Why do i always seem to have to use auto tone?

Messages
2,983
Name
...
Edit My Images
No
Ok ive got a D300 and an assortment of reasonably decent lenses and am happy taking the shots that im taking. BUT i always seem to have to use auto tone in lightroom to get a better looking picture than the one that the camera took.

I generally use Apeture priority and like i say, thing look ok, but why doesnt the camera give me the "richness" of colour that auto tone does? If i put the camera in manual mode and adjust settings so that the light meter bar is correctly exposed im in the same boat as Aperture priority mode, a nice pic but never as nice as the adjusted version.

If i toggle between the before and after versions of the pics, the before's look a little washed out, lack of contrast. I use the area metering mode setting, cant remember if thats the right name for it, its the middle setting on the metering dial :)

Is there something im missing to get a better photo in the first place?
 
If you are shooting JPEGs you can adjust the Picture Control in the Shooting Menu to achieve the effect you want.
 
You can do it in with Raw as well using ViewNx2. I think the reason is because by default camera will shoot with NEUTRAL colours. It is up to you to change how you like it.
 
You can do it in with Raw as well using ViewNx2. I think the reason is because by default camera will shoot with NEUTRAL colours. It is up to you to change how you like it.

Yes, the options are Standard, Neutral, Vivid and Monochrome (assuming the D300 is the same as the D300s) and there are variations of "strength" within each of those.
I think that using RAW is an easier and more effective way to achieving a pleasing result than adjusting picture controls, but the choice is yours.
 
yeah i shoot everything in raw. I didnt know about those settings so i'll have a nose through the menus to see whats what.
 
yeah i shoot everything in raw. I didnt know about those settings so i'll have a nose through the menus to see whats what.

surely those setting will have no effect at all if your shooting in raw?
 
surely those setting will have no effect at all if your shooting in raw?

I agree :shrug: RAW is almost negative like in quality hence the ability to adjust as we do

Les :thumbs:
 
There are various possibilities that spring to mind....

- Your exposures, whether judged by the camera or manually by you may not be correct;

- The lighting supplied by nature might not create the most dynamic, punchy looking image, regardless of exposure accuracy;

- You might have a poor lens or lens filter that is killing contrast and it needs reviving in software;

- Your monitor is off and not doing justice to your photos.


It might help if you could post an example from Lightroom without edits and then the same image after you've tweaked it to taste.

As an example, here's one of mine without and with a few Lightroom tweaks. I don't think I did anything wrong when taking the shot, but I have added some zing with Lightroom.

20110721_161628_000.jpg
 
The OP has answered thier own question.. They shoot in RAW. In Lightroom a RAW file has no processing whatsoever, will more than likely look awfull. You need to process it to get it looking how you want it, be that auto tone or doing it yourself.

Have a look at this at 0.40 it shows the RAW photo straight from camera

http://youtu.be/ccpOz95z31I?hd=1
 
surely those setting will have no effect at all if your shooting in raw?

I understand that these picture control settings have no effect in RAW with 3rd party editors, but Nikon software can recognise them. I don't use use Nikon software so cannot testify to that.
 
The file doesn't have "no processing". The default is to apply Adobe Standard camera profile which will do all sorts of things to the tone curve, saturation, sharpening etc.. It will also apply a white balance adjustment, without which the image will have a strong green tint. The data also has to be converted to a colour space. You really cannot sensibly look at a raw file without processing it.

If you want to see the image with less processing (not "no" processing) then try using the Zeroed preset. Here's an image imported on Lightroom defaults and then with the Zeroed preset applied. As you can see the defaults have made a nice vibrant image. There is plenty of processing going on there.

20110721_164243_000.jpg


If we zoom in closer we can see that the default processing appears to have pushed some tones too far, to the point where detail is lost. It looks like some reds and yellows are clipped. If we undo some of that processing we reveal the detail that was present all the time in the raw file.

20110721_164257_000.jpg


Lightroom should give you a good basic starting point for a usable image when left on default settings. If you want to take it a step further then that's fine. It may not always be necessary.
 
Last edited:
The file doesn't have "no processing". The default is to apply Adobe Standard camera profile which will do all sorts of things to the tone curve, saturation, sharpening etc.. It will also apply a white balance adjustment, without which the image will have a strong green tint.


Ok.... "hardly any real world processing" Even Adobe standard is flat and lifeless, maybe not quite as much as "zereod" but for intents and purpose, Adobe default is no processing.
 
I understand that these picture control settings have no effect in RAW with 3rd party editors, but Nikon software can recognise them. I don't use use Nikon software so cannot testify to that.

Yes
Both ViewNX2 (free download from Nikon) and Capture NX2 (NOT free download from Nikon) will read all the raw info. and apply it to the picture.
Obviously both of the programs allow you to change any of the settings.
 
Ok.... "hardly any real world processing" Even Adobe standard is flat and lifeless, maybe not quite as much as "zereod" but for intents and purpose, Adobe default is no processing.

You don't have to stick with Adobe Standard. There are other camera profiles available. Basically you can set up your defaults however you wish. Here's an image with no adjustments except to white balance. I've used Camera Standard as my profile - that's my default for this camera - rather than Adobe Standard. I'm happy with it as is, without needing to hit Auto Tone or adjust any other aspect of the tone curve.

20110721_170633_000.jpg
 
I still prefer to adjust each image as it comes. I guess my style of shooting doesnt lend itself to batch processing with picture styles.
 
Yes, I also adjust each image to suit its needs and my desires. My point is that Lightroom can get you to a pretty decent starting point right off the bat. Some photos need lots of work, some a little, some need none. Each is different. But if you have to routinely hit Auto Tone to get you to a good starting position then my guess is there's something wrong somewhere in the workflow. The complaint in the opening post is the need to always use Auto Tone. That is far from my experience with Lightroom.
 
well i only hit the auto button as, frankly, ive no idea what im doing with individual sliders and the auto button gives me that extra bit of zing to the images with the barest minimum of effort on my part.

Interesting thread though, thanks for all the thoughts :)
 
Ash, up to you, but if you upload a representative raw file (you could use your own web space if you have it or Dropbox or something like that to host the file) which you think is improved by applying auto tone then maybe people could take a look at it and give you their thoughts and maybe their idea of how it might be processed for max visual appeal. It might also allow some analysis of any problems in the picture taking rather than the picture editing.
 
ok heres an example, its probably a bit more extreme than most have been but it shows up what i mean. Mainly its like your image up top of the woman in the field, the images just look a little washed out and need a boost.

Taken with a D300 and a Tokina 12-24 f4 with a polariser, which is a decent enough lens, not the best wide angle by all accounts but shouldnt be the worst either, i hope :) Raw mode, area metering. The boat is still blown out but you can see the difference on the water / hillside.

5961591401_d247ece8fe_b.jpg
 
I don't know what effect the auto tone adjustment had on each exposure related parameter, but is that an adjustment of +67 on highlight recovery? If so, and the boats are still blown out then that's overexposure. That's why the scene looks washed out rather than rich and colourful. It's possibly not far over, but it is over, and the edited adjustment, while looking good initially, is perhaps just a little overcooked. It's punchy, but slightly fake looking. I bet the original is nearer the truth, but maybe overexposed by about 1/3 of a stop. What were your exposure settings for the shot?

EDIT : Actually I've just brought up clipping warnings in Lightroom on your screen print. There is only a little clipping on the boats in the original shot. It actually seems about right to me on that basis. I'm not sure what your auto tone adjustment did, but something looks a little off with the adjustments battling each other.

Also, what was your focal length for this? How far is it to the boats? In weather like this you can easily find a hazy atmosphere and that reduces contrast which needs correcting in post for the best result. The farther you are from your subject/scene the more of a problem such an atmosphere can becomes.
 
Last edited:
cheers for that. pretty intersting points. the settings were 24mm 1/80th at f11 iso200 The boat on the right was maybe 30-40 feet away

Yeah there was a lot of highlight recovery on there but that step wasnt on the screen dump, just the original import on the Before and the Auto tone on the after. I appreciate what you say when you point out the After being overdone, but the Before is defenitly a bit wishy washy, the world through my eyeballs at the time would of been something in between, shame Lightroom doesnt give that option yet :)

I will scrub the history and just fiddle with the sliders a little to see if i can get something a bit better.

*edit* actually, just hit the reset button on all the changes and its defaulted the Brightness to +50 Putting that back down to 0 gives a more natural look. So maybe its the Raw import processing thats going a bit doo lally and over exposing it when i load them into lightroom in the first place. These computers are all a bit confusing, we should all just go back to polaroids and be happy :)
 
Last edited:
Yeah there was a lot of highlight recovery on there but that step wasnt on the screen dump, just the original import on the Before and the Auto tone on the after.
Oh yes, now you've pointed it out I see that. :)

There's a rule of thumb for shooting in bright sunshine with the sun lighting your subject/scene called the "Sunny 16 Rule". It works pretty well for holding bright details in whites in sunshine. It may need a little adjusting when in ultra-reflective scenes like a snow covered mountain when skiing or a white, sandy beach, but it is a good guide for "normal" sunlit scenes.

At 1/80, f/11, 200 ISO your exposure is 2 1/3 stops brighter than a Sunny 16 exposure. Now, you had a CPL fitted, so you've probably lost between 1 1/3 and 2 stops from the filter depending on brand and grade, so that's narrowed the gap. It still puts you over by maybe 1/3 to 2/3 of a stop but it's definitely in the ballpark. It would be nice to have the raw file to play with, but I bet knocking 1/3 off the exposure, dialing in a little highlight recovery - maybe +20 at a guess - and adding 5-10 points to your black level would have you even closer.

EDIT : Actually, you might get away with simply deepening the blacks, with no changes at the top end at all.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top