- Messages
- 19,304
- Name
- Andy
- Edit My Images
- Yes
I was in my favourite shop this morning...Waterstones, which has a Costa in (what a combination!) and I was, as usual perusing, through the photography section.
I was looking at some of my favourite photographs and wondered why I liked them.
In most, but not all, I could identify some reason why I liked them; what I thought made them a good, as opposed to an average/bad photograph.
I started to challenge myself to think of one object that, if removed from the photograph, would change them from a good to average/bad photograph.
I then thought I'd see what others would do.
So, if you're interested in joining in, just post a photograph you like and tell us what object, if removed, would change it from a got to an average/bad photograph....
I'd like it to be specifically about an object.
Of course, people will disagree on a number of grounds: this initial photograph isn't good in the first instance, when the object is removed it doesn't become a average/bad photograph or they would have removed something else.
It wasn't easy - there were loads I could have submitted!
I'll start: if the man in the foreground was removed I think it would change it from a good to an average/bad photograph. His eye contact with the photograph, for me is a great catch, wondering what he is carrying (I think it's a mirror), if he wasn't carrying a picture, has he just bought it, or is he selling it.
I was looking at some of my favourite photographs and wondered why I liked them.
In most, but not all, I could identify some reason why I liked them; what I thought made them a good, as opposed to an average/bad photograph.
I started to challenge myself to think of one object that, if removed from the photograph, would change them from a good to average/bad photograph.
I then thought I'd see what others would do.
So, if you're interested in joining in, just post a photograph you like and tell us what object, if removed, would change it from a got to an average/bad photograph....
I'd like it to be specifically about an object.
Of course, people will disagree on a number of grounds: this initial photograph isn't good in the first instance, when the object is removed it doesn't become a average/bad photograph or they would have removed something else.
It wasn't easy - there were loads I could have submitted!
I'll start: if the man in the foreground was removed I think it would change it from a good to an average/bad photograph. His eye contact with the photograph, for me is a great catch, wondering what he is carrying (I think it's a mirror), if he wasn't carrying a picture, has he just bought it, or is he selling it.

