Want to buy my first DSLR - advice needed!

Messages
9
Edit My Images
No
Hi All,

I am looking to purchase my first DSLR camera and have read through hundreds of webpages giving lots of advice, but am now confused!

The lens is the key according to most forums, webpages, reviews etc, but I need to be sensible with limited funds available.

1. Usage
I am heading to Germany for the German WRC Rally in a few weeks and would like a camera that can shoot fast and I'm guessing that the 18-55 kit lens is not going to have the reach for shoots taken in forests of rally stages / and track photograhy.

Aside from motorsport, the others will be of my wife and 2 year old son playing around on holiday, site-seeing, walk-about shots (I've seem that term somewhere!) etc. Over time will also be at football matches and airshows/airports.

Costs:
Not sure how much to pay really. What's hampering the issue is that I have a £250 voucher from John Lewis which I'd love to use, but reluctant to buy their off-the-shelf items?

Nikon or Canon?
Have used Canon in the past and had the little ixus i which I thought was an amazing point'n'shoot camera, and have used a Canon DSLR a few years back borrowed from a friend and thought easy to use and comfortable.

My thoughts (and am I right?):
1000D - cheap, entry-level, 3fps
450D - now stopped selling? seems harder to find than say a year ago?
500D - with video, 3fps?
550D - Raved about on some websites with 1080p video, only 3.7fps ***? at the top end of my budget with a 18-55 lens

So I looked at Nikon:
D5000 - seemed all good reviews until I read about it not having AF, and that means not many existing lenses can be used?
D90 - can't really afford.

So I then looked at reconditioned camera on MPB something like the D80 or Canon 40D? Would the £400 cost of these with then a good lens be more beneficial than a 450D/D5000? Do the slightly older cameras have lesser technology?

Lenses:
That may be a whole new thread - but according to most on various forums the 70-200 would seem good for motorsport, although would a 70-300 be much better to cover the longer distances? Close-up of cars - at shakedown/parc ferme I'm guessing the kit lens would be sufficient at the outset of my DSLR photography hobby!?

As you can see I'm confused as to what to do for the best?

Any guidance / tips / help very much appreciated.

PS. Any recommendable camera shops in Leicester - does anyone know?

Thanks,
CHRIS.
 
Last edited:
I'll throw Sony into the mix. A Sony A450 - A550 seems to cover most bases. Pros & Cons:

Each has 5fps (A550 has 7fps in locked focus mode)
Image stabilisation (VR/IS within the body)
Quick live view- so you can use it like a P&S
Tilt screen, works well with Live view
Dynamic range optimisation - works the shadows and highlights


No video mode- as with some newer cams
Premium lenses can be more pricey than its nikon/canon equivalent
Out of camera JPEGs not the best
Small view finder
There are rumours that in the year horizon, the upgrades to these cams will be here with video (prob more expensive too)

Price wise you can get a new starter kit:- A500 +18-55 + 55-200 for around £550
 
Bit cheeky I know, but I have a nearly new Canon 500D for sale on the classifieds and would take your John Lewis voucher as part payment. My local and only supermarket is Waitrose and as along as I can use it there it would soon get spent, so like cash to me.

The offer is there if you are interested and maybe have a look at the Canon 55-250 IS lens.

Not very expensive, excellent picture quality with the benefit of the latest IS too. Doesn't have its own motor, but tests I have seen show it to be equally as fast as those with, if not quicker

This isn't a sales pitch, but seeing as Leicester isn't that far from me you would be welcome to come and have a try with the camera and I also have the lens mentioned above (not for sale though)
Bought it as a stop gap from a friend, but haven't seen anything I prefer without spending considerably more

Cheers
Rich
 
Last edited:
I've recently bought a Canon 500D and am very impressed with it, lots of good reviews.

it all depends on budget, if I had more money I'd of gone for a 550, more money a 50D.
 
So I looked at Nikon:
D5000 - seemed all good reviews until I read about it not having AF, and that means not many existing lenses can be used?
CHRIS.

Don't write off the D5000 - it has perfectly good AF and works with the full range of current lenses.
It doesn't have a projecting screw that allows autofocus on older Nikkor lenses without an internal motor.

From the early 1990's, Nikkor lenses had internal motors for focusing and the D5000 will provide full AF with any lens from then onwards. Unless you have a specific Nikkor lens from more that 20 years ago that you simply MUST have, then this should be a non-issue as far your choice is concerned.

There's a good lens compatibility article here: http://www.kenrockwell.com/nikon/compatibility-lens.htm#dslr

hth
Graham
 
Nip in and have a fiddle with a few models in your price range, you need to see how it feels to handle, where the controls are etc

Models such as the 450, 500, 550 seem to be replaced with a new model every 6 months or so so there are always some good deals about as the next new model is released
 
Last edited:
The clue on Nikon lenses for focusing on this, now, not so new style of no motorised body, any lens designated; 'AF-S' will Auto focus on D40, D40X, D3000, D5000 . . . might be a couple of others? The AF-S designation goes back a few years, I have an AF-S 18-70 that came with a brand new D70s.

Third party lens makers have been embracing the 'S' requirement for a good while now. The sticking point might be on pro spec, fast (expensive) lenses. If you intend going that rout . . . :thinking: And building a collection of old lenses, they would have issues.

But for us less passionate, normal, non anorak types, the D5000 is a great body, very much a D90 where it matters:thumbs: I would recommend the Nikon 'AF-S' 18-70 and the 70-200 or 300 for motor sport, as a good stating point for good IQ If you want the super zoom 18-200, Sigma, Tamron (18-270!), Nikon can accommodate according to budget.

CJS
 
Last edited:
If you go the s/h route then the Canon 40d is still an awesome camera. If you check the clasified section here mint ones go for around £400 and the Canon 18-55is and 55-250is could be had for around £200 the pair.

That'll see you sorted until the inevitable happens...
 
Appreciate all the comments and feedback guys; even the cheeky offer Tijuana Taxi (sounds appealing I must admit and we're not too far from you either!).

Off to get my son's hair cut before holiday and then into leicester to have a try of as many cameras as i can.

Be back on later.

Cheers,
CHRIS.
 
:plusone: EOS 40D...ace piece of kit

Paul
 
:plusone:I would also suggest you seriously consider S/H, lots of honest sellers here......40D would be my choice, a good all rounder that will hold it's own for many a year to come.

Hope you can make your mind up quicker than this member did:D
 
Last edited:
Hope you had a good camera testing trip Chris and have a better idea of what you want

Afraid my cheeky offer has to be rescinded as the camera was sold this afternoon

Cheers
 
ignore relative fps, its all a marketing numbers game at the amateur end, just changes the number bad shots you have to bin.

ignore the wrc as a buying requirement if its a one-off rallying holiday, in 2 weeks you're unlikely to have the knowledge or practise for techniques necessary to get the shots perfect, just take any camera and lenses available and have fun trying.

kiddy = get video

they're all pretty good. More money gets you more durable (heavier metal & less plastic), sometimes better weather sealing, features like video and most importantly usually better high iso performance on the bodies.

Long zooms: expensive lenses get you bigger aperture (low f number) for less depth of field and also ability work with less light or higher shutter speeds, better focussing speed, they also generally weigh more. If its for general family use then standard light consumer (kit) lenses are easier to cart around, but action sports photography (stage, track or pitch) will soon start to push the limits of a consumer lens' ability. You're not going to have the knowledge/skills/practice to get the best out a pro lens to start with, so just get something and start learning. In the canon range the 55-250 IS appears to be getting a good reputation for a basic long lens, 70-300 I've heard is soft at the long end, 70-200Lf4 is a cracker if you've got cash spare, the f2.8 IS version if you're really desperate to spend money or are committed to the best.

avoid super zooms unless you really need one lens to do everything, they compromise image quality compared to shorter zoom lengths, but have their place for convenience.

the trouble with a camera is then you need all the other bits, there is the filters (just get screw on UV to protect the lenses to start with, get hoya HMC, do not get cheap ones), the hoods (extra at canon consumer end), spare batteries, some memory cards, . . . then there is the never ending search for the perfect bag, etc etc. . . . and then there is the software for post processing to get the photos out you thought you had taken. . . .
you have been warned


there's no right or wrong to start with, find a body you are comfortable holding and button layout you like and after that enjoy a long learning curve :thumbs:
 
should have read the thread more carefully before typing all that :D . This is what comes of trying to teach my son to write his name in ogham while replying! Hope it was a good shopping trip.
 
I've been using a 400D with a 18-55 lens and a Canon 75-300mm , not a bad set up and will be selling for circa £325. It has done me proud for last 2 years and a great way to start.

Not sure what I would upgrade to yet ***! I guess the point I'm trying to make is that you don't have to have the best of everything to get some decent shots!

Thanks
 
I use a Canon 450D and as an aside if you need to shoot fast and continuous the XXXD series don't really cut it.

However if 3-4 frames/sec is good enough then by shooting JPEG large (not RAW) you can usually get around 12-20 shots before the buffer fills up.

I have been shooting JPEG for a few months now and find for the kind of shots I take there is no discernible difference between that and RAW.

.
 
Last edited:
I'm genuinely not trying to be bias but go and try the a550 for a few reasons that would benefit you;

7fps on continuous shooting, great for motorsport spray and pray

in body IS, some argue that in body isn't as good as in lens or whatever but IS can be invaluable in fast paced situations.

I would also buy a second hand minolta 70-210mm f4 off eBay for around £150-200 and that should get you some good motorsport shots.
 
ignore relative fps, its all a marketing numbers game at the amateur end, just changes the number bad shots you have to bin.

ignore the wrc as a buying requirement if its a one-off rallying holiday, in 2 weeks you're unlikely to have the knowledge or practise for techniques necessary to get the shots perfect, just take any camera and lenses available and have fun trying.

kiddy = get video

they're all pretty good. More money gets you more durable (heavier metal & less plastic), sometimes better weather sealing, features like video and most importantly usually better high iso performance on the bodies.

Long zooms: expensive lenses get you bigger aperture (low f number) for less depth of field and also ability work with less light or higher shutter speeds, better focussing speed, they also generally weigh more. If its for general family use then standard light consumer (kit) lenses are easier to cart around, but action sports photography (stage, track or pitch) will soon start to push the limits of a consumer lens' ability. You're not going to have the knowledge/skills/practice to get the best out a pro lens to start with, so just get something and start learning. In the canon range the 55-250 IS appears to be getting a good reputation for a basic long lens, 70-300 I've heard is soft at the long end, 70-200Lf4 is a cracker if you've got cash spare, the f2.8 IS version if you're really desperate to spend money or are committed to the best.

avoid super zooms unless you really need one lens to do everything, they compromise image quality compared to shorter zoom lengths, but have their place for convenience.

the trouble with a camera is then you need all the other bits, there is the filters (just get screw on UV to protect the lenses to start with, get hoya HMC, do not get cheap ones), the hoods (extra at canon consumer end), spare batteries, some memory cards, . . . then there is the never ending search for the perfect bag, etc etc. . . . and then there is the software for post processing to get the photos out you thought you had taken. . . .
you have been warned


there's no right or wrong to start with, find a body you are comfortable holding and button layout you like and after that enjoy a long learning curve :thumbs:

Wookie, thats one of the best 'feet on the ground' descriptive advise threads I have read in a long time. Dont need to spend a fortune, dont need top pro quality, be comfortable, take pictures, keep it simple's, enjoy and learn . . . :clap:

I hope a lot of members take note of the method in future . . . :thinking:

CJS
 
Last edited:
I'm genuinely not trying to be bias but go and try the a550 for a few reasons that would benefit you;

7fps on continuous shooting, great for motorsport spray and pray

in body IS, some argue that in body isn't as good as in lens or whatever but IS can be invaluable in fast paced situations.

I would also buy a second hand minolta 70-210mm f4 off eBay for around £150-200 and that should get you some good motorsport shots.

Oh dear, sorry mastertrinity, you obviously have not read and 'understood' Wookies excellent post . . . :thumbsdown:

CJS
 
:plusone:I would also suggest you seriously consider S/H, lots of honest sellers here......40D would be my choice, a good all rounder that will hold it's own for many a year to come.

Hope you can make your mind up quicker than this member did:D

:lol::lol::lol:

And a few days later, he was in the for sale section trying to sell what he bought.

:bonk::bonk::bonk: :bang::bang::bang:


going back to the op's question, a second hand D90 might be what you need.
 
Last edited:
Thanks to all who have commented and especially wookie!

I think I know where I'm headed, but gonna think about things and head out at lunchtimes to play with the cameras again so hopefully by next weekend I might have bought something!

Thanks again - still open for any more comments/guidance!

Cheers,
CHRIS.
 
FPS is a very important issue and if you ask KIPAX on here who is an excellent sports tog then he will tell you the same;)

Yep, I agree, but as 'Wookie' says, 'only when you know how' . . . until then, it has the potential to add frustration?

We all do it, biggest, fastest, pro quality, etc., etc., . . . and we can hardly crawl, let alone 'walk before you run' . . . :shrug:

CJS
 
Okay, her I come brandishing my Pentax stick !

If you have read reviews, you will know that the Pentax Kx has recently taken the award for best entry level DSLR.
Pc World are doing stonking deals on these at the moment, twin lens kit (thats Kx body, 18-55DAL, 50-200DAL) for £450, you can even add a 100mm DFA 1:1 macro lens for an additional £230, this lens alone is retailing most outlets for £500 +
Not much good for your vouchers but they would be almost that much dearer anyway for the same kit !

Alternatively (cheecky reply number 2) I have just listed my Pentax Km over on pentax forums today, I have decided to upgrade to a K20D (a great used buy at £400, another option for you).
My Km is eighteen months old with 7000 pictures taken, mint condition, original boxes and everything that came with it. I have not got around to listing it on here yet but if you were interested I would do more for you.
Listed on Pentax forums Km with 18-55DAL, £250 ovno. For someone on this forum, that has given me so much help over the past eighteen months, I can chuck in a 4 gig memory card, fresh set of lithium batteries and a lowepro AW160 bag, then you would be ready to go.

For sample images of the Km or the Kx, every picture on my flickr was taken with these two cameras (99% with Km).
 
Hi,

Thanks again to all the posts but we're now back from our holidays and despite having not long to source a camera we amanged to get a real bargain. We opted for a Canon 450D with 18-55 IS lens - saw a deal on ebay and the camera is literally brand new, the previous owner had not used it! I then managed to use the JL vouchers for a Canon 55-250 IS lens - and that lens is amazing!

Then we went to Jacobs and bought a Lowepro Slingshot 102 AW (love the AW cover) along with spare Canon battery and 4gb 20mb/s SDHC card.

All kitted out, I read the manual on the Eurotunnel across to Calais!

After a few test shots in a very gloomy and wet Reims we headed off to our campsite in Luxembourg and to get ready for the Germany WRC just over the border in Trier.

In my very limited knowledge of photography, I think the camera has done an extremely fantastic job at making my photos look awesome. Great colour and size - just on a different planet to what we are used to with our Canon Ixus I.

I am about to dare to place some of my favourite shots in the motorsport section, and hope I don't get shot down too badly! For us they are the start...

Cheers one and all,

Chris.
 
Good choice with the 450D. I bought one a few weeks ago :) (refurbed Rebel model)
Not had a chance to go out and abouts to snap though. Have to agree an SLR is so much more responsive than a P&S.
I got meself a multicoated uv filter (Kenko) and on the lookout for a bag
 
You seem to have the thing pretty well sussed out, however if your interested in a canon and motorsport is you particular thing consider a 2nd hand EOD 40D

In fact the 40D is a pretty decent alrounder, I should have read down all of the thread, and congrats with the canon purchase
 
Last edited:
Back
Top