which is better?

[LKavaney]

1st or 2nd? Thanks

 

[andrewc]

I like 1 best. The girl looks familiar?

 

[Betty]

2nd, her dress doesnt seem as blown out

 

[hellkat]

IMO 2nd one.. dress has more detail...

 

[LKavaney]

LOL! I think I'm gunna give up on this B&W stuff lol

Edit:- Ok not quitting really. I need to just work harder Thanks guys I appreciate your help xxx

 

[V8burble]

For what it's worth it's #2 for me to. Dress detail is better

 

[englandshottest2]

just imo the 1st one would be best if you upped the contrast more and were going for the artsy b&w look, wheres the 2nd one is probably best as a representation of them/the moment/day as more detail is present.