What's the point of calibrating monitors...

Messages
960
Name
Ben
Edit My Images
Yes
When as soon as you upload your photos and someone looks at them on their own un-calibrated monitor they look terrible...too much contrast/saturation.

This has just happened to me and I'm wondering what's the point?

Is it JUST for accuracy when printing?
 
If you ever use photo sharing sites it is useful as if you edit on a badly uncalibrated screen they will look fine to you but awful to anyone with a calibrated screen or even a well adjusted uncalibrated screen.
 
But that's just the reverse of editing them on a calibrated screen and people without one thinking it looks weird :/
And there's probably more un calibrated screens than calibrated.
 
I calibrate my work computers too as I find it easier on the eyes because the colour/contrast/brightness is adjusted
 
POAH said:
I calibrate my work computers too as I find it easier on the eyes because the colour/contrast/brightness is adjusted

I agree it is easier to work with, the colours seem more pleasing. However uploading photos to my website for the public to then see looking 'wrong' isn't good :/
 
I agree it is easier to work with, the colours seem more pleasing. However uploading photos to my website for the public to then see looking 'wrong' isn't good :/

Are you sure that the files you upload are in RGB or sRGB and not aRGB because that can screw up how pictures look on the internet.

When you upload to your web site (or wherever) do the images look "wrong" on your (calibrated) computer or just on other computers?
 
Let us consider an example. Let us suppose that you are editing your images on an uncalibrated monitor that is cooler than the correct colour. If this image is then viewed on someone elses uncalibrated monitor that is significantly warmer than true, your image will look a whole lot worse than if you had completed your edit on a properly calibrated screen. In fact your image will only look right on a monitor that matches yours, to everyone else it will look wrong to differing degrees.
 
Using your logic would you never put your watch right because you couldnt guarantee that your friends watches are right when you arrange to meet them?

Its easy enough to explain to people that all monitors are different and that you can guarantee that printed products will be perfect. Indeed if a customer has noticed that your images look 'wrong' they're clearly interested in 'right' and I'd be offering basic calibration advice.
 
Thanks for all the responses everyone!
Phil, that is a perfect explanation of why it's worth calibrating. Although I'm not intending on doing much printing and would need a correct printer profile.

But thanks again :)
 
Calibration is primarily for correct printing.
 
POAH said:
you need to upload sRGB images

So when I export images from Lightroom is there a way of selecting what sort to upload?
Thanks
 
Ah just checked, looks like I have sRGB selected anyway.
 
If your monitor isn't calibrated, then it won't match the cameras monitor, and you'll spend unneccesary time balancing non-existing colour balance issues.
 
Other screens won't be equally uncalibrated. They will be warmer/cooler etc then each other. At the least setting it correctly will average out the problems. Mine isn't, but it is well adjusted. Looking at the critique section on here I can see all the colour differences/ white balance issues that get commented on.
 
My main reason for calibrating my screen is for printing. Sure other peoples screen that view any of my images may be a bit out, that's their problem.
But if I want to print something, I don't want all the time spent making the image just how I want it to be a waste of time because the print looks different to my monitor.
 
In that case...I shall continue to calibrate my monitor then :)
 
I have a calibrated screen too, at work I have to use the CYMK colour profile for printing :)
 
They majority of people have poor quality LCDs in laptops, tablets and phones and they really are difficult if near impossible to calibrate properly. Best you can do is just hope it will look acceptable on their display. It won't be as you intended, but best to get close.

Calibrating yourself seems pointless in this case, but then it just adds consistency to your editing, especially if you then edited on another monitor/computer and calibrated that.
 
I would calibrate my monitor if I could find a cheap way of doing so. I've gone through the Windows calibration setup and my photos look good enough on my monitor so it can't be too far off, but it would be nice to know for definite. I wouldn't want to spend much to do so as I can't see the worth of it for me as I don't upload much to the net and I don't print much either. The prints I have made are slightly darker than my monitor but not enough to make any major changes.
 
I use a Spyder Pro to calibrate my monitor on a regular basis because I print quite a number of A3+ images. I use the correct ICC profiles for the printer/paper combination. In this way I can (usually) guarantee that the printed image is going to be an exact representation of what is on the screen.

Saves both the time and expense of printing trial copies of an image before it finally looks right :thumbs:
 
Back
Top