Turning a good/excellent photograph an average/bad photograph..

Messages
19,304
Name
Andy
Edit My Images
Yes
I was in my favourite shop this morning...Waterstones, which has a Costa in (what a combination!) and I was, as usual perusing, through the photography section.

I was looking at some of my favourite photographs and wondered why I liked them.

In most, but not all, I could identify some reason why I liked them; what I thought made them a good, as opposed to an average/bad photograph.

I started to challenge myself to think of one object that, if removed from the photograph, would change them from a good to average/bad photograph.

I then thought I'd see what others would do.

So, if you're interested in joining in, just post a photograph you like and tell us what object, if removed, would change it from a got to an average/bad photograph....

I'd like it to be specifically about an object.

Of course, people will disagree on a number of grounds: this initial photograph isn't good in the first instance, when the object is removed it doesn't become a average/bad photograph or they would have removed something else.

It wasn't easy - there were loads I could have submitted!

I'll start: if the man in the foreground was removed I think it would change it from a good to an average/bad photograph. His eye contact with the photograph, for me is a great catch, wondering what he is carrying (I think it's a mirror), if he wasn't carrying a picture, has he just bought it, or is he selling it.

kertesz.jpg
 
I also think removing the steam train would make this much less interesting :)
 
How about this shot by HCB then?

art_henri-cartier-bresson-aquila-degl.jpg


Removing that very fortuitous crow from the foreground, certainly wouldn't ruin a great image, but it's so beautifully placed you just marvel at the guy's luck. If it was anyone other than Henri I'd suspect it was stuffed!
 
How about this shot by HCB then?

art_henri-cartier-bresson-aquila-degl.jpg


Removing that very fortuitous crow from the foreground, certainly wouldn't ruin a great image, but it's so beautifully placed you just marvel at the guy's luck. If it was anyone other than Henri I'd suspect it was stuffed!

Nice one, looks like the crow is mooning HCB...:D

He took some fantastic photographs that I can't help thinking, and I sincerley hope I'm wrong, that they are staged...
 
content and impact i feel are the most important ingredients
a snapshot of life should tell a story

the bottom of the list is pure technical expertise...well shot *****
 
I do find it amusing how often I see world renowned shots and think - if I submitted that to my camera club how much it'd be caned as crap for so many reasons :D

Your 'fortuitous crow' shot would fail for having that crow in it (but it not being immediately obvious it IS a crow), then the woman with the railing through her head and too much dead space at the top of the shot :lol:

DD
 
To me if the man in the foreground was removed it would actually make the picture better.
 
May I be so bold as to ask that members keeps posts in the spirit of the original post...:thankyou:

I'm genuinely interested in seeing people's ideas.

:thumbs:
 
How about this shot by HCB then?

art_henri-cartier-bresson-aquila-degl.jpg


Removing that very fortuitous crow from the foreground, certainly wouldn't ruin a great image, but it's so beautifully placed you just marvel at the guy's luck. If it was anyone other than Henri I'd suspect it was stuffed!

erm...i wasnt there that day so not guilty
could be my pidgeon pal....

caw!
 
I feel removing the cans of corn beef would really remove some of the poignancy of the photograph.

With the cans, he actually owns something, even if they are only empty corn beef cans!

A great quote by Don McCullin, in refernce to the photograph was "and suddenly somebody touched my hand and he was holding my hand. I thought I was on the verge of really crying…"

1969biafraemE.jpg
 
Back
Top