There's not really any benchmark. They come up for sale so rarely, there's no "going rate". It depends totally on who wants it at the time and how much they're prepared to pay.
There are two reasons for this. Firstly, anybody who spent £5k+ on a lens presumably had a fairly good idea that they could justify it, so mostly they won't want to sell unless they have to. Secondly, the 500mm Mk I was discontinued a year ago when Canon announced the Mk II, but then the tsunami hit production, so the Mk II has been delayed and it's still silly money (£8k+). So the only realistic option for most people is a used Mk I, which means the prices are sporty.
When they were withdrawn, new Mk I's were selling for about £5500. If you can get a used one for that price these days, you've done very well indeed.