Wedding photography and have a go heroes

Status
Not open for further replies.
The problem is, people all too easily manage their budgets dwon, but find it far harder to manage their expectations down accordingly. You're talking as if people are rational, they're not. They're mental. All of them. Especially me.

Belting post with a cracking finale............:lol:
 
Don't imagine any longer then. :)

I did one earlier this year and two pros for 14 hours with an album cost dear old dad the princely sum of £600.

That's £18.75 per hour (with the PP and album time) but only if you don't include all the overheads.
Including the overheads made it £9 per hour. Hardly a rock and roll lifestyle on that income.By the time we bought lunch we hardly made a bean!

I thought it worth it because it gives me the marketing material I need for the Asian market in Manchester so a loss leader for me. Really good experience but don't assume on the pricing. :)

Thanks for a straight and honest answer its appreciated :thumbs:
Loss leaders are good as is what amounts to around £200 / day

/curiosity (no hidden agenda or anything else )
Don't I remember a thread / post recently from you referring to
pricing structures, you also said that you need to factor in
things like insurance / equipment / training etc?
I guess then you must be running at a loss from that?
 
Loss leaders are sometimes a necessity Chris. Example,I`m driving to a ladies house in the lakes on Sunday morning to do a shoot for her of her horses and dogs,I will charge her for printing only.Losing a fair wodge of dosh.

Why? She is the publicity lady for 5 private estates up here......;)
 
And the same reason I dont charge for a studio shoot. Just prints bought:D

People think if it only cost them what they want they are safer:lol: not when they see the prints and want them all:D


md:thumbs:

but i do get caught sometimes:'(
 
Loss leaders are sometimes a necessity Chris. Example,I`m driving to a ladies house in the lakes on Sunday morning to do a shoot for her of her horses and dogs,I will charge her for printing only.Losing a fair wodge of dosh.

Why? She is the publicity lady for 5 private estates up here......;)

Yep I have already agreed that loss leader are good
( why else would tesosainsburyasda do it ? :D )
Good luck with the shoot I hope that it pays dividends in the future :thumbs:
 
i reckon people who have a 'have a go' wedding thread in the business section should link to their images in the critique bit... just coz otherwise people who contributed on your thread might not notice the new wedding thead as there are loads of them and they get lots in the general other threads too
 
Yep I have already agreed that loss leader are good
( why else would tesosainsburyasda do it ? :D )
Good luck with the shoot I hope that it pays dividends in the future :thumbs:


Sorry Chris,I didn`t read your post properly.I`m tired and starting work soon,that is my excuse and i`m sticking with it.........:)
 
I've still only got my feet under the table. Oh well, I suppose it saves on the hangover! :)
 
you can shoot a wedding without a flash gun.
but i realy wouldnt want to.
my opinion tends to be, if an am tog is going to step into the breach and provide a friend or family with wedding photos that otherwise they wouldnt have had.
fine.
if somemone has a fair amount of experience (assistant/second tog/whatever, and wants to get into it themselves. provided theyve given it some major though, asked for advice, and gone into it in a pro way. fine.

but i do find it a little scary when people who dont seem to have any experience, decide they want to be wedding togs.
no, were not scared of the competition.
ijust wonder how the b&g fell, when they think thyre employing a pro tog, who then turns out a load of sh... photos, or at best average shots, and the wedding goes badly.

i dont profess to be the best tog in the world.
i'm second tog to my wife, who has all the quals, and way more experience than me.


wedding work isnt easy.
it is enjoyable, but much harder work than people think.

doing weddings makes me think of the swan.
all serene and gracefull on top.
paddling away like buggery underneath.


and sadly there are a few on TP who are sometimes a little too keen to shoot people down.
please keep it nice people.
 
The problem is, people all too easily manage their budgets dwon, but find it far harder to manage their expectations down accordingly. You're talking as if people are rational, they're not. They're mental. All of them. Especially me.

Yes, of course people are nuts, but you don't have to pander to their insanity, or feel responsible when THEY have made the wrong decision.
It's a bit patronising to think that they can't take some responsibility for their decisions.
People can choose to buy the cheapest thing going in every area of life - at some point experience should teach them it's not necessarily the best option.

L
 
Yes, of course people are nuts, but you don't have to pander to their insanity, or feel responsible when THEY have made the wrong decision.
It's a bit patronising to think that they can't take some responsibility for their decisions.
People can choose to buy the cheapest thing going in every area of life - at some point experience should teach them it's not necessarily the best option.

L

While I get your point completely Lois the unfortunate results of so many poorly equipped (both in terms of euipment but far more worryingly, knowledge) togs being unleashed upon the wedding photography market is that they are totally responsible then they cock up someones wedding. Now that can't easily be recified. I've spent nearly a week trying my best to rescue a poorly photographed wedding from Florida. It should have been a dream wedding in the sun and the pics were horrendous. The Bride was in tears and wanted to burn them.

Yes the purchasers SHOULD take more responsibilty for employing them but from experience that's not always how it works. Caveat Emptor, let the buyer beware, is little consolation to a bride without a decent pic. Not that many are well educated in terms of photographic technique to it's a bit of a lottery for them as purchasers. There is a lot of discussion at times with the various professional bodies calling for some kind of registrations scheme which would at least set a benchmark. But that's a whole other discussion! :)
 
Surely the professional bodies mostly HAVE a benchmark - you pass your licentiateship, for example, you should be at a certain standard.
Unfortunately what the professional bodies entirely fail to do is make themselves relevant outside of the world of photographers

L
 
And that is a HUGE problem Lois. I'm submitting for my L with both SWPP and RPS in Sept basically the SWPP one gives me a relevant body and the RPS gives me one that some people might have heard of!

I just need to do a lot of work over the next few months to make sure I have the content. I've got about 3/4 of what I think I need shot already but I want a few more and in a certain style.

It's a very valid point you make. :) and I do wish the bridal press would reinforce looking for those as a MINIMUM standard, even if it makes me have to work even harder to improve.
 
i dont profess to be the best tog in the world.
i'm second tog to my wife, who has all the quals, and way more experience than me.
Just out of curiosity... and wanting to try to balance the [very good] arguments being presented here...

Are you implying that there are actual academic qualifications required before you can call yourself a pro wedding tog, or are you just referring to experience and ability et al when you mention 'quals'...? Because you mention 'quals' and 'experience' as separate entities. If they are, then that's fine...

I have no axe to grind here, just a pragmatic qn.
 
I find this subject quite difficult to comment upon ...but i'll have a go.

I understand your OP AliB but imo at the end of the day people have to make their own choices whether to do a wedding or not. People on the forums can comment as much as they want, why not its a forum. Forums promote discussions, opinions different points of view....but at the end of the day thats all it is, it's their opinion. The tog wanting advice about doing a wedding is ultimatley resposible for making the decison whether he is ready to do a wedding or not. A good tog would evaulate all of the resources available to him, equipment, skill level, risk, B&G requirements etc and make an informed decision. People are allowed to make suggestions, its a free soceity and I dont think people should be afraid to make their sugesstions.
 
It's when I see the same old faces HCK "Go on, have a go" "all have to start somewhere" The same people who have never shot a wedding and have no intention of doing so. Their opinion is based on no experience and little knowledge of what it entails. Those same people are funnily enough never around when the results are posted, not there to suggest ways of improving the pics, never there to pick up the pieces when the bride is in tears.

It may be a free societey but the responsibilities of the day are not theirs to bear and their suggestions promting people to "have a go" are grossly irresponsible and posted with depressing regularity. Some seem to see it as "sport" winding others up to have a go and fail. And when it can be interpreted in such a manner it's not making a suggestions and it's not constructive. TP is less guilty of that than some other places but I have seen it.
 
i had a go and it all came out fine, didnt charge at all but i have charged for my second wedding but only 350 under the understanding that it might all go horribly wrong :)

i think if people are confident with themselves and their kit, they can just have a go - as long as everyone is clear about whats going on, i dont see the problem

the other thing is, a bride and groom would be so happy with a shot that if posted here gets shot down, because we are critical of techincal ability, composistion and so on which the bride and groom wont see as clearly as they are not photographers
 
the other thing is, a bride and groom would be so happy with a shot that if posted here gets shot down, because we are critical of techincal ability, composistion and so on which the bride and groom wont see as clearly as they are not photographers

Glad it went well for you feebs. One question, where would you have been if it hadn't? For every ten that do go well, how many don't?

And (this is not getting at you at all btw, you work could well be stunning!) if the bride and groom don't know what they are doing is this a good reason for lowering quality and not bothering to pay attention to technical skills or composition? It doesn't matter because they don't know any better is only going to drive quality down. Still, those of us who are busting a gut to get as good as we can should find it easier to differentiate. :D
 
of course we have to strive for better, but obviously your photography is getting critiqued on a photo forum so you are going to have different ideas of what is good and what is not.

its not about 'lowering' the quality, its about not having the experience yet to produce images of such good 'quality'

in actual fact, alot of the wedding photos i have seen which are apparently fantastic and oh so good are techincally brilliant but lacking any heart and soul - so its a double edged sword

for example there is another event photographer that i have seen out and about, his work is techincally very good but hes got a bit of an abstract perspective of people and events, so his shots are brilliant but they are his interpritation of an event rather than an documentative shot of the heart and soul of that party

techincal ability is important and its something we all have to work towards, but its not the only thing relevant about photography and 5 million pictures of a well exposed bride who looks like she should be on the cover of vogue rather than at her own wedding is NOT good photography in my eyes

likelyhood is the couple will be just as happy with a couple of not so techincally brilliant but emotive representations of their day
 
how often do the clients come on here? I am not sure what you mean by people who SAY to have a go not being around to pick up the pieces?

L
 
Those same people are funnily enough never around when the results are posted, not there to suggest ways of improving the pics, never there to pick up the pieces when the bride is in tears.

AliB, sorry i have to disagree imo its not their responsiblity to do so, its the wedding photographers, he/she is the sole decison maker when it comes to doing the wedding all the 'have a go heroes' are doing is offering their advice and opinion, the wedding tog doesn't have to take the advice.
 
Quite simply Lois that when the pics appear they are not there to offer any crit, praise or advice. When the pics are quite plainly poor, they are nowhere to be seen. When the posts appear about the bride hassling the tog for the pics? Nope. strangely quiet, yet almost every post saying "should I do it" There they are, "Oh yes mate, have a go" The fact that you have not shot a person before never mind a wedding and most of your pics are of cars or buildings, don't let that limit you. You don't actually know what goes on at a wedding? Never mind........

And feebs, yes you are right about emotion, should always be aiming for that but it should also be shot right and there is nothing to stop you shooting the "vogue" shots too. :) I aim to be able to stretch myself to get all of that. Last weekend I spotted a red wall at the wedding but it was as dark as night. So I used a video light to shoot the "vogue" style shots. But that's in addition to everything from church to wide angle stuff to bridesmaids shot lying on the ground to shots on the floor of the dancefloor at the first dance. I want to do it all. :) So I need to be capable of that.
 
Looking at it another way - these "have a go" heroes could just be offering support for the prospective wedding tog.

As said above, the Tog has to make the decision, and if they can be swayed into it by someone on a forum saying "have a go" then they were probably going to do it anyway.

So who is to judge when someone is "ready to have a go?" I am trying to persuade a friend of mine to go into wedding photography. She has done two, and her work is truly stunning. But it's her self confidence that is stopping her.
 
AliB, sorry i have to disagree imo its not their responsiblity to do so, its the wedding photographers, he/she is the sole decison maker when it comes to doing the wedding all the 'have a go heroes' are doing is offering their advice and opinion, the wedding tog doesn't have to take the advice.

And that is where we will need to agree to disagree :D

The people I refer to have never shot a wedding and they are not offering advice at all. They are winding people up to take on a role that is currently outwith their capabilities. That's what is wrong.

I'm referring to the posts form people saying "I've not shot a wedding and I've been asked, should I do it" It's plain that they don't yet posess the skills or experience yet are told not to listen to those of us who do it and just get stuck it. It is irresponsible of them but they don't have to worry about it, It's not their problem if and when it all goes wrong. :shrug:

If it was genuine advice I would never have written this post in the first place.:)
 
Sorry, but that is the danger of someone coming onto a forum to ask these types of questions - you don't know the credentials of the people offering advice. What's the answer? Vet everyone before they come on here to see what level of experience they have before allowing them an opinion?
And frankly, if you've told someone to have a go, and they have, and they have screwed it up, what help is it for you to be around to agree their photos are rubbish? I doubt it would mean people would think twice before offering exactly the same advice

L
 
Plus the advice differs greatly according to how people word their initial post. One person could give slightly less info, or word what they want to say not too well, and get slated. Another person could be in exactly the same situation and just put their point across better, and they will get more encouragement.

L
 
So who is to judge when someone is "ready to have a go?" I am trying to persuade a friend of mine to go into wedding photography. She has done two, and her work is truly stunning. But it's her self confidence that is stopping her.

Making a bit of mischief but you have already judged her and are quite Ok with doing it. :) And encouraging her.

I'm only pulling your leg there. It's a valid point you make, just who does judge? Well my opinion is that if you are used to shooting people you are off to a good start. If you understand your equipment and can shoot in low light then great , you are half way there. If you can talk to people, calm them when they need calming and organise people then you are getting somehwere near and if you can control your shutter speed and depth of field while working quickly on your feet and with a smile on your face? And keep it going for 12 hours? Then what are you waiting for :D

It's a hard one to call. I do have a friend with no training or depth of knowledge at all who can take stunning pics on a camera phone so I can see everyones points of view here.

I'd like to say thanks for the very valid points made. I can only ever see things through the eyes that I have and I do like to understand other's views as well.
 
Sorry, but that is the danger of someone coming onto a forum to ask these types of questions - you don't know the credentials of the people offering advice.

I doubt it would mean people would think twice before offering exactly the same advice

L

The credentials are easy Lois. I've seen threads where 4 or 5 pro wedding togs have been giving similar advice and been shouted down by a pack of baying "have a go" merchants who would not know one end of a wedding vow from another.

And you are right, it does not stop them from saying "have a go" to the next poor soul who asks the question. :)
 
I realise you're only making mischief with that one, but this particular tog has won national awards for her photography.

So yes, I *know* without a shadow of a doubt in this case that she would do an excellent job. I've seen the results of the two weddings she has done for mutual friends, so it's not quite the same as what you are discussing here. I know her, have seen her work, and have shot alongside her so know she know's which end of the camera to hold:D:D

Let's face it, everyone has to start somewhere, I happen to think she's at a technical level where she would so a stunning job, and she can also visualise what she wants and go get that shot too.
 
Have to agree with you that there IS a point whereby you have enough in the toolbag to go and do a good job. I'd love to see her work because I often look at others for inspiration too.

I don't like to directly copy other peoples work but I do find that I have a bit of a memory bank of shots so if I see an opportunity I have got a visual reference for what I want to do.

That's another great point you make. How many togs actually visualise what they want before they shoot it. Some may still be "happy accidents" but I crossed a big bridge when I started to use the camera more as a tool to get what I visualise. There is a place to shoot what is in front of you as feebs made so well but I do also think there is a place for some more creative shots.
 
Ali I was very curious so had a look at your site. It is simple, yet gets the point across. You're an obvious professional. I am a little surprised at your very reasonable rates though!

What really bugs me of late is the whole attitude towards wedding photography. There is no 100% friendly ground.

(The following is only a spur of the moment suggestion, it is likely flawed :lol:)

I think the best thing to do would be to have a thread where all the questions asked about doing a wedding are listed. Against each question is a clickable link to a search relevant to that question. In that search they will find numerous answers in LOCKED threads. Then it is up to them to figure the rest out. It's like offering a free book. If they choose to read and research, they have the best chance of finding answers. If they don't .. much like deciding not to read the book with all the answers ... it is their own doing. It would only be the same if they asked anyway. Just because they ask, does not mean they will take what ever valid advise is given.

I really do think the newbie wedding 'What lens', 'What do I charge' etc kind of threads are one of the very few downfalls of this forum. We see a side to people in them that really can be quite uncomfortable to read sometimes, and worse.
 
The credentials are easy Lois. I've seen threads where 4 or 5 pro wedding togs have been giving similar advice and been shouted down by a pack of baying "have a go" merchants who would not know one end of a wedding vow from another.

And you are right, it does not stop them from saying "have a go" to the next poor soul who asks the question. :)

How does the person asking the question know who to trust? I am probably being dim, because I don't, while viewing a thread, necessarily know who's a pro and who isn't.

L
 
Ive not read every post but i wouldnt go near a wedding shoot, whoe baby no sir, so much expected the stress must be horrendous. Those that find it a doddle are exceptional. Those that can do it deserve to be well paid for it these are peoples emotions that the togs are dealing with in a life changing way they dont say its there big day for nothing. I could not and would not offer advice on this prickly pear.
 
I really do think the newbie wedding 'What lens', 'What do I charge' etc kind of threads are one of the very few downfalls of this forum. We see a side to people in them that really can be quite uncomfortable to read sometimes, and worse.

yep, it's a bunfight

L
 
Thanks Jo :) The reasonable rates are because I'm still in my first year so I actually want a pretty full diary and once I have built up a good solid portfolio with some depth to it then I can think about putting the prices up. There is no point in trying to pitch at a point in the market until I can demonstrate solid ability. Still got lots to add to the site once I get my PC working!

I think the business forum was an attempt to isolate some of the hostile stuff. :)

You do need a good solid grounding to do (decent) wedding photography. The conditions change in an instant. Indoors, outdoors, details shots, portaiture, reportage......

If you look at the good wedding togs on here, they can shoot just about anything, there is a versatility that comes from a good solid understanding. Having to ask "which lens" is a great question to ask of you are new to photography and attending as a guest but not one to be asking when you are taking money!

I'd happily help to write some tutorials on it but there is already a wealth of information on here and, you know, books still exist. :)
 
How does the person asking the question know who to trust? I am probably being dim, because I don't, while viewing a thread, necessarily know who's a pro and who isn't.

L


You often get links to their websites on their signatures Lois. DiddyDave, Hacker and Spxx being the most obvious. Some do reply and say 2I've never shot a wedding but go on, have a go" And the sheer negativity of some towards wedding pros has to be seen to be believed sometimes. "Bunch of overpaid, arrogant t***s" as it was once so succinctly put. It can get a bit much.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top