Which Wide Angle lens for film?

[AJQS]

I need a wide angle for my OMs now that I've discovered my Vivitar's been kanckered all this time!

So I have the choice of:

1. Miranda 24mm f2.8 - exactly the same lens as my Vivitar with different branding, couple on ebay, bit pushed for time as I want it for saturday's meet really

2. Sigma 18-35mm f3.5 - f4.5 - don't know anything about this lens, it's expensive for an old Sigma IMO though.

3. Tokina 25-50mm F4 - slow, but have seen some test shots and it's not a bad performer, more CA than I'd like though. Cheap.

Also been thinking of maybe a general purpose 28-70 f3.5 ish but don't expect the performance to be any good?

Anyone shed any light on the last 2 options - especially full frame performance

 

[AJQS]

What no one's used them? You Caninkon lot are obsessed with Sigmas and Tokinas.. :shrug:

 

[ecniv]

No idea... more digital for me...

I have the tokina 11-16. But as a crop sensor works fine. For full/film I think people have said it vignettes.

See flickr link, sets on the right hand side, tokina 11-16.

The ones you've mentioned I haven't used so cannot comment on.