Watchdog presenters mum hassled over pictures of Grandchildren.

The comment from "m" below the article is a good example of the paranoia that's causing situations like this in the first place. Tin foil hat's at the ready :cuckoo:
 
maybe, but I think that pulling a camera out in a swimming pool now days is asking for this & I'm not surprised she was asked to stop in the current climate.

there is a place to start this fight to change the opinion of people like M's comments to the article, and I'm sorry but a swimming pool is not the place to do it

Hugh
 
When our children were younger, about 15 years ago, I always took a camera into the kids pool with us, and got some really memorable pics of them learning to swim, both from above the water, and below it.

Nobody took the slightest notice. Took lots of pictures of friend's children, too, at their request. Did the same on holidays abroad, always. Never any problem.
 
I wonder what damage a camera can do? I've dropped mine once and that hurt my wallet but thats about all. "Child Protection" :thinking:
 
M said:
it is a sign that with all the new technology that exists out there peadophiles can access images of our children much more easily than we imagined

Does she mean 'cameras'? If so, I think she's a little behind the times..... People have been taking photos of their kids and NOT BEEN PAEDOPHILES for quite a few years now! :D
 
I'd personally be more concerned about the person standing with a camera in the dunes at the beach, than the person clearly taking photo's of their family at a swimming pool.

I can understand the concerns, and why cameras have been banned from many public pools but this is a relatively new stance, as HOPPYUK states above, this was never an issue before. My parents have a large number of photo's of me and my sister in swimming pools and paddling pools as children, and they make up an important section of the family album. It would be a shame for all family albums to be limited to photo's taken within your own home!
 
This nonsense has been going on for donks.
In 1995 BBC newsreader Julia Somerville took pics of her child in the bath and put them into a Boots in London for developing. When her partner went to collect them officers from the Met Child porn unit arrested him followed by Julia.
They had to go through police interview then bail. Eventually the matter was dropped.

Seems to be damned little common sense anywhere now.
 
I wonder what damage a camera can do? I've dropped mine once and that hurt my wallet but thats about all. "Child Protection" :thinking:

Think about it? What damage can a camera do? I work with children, some of whom have been photographed. The photographs have reduced hardened judges, barristers and police to tears. Photographs can propogate harmful situations for some children for years and years that is why it is an offence to circulate or make some sorts of images. I sometimes work with adults who still have indecent images taken of them as children circulating on the net! They are powerless to do anything about them and it feeds into their sense of worthlessness.

I don't usually get involved in threads like this as they turn into polarised views and anyone defending certain 'rules' are labelled as a part of the "nanny state". but please at least give a bit of thought to your response.

I don't like some of the rules in place at some types of venue and don't particularly think that stopping a grandma is right. However, I am a 40ish year old bloke who could be viewed as 'dodgy' if I did the same thing, yet I am soon to be a Grandad. Who decides whether the Granny is dodgy and the Grandad (me) is not? The pool attendant / student with the summer job. Maybe the rules in certain places are there to prevent any ambiguity?

Before people go bonkers about human rights and photographers rights, I am all for them. But I am also all for Children's rights. My job has taught me that you should never dismiss the way in which people who want to can gain access to children. I have seen old, young, male and female people harm children. I have also been part of an operation where police covertly watched a man in Manchester tracking and photographing children at Sale Leisure Centre (a few years ago). He wasn't sexually motivated he was just looking for a blond child to kill. Don't remember the press giving the Police a pat on the back for stopping that one! I have also had two cases this year alone where children have been photographed. What damage can a camera do? Good question!

I love photography. It kind of keeps me sane! But just like anything else it can have it's negative side.

Sorry for the rant. Being a do gooder sometimes leaves me feeling a little frustrated at the public in general who want it all ways.

Chris :)
 
Fair point.

But answer this honestly. Would stopping everyone from using a camera in Sale Leisure Centre have made a difference?
I understand there is certainly a negative side to the ability to capture images. There are sick people out there who damage children by taking indecent photos of them.

But, and I ask you this with the best of intentions.....
How is preventing photography in public places going to stop those images being taken?

I honestly don't think those rules are in place to protect the public. They're to protect councils and institutions from being accused or blamed, should something ever happen.
 
Fair point.

But answer this honestly. Would stopping everyone from using a camera in Sale Leisure Centre have made a difference?
I understand there is certainly a negative side to the ability to capture images. There are sick people out there who damage children by taking indecent photos of them.

But, and I ask you this with the best of intentions.....
How is preventing photography in public places going to stop those images being taken?

I honestly don't think those rules are in place to protect the public. They're to protect councils and institutions from being accused or blamed, should something ever happen.

maybe - and I do think you're right, but nowdays I ain't surprised this happend in a swimming pool and I think that we're onto a loser if we start the fight to chaange public perception in a swimming pool

Hugh
 
Fair point.

But answer this honestly. Would stopping everyone from using a camera in Sale Leisure Centre have made a difference?
I understand there is certainly a negative side to the ability to capture images. There are sick people out there who damage children by taking indecent photos of them.

But, and I ask you this with the best of intentions.....
How is preventing photography in public places going to stop those images being taken?

I honestly don't think those rules are in place to protect the public. They're to protect councils and institutions from being accused or blamed, should something ever happen.

Hi Marcel,

I said that I didn't particularly agree with banning taking pics. What I was trying to convey is that not everyone with a camera is always taking innocent pics and it is a difficult job for those that have to make that decision to assess. Councils are made up of us allegedly (people & community). They will of course try to protect themselves.

Hope that helps.

Chris :)
 
I wonder if Nicky Campbell would care to enlighten the rest of us as to what a terrorist or a paedophile looks like.

I work with children, some of whom have been photographed. The photographs have reduced hardened judges, barristers and police to tears.

I'm sure that's true. I remember having a driving lesson the day after my instructor had finished jury service. He'd spent the previous week being shown images of child abuse taken by the abuser - shaken wasn't the word.

But just as knife crime doesn't mean we can't cut things in the kitchen, it doesn't follow that because some paedophiles use cameras that grandmothers should be prevented from taking pictures of their children.
 
Cameras don't hurt anybody - people do
 
maybe - and I do think you're right, but nowdays I ain't surprised this happend in a swimming pool and I think that we're onto a loser if we start the fight to chaange public perception in a swimming pool

Hugh

Good point.

Chris :)
 
Cars also kill people but so far they don't appear to have been banned in public places.
 
What am I saying here? Hmm. Perhaps that we as photographers need to accept that a minority amongst the human race are sick individuals and sometimes we need to accept that the fight againt those individuals is going to mean we might need to make sacrifices and not do eveything we might want to do
 
To be honest, I struggle to get my pics of kids in focus most of the time, so it would be 'ever so obvious' what I was taking a picture of. And if someone was taking pictures of my kids, I would step in and ask why.

I saw someone recently with a digital camera taking pics of their kids in a public pool and gently pointed out the policy. That was an end to it. No drama, no interrogation.

I was in the playground today and walked round with my DSLR and no-one battered an eyelid dispite my kid and a friend being elusive. I gave no-one cause for concern and it's only a problem when it becomes a problem.

Graham
 
What I was trying to convey is that not everyone with a camera is always taking innocent pics and it is a difficult job for those that have to make that decision to assess.

But when did we go from a world of innocent until proven guilty to best not trust anyone or take any chances?

How very sad it must be to live a life in fear like that :(
 
If someone points a gun at your head are you going to wait and see if it's loaded? There needs to be common sense applied (unfortunately that seems to be lacking) but the world is changing and people are defensive and protective and have every right to be that way.
 
When the media told us that everyone is out there to kill us and steal our children ;)

What I was trying to convey is that not everyone with a camera is always taking innocent pics and it is a difficult job for those that have to make that decision to assess. Councils are made up of us allegedly (people & community). They will of course try to protect themselves

I do agree with you, it must be difficult to assess.....but if you take a step back and think about it logically.

Out of 1000 people taking photos of children in public. How many of those are likely to be for sinister purposes?
The thing is, no one can answer that, and therein lies the problem. Just because some people do use a camera to take indecent pictures of children, doesn't mean that there should be a blanket prevention "just incase"

That's like saying that all those who set up websites must be vetted beforehand, just incase they want to use it to distribute child porn.
What about computers. Some people use them to store and access child pornography. Should there be a blanket ban on computers? Is everyone who uses a laptop viewed with suspicion incase they are using it to view child porn? If not, why not?

It's a slippery slope we're going down unfortunately, and it's certainly exacerbated, nay created by the media, fuelled by money.
Sensationalist crap sells unfortunately, so they will print and repeat sensationalist crap just to make money and to hell with the social consequences.

When innocent people are viewed with suspicion by default it's a sad indictment of the world that has been created.
When parents have children, they aren't all viewed with suspicion that they might murder their own children are they? How about aunts and uncles? (IIRC a higher %age of child abuse cases are from those known to the children). So why arent relatives ever viewed with suspicion just by being in contact with children? See how silly it sounds when you think about it logically?

If I go into ikea and buy a set of kitchen knives it doesn't mean I'm going to stab someone to death, and therefore I'm not likely to be viewed with suspicion.

How many camera owners are there in this country?
1,000? 10,000? 500,000? 10 million?
How many of those people have used those cameras to take indecent images of children in public.
Im betting its certainly not many.

I'm not saying it doesn't happen at all, but let's get it into perspective. It's sensationalist and a gross over-reaction designed to protect someone for being sued, and any restrictions are absolutely 100% nothing to do with protecting any customers. The very least they could do is be honest about it.

(This is not aimed at you Blue Moon, btw, I'm speaking generally to everyone here, I just quoted you first :))
 
What I can't really understand about this! is What sort of photos is it that someone could take in a public place that would be of benefit or use? Kids in a swimming costume?, kids on a beach?..... :thinking: Please enlighten me...
 
What I can't really understand about this! is What sort of photos is it that someone could take in a public place that would be of benefit or use? Kids in a swimming costume?, kids on a beach?..... :thinking: Please enlighten me...

b****r! I was going to post the same thing as I read through the posts
You beat me to it :D :thumbs:
 
No point pondering or wishing!! The best of this world has gone and we are left with the dross.

Its simple .. The UK is ****ed.

Its not about politics or race its simply that we have let bored wannabees with a little power do what they want.

My daughter is 23, I have pictures of her in the swimming pool, but 23 Years ago is when the kids were getting molested the most.

Now the Social services etc have decreed that all men are perv's and thats that.:bang:
 
Yep, it's all a total load of BS and I am sick of it. It's paranoid idiots complaining to over zealous officials about shots that can do no harm at all. Quite simply there's no true risk here at all - it's all BS.
 
Yep, it's all a total load of BS and I am sick of it. It's paranoid idiots complaining to over zealous officials about shots that can do no harm at all. Quite simply there's no true risk here at all - it's all BS.

Yes but What do we do?

Everyone I talk too agrees but being british we accept ( me too)
 
I saw a quote recently may have been on here it may not
have been not sure. Anyhow, slightly paraphrasing

On look there is a man with a child he must be a "Perv"

Would never have crossed that persons mind, that said adult, maybe a father
taking his kid for a walk, just picked up from school etc?

Just goes to show how a lot of minds have been "programmed" in todays
everso everso PC society

 
There's not a lot we can do I'm afraid, except stand up for what we think is right when we are challenged. I know I have done, and will continue to do so.
 
Yes but What do we do?

Everyone I talk too agrees but being british we accept ( me too)

Another great quote from Liar Liar this time
If you don't know Jim Carey the habitual liar has to tell the truth for
24 hours his car gets impounded and damaged
He is asked "so what are you going to do about it?"

"nothing" he admits "I will just bend over and take it up the ass"
It was bloody funny at the time, but Oh so true as well
 
I wonder if threads like this on forums such as these are being monitored by the police or social services :thinking:

These are indeed sad days........
 
It's a very sad state of affairs when we assume that a camera is being used for illegal purposes, terrorism, paedophilia etc., when as Marcel so rightly said the significant majority are totally innocent. I agree that people need to be aware of these things but there has to be a balance. Try googling children, you get 380million image hits, me taking pictures of my own children and yes posting them on the web are hardly going to make a dent.
 
As I read this I am astounded.

I moved to France 8 years ago and travel through Spain a lot, I take shots of my son everywhere, pools, holiday resorts, local festivals, beaches, you name it I've photographed him there, except parks, it's banned here :shrug:

Never had a problem with authorities or parents doing exactly the same thing with DSLR's.

I like the relaxed attitude here, it's like, why would you not want to or be afraid to photograph your children :thinking:
 
Its the PC brigade trying to impose their narrow little minds on everybody else,god knows what goes through their minds thinking that a little old lady with a camera could be a paedophile.Lets face it the real P****'s would be much more suptle in getting photographs that satisfy their depraved cravings
 
I like the relaxed attitude here, it's like, why would you not want to or be afraid to photograph your children :thinking:
It's because of pathetic people such as the person who signed themselves as 'M' in the thread below the Dail Mail article linked to in the first post here.

This is the inane, pathetic, paranoid drivel 'M' spouts...

"NO it is NOT a sign that we live in a nanny state but it is a sign that with all the new technology that exists out there peadophiles can access images of our children much more easily than we imagined. We have to protect children at all costs and if my children were swimming at a local pool and others had their cameras out I also would be a bit worried. Two woman just got arrested of sexual assault charges and the distribution of indecent images of children at a school nursery. No one should be appalled that their are now RULES in place to try and help protect children in public places so move on grand ma we live in a different time than your generation I am sorry to say."

She/he deserves locking up... what an asshole.
 
Think about it? What damage can a camera do? ...

It sounds all nice and logical, but if you abstract from the cameras for one little moment and replace them for the sake of argument with some other object that can be used to cause harm in any direct or indirect way (say a golf club) - what is the conclusion then? Should we ban this object (golf club) from all public places because some weirdo can potentially bat people to death or cause harm to kids???
 
It sounds all nice and logical, but if you abstract from the cameras for one little moment and replace them for the sake of argument with some other object that can be used to cause harm in any direct or indirect way (say a golf club) - what is the conclusion then? Should we ban this object (golf club) from all public places because some weirdo can potentially bat people to death or cause harm to kids???
Exactly... spot on. As I said earlier, it's all a total load of BS.
 
Back
Top