.
 
I recently made the same switch. I had been using the Manfrotto QR system for years but never used an L bracket, I tried the Manfroto L bracket but found it to be clumsy, heavy and inelegant. So I switched to Kirk L brackets which stay on the cameras 24/7, I don't mind the slight extra bulk and really like the feel of them in my hand. I use a monopod a lot more now too which isn't a bad thing I suppose!

I went through the whole research thing for heads and settled an a Markins Q10 for my monopod and an Arca-Swiss Z1 for the tripod. I'd wholeheartedly recommend either of them if they fit your needs/budget. The Markins is smaller but well made and intuitive to use, it sits well on a monopod. The Z1 is beautifully engineered and a joy to use... but quite expensive. There are loads of other options though so a good idea to research them all I guess.

The other decision to make is what type of release mechanism you want... I went for the lever release on both systems (Arca call it 'Fliplock') as opposed to the screw in type. I think I'm in the minority and most go for the screw in but I prefer the speed and convenience of the levers, it largely depends on your style of photography I think. There are two possible downsides to the levers though... Firstly there's always the remote chance of catching the levers and releasing them accidentally, this is almost impossible on the Arca Fliplock as it has a two stage 'lock' to prevent accidental release but on the Markins there is no backup safety like this so if you accidentally release it your camera will tumble to the ground! I use the Markins on a monopod so rarely let go of the camera anyway and it isn't an issue but if you use it on a tripod then this should be a consideration. Secondly, the lever locks need a one time adjustment to precisely fit the plate you are using, so if you have multiple bodies you need the same make of bracket on each body as the fit varies slightly between manufacturers... not a big issue but may be worth bearing in mind.

Hope that helps.
Ah...didn't know there were 2 types Keith.....will the Arca plate fit either a screw or Fliplock?
Thanks
JohnyT
 
If you're doing landscape stuff I'd recommend a geared head, either the Manfrotto 410, 405 (which is bigger than the 410 and heavier) or if you win the Euromillions on Friday an Arca Cube.

They're not natively Arca compatible so you'll need the Hejnar conversion which is a 5 minute job and costs around £60.

Alternatively if you're happy with your current head you can lock the existing QR plate down tight and fix a Kirk Arca clamp to the top of it.

Thanks for that info Mark, although I'm not keen on having 2 quick releases so to speak. Must admit I do like the Manfrotto heads but the 'L' bracket situation is forcing my hand.
JohnyT
 
Thanks for that info Mark, although I'm not keen on having 2 quick releases so to speak. Must admit I do like the Manfrotto heads but the 'L' bracket situation is forcing my hand.
JohnyT

You wouldn't have to adjust the Manfrotto plate, just attach the clamp to the top of it. It's not the most elegant of solutions, granted.

L brackets are awesome, I wouldn't be without one.
 
You wouldn't have to adjust the Manfrotto plate, just attach the clamp to the top of it. It's not the most elegant of solutions, granted.

L brackets are awesome, I wouldn't be without one.

Yep I see what you mean Mark but when I attach the clamp bit on the Manfrotto system I'm always not 100% sure it's secure, I had a Giottos one and that seemed more positive. Which QR system would that be btw?
Thanks
JohnyT
 
May I toss in one more? :D

B3-03.jpg


This setup was selected entirely for panorama shootings.

Head is a Benro B3 and panorama clamp Benro PC1, $200 at DC. Stuff.

Here show in it's final - slightly painted - incarnation...

DSC_3526.jpg


Happy Hunting! :)

Note to self: really needs to get WB under control....
 
Ah...didn't know there were 2 types Keith.....will the Arca plate fit either a screw or Fliplock?
Thanks
JohnyT

Yes, the Arca plate will fit either... it's just a matter of preference. I think most manufacturers offer alternatives, certainly Arca-Swiss and Markins do... for example:
Markins Q10 with screw
or
Markins Q10 with lever

Like I say though, I prefer the lever types because I'm constantly taking the camera on and off the tripod/monopod and need to do so quickly. If you're a more leisurely landscape photographer for example then maybe the security of the screw type would be better.
 
Ok are there any Arca Swiss compatible ballheads that I should avoid? The Benro and Sunwayfoto seem a reasonable price but would be prepared to buy a Z1 if the price difference was worth it. In fact the max. load is greater on the 2 cheaper models, which must be a good thing.
Thanks
JohnyT
After reseraching I realise 'creep' is the one to look out for. Seems the Markins and Z1 get pretty good reviews on this.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top