Why do I have to calibrate the lens for a 50D

Messages
6,257
Name
Steve
Edit My Images
No
Hi all

I haven't used this function yet and don't have any plans to, but I can't help but wonder why it's there :shrug: is this an opt out for Canon....? Surely Canon lenses and Canon cameras should be spot on when used together and shouldn't require calibrating :thinking: maybe I'm being a bit cynical but it just seems strange :) Oh and just to pre-empt the Canon Nikon thing, please no switch to Nikon type posts as I can't afford to :D

Seriously though I would like to know the real reason for this function being introduced?
 
a lens thats slightly on the outer fringes of being within tolerances can be improved with this function. The 1d3 and presumably 5d2 also has it.

Thanks Andrew :) but thats really my point, surely a lens costing £££'s should have a perfect focus point for Canon cameras but tbh I suspect it's more likely an issue with the cameras :thinking:
 
shouldn't canon be applauded for providing a diy option when others require you to send the camera+lens away?

Perhaps they should.... and I'm not knocking Canon at all :) but I have three Canon cameras (450D, 30D, 50D) and would expect my lenses to be perfect with all three! and if not then why? as I said I can't really understand the real reason for this?
 
You should be very thankfull you have that function on your camera. I wish I had it on my 40D. If it annoys you, we can swap cameras :D
 
You should be very thankfull you have that function on your camera. I wish I had it on my 40D. If it annoys you, we can swap cameras :D

Nope, doesn't annoy me at all :D But would still like to know why it's there? is it an issue with the cameras or the lenses:thinking:
 
Canon have provided it so "should" you have a lens, or Lenses that are "within tollerence" but maybe not as accurate as you would like can be trimmed in. Good idea.

I have a 1Dslll and have checked my 4 L lens with it and found them all to be OK.

It's a usefull function but one you may not need or want to use.

By the way Canon recommend that you don't pussy foot around with small adjustments, you need to use fairly large numbers to see any diffrence
 
Camera and lenses are built to with a design tolerence, let's say the ideal is 0 but it could be +/-20 "points" away from that. Now the lens also has a tolerence of +/-20 so what happens when the body is +20 and the lens is -20? It's a perfect match! Now if both are -20 then you end up with -40 which is too far out to be acceptable. Before microadjust was introduced this meant sending the body and lens off for calibration, now you can simply do it in camera.
 
I've had no occasion to use this function on the 5D with any of my lenses. In fact Canon clearly state you shouldn't use it unless you have a problem, and mostly I think it's unlikely that you will. They're for very fine focus adjustments anyway, and I welcome the ability to be able to make these adjustments rather than have to send the camera and lens off for calibration.
 
Canon have provided it so "should" you have a lens, or Lenses that are "within tollerence" but maybe not as accurate as you would like can be trimmed in. Good idea.

I have a 1Dslll and have checked my 4 L lens with it and found them all to be OK.

It's a usefull function but one you may not need or want to use.

By the way Canon recommend that you don't pussy foot around with small adjustments, you need to use fairly large numbers to see any diffrence

Thanks Chappers :thumbs: So is this an autofocus calibration issue with the lens on the camera :shrug: Just been thinking about this a bit further... if it was a lens issue then presumably Canon would have complaints because as far as I know in the pro-sumer range the 50D is the first with this function ? therefore probably a camera issue :thinking:
 
Camera and lenses are built to with a design tolerence, let's say the ideal is 0 but it could be +/-20 "points" away from that. Now the lens also has a tolerence of +/-20 so what happens when the body is +20 and the lens is -20? It's a perfect match! Now if both are -20 then you end up with -40 which is too far out to be acceptable. Before microadjust was introduced this meant sending the body and lens off for calibration, now you can simply do it in camera.

I've had no occasion to use this function on the 5D with any of my lenses. In fact Canon clearly state you shouldn't use it unless you have a problem, and mostly I think it's unlikely that you will. They're for very fine focus adjustments anyway, and I welcome the ability to be able to make these adjustments rather than have to send the camera and lens off for calibration.

Thanks pxl8 and CT for the replies :thumbs: which make perfect sense and I understand fully :) I also appreciate the ability to adjust DIY and don't mean to sound as if I'm knocking the function, which I'm not! so is this an autofocus issue with the camera?
 
It's camera and lens - see my post above :thumbs:
Hi pxl8 read this after my previous post :)

So if it's both and I agree probably is :thinking: then if one lens is calibrated to one camera then anyone with multiple cameras would have a problem as the lens was adjusted it would be 'out' for the other cameras :thinking: seriously not trying to be pedantic but this whole issue sounds like a quality problem with compatability of Canon lenses and cameras? like I said I don't have any problems but trying to understand the why's :D
 
Ok, both camera and lens can be out of calibration, as in the +20, -20 example above.

The microadjust only changes how the camera behaves, it doesn't do a thing to the lens so if you've got multiple bodies you can adjust each one to suit each lens.

BodyA is -5
BodyB is 0

LensA is -5, Body A is calibrated +10, BodyB is calibrated +5
LensB is +4, Body A is calibrated +1, BodyB is calibrated -4

Each lens will then work on each body. The only situation where it's a problem is if you've got multiple copies of a lens as the body can recognise the model but not individual copies of the lens.
 
Might also be good to use if you use Sigma or Tamron lenses are there acceptable tolorence level might not be as good as Canons.

I think its a great idea, and one that might be very handy if i had any of the cameras. Im hoping its one that will eventually be put on all Canon cameras so when i do upgrade then i will be able to use this function
 
personally i have welocmed the idea - havent used it. but to me i think of its a safeguard. If i was hired to do a job and my lens died on me and i hired a lens for the job at least i know if its not as good as the one i am used to i can adjust it with out having to send it back and get a repalcemnt, if i could time wise!
 
I think its great, I know its one of the reasons I upgraded.

As much as canon say something along the lines of "Don't adjust it unless there's a problem" I've gone through a lengthy process of calibration and checking with each of my lenses, The only lens which was perfectly calibrated (for my body) was the 24-70L

Now I doubt very much that the fine adjustments I have made will be noticeable in my images but I do like to know that when I'm shooting, my equipment is setup and fine tuned to be as good as it possibly can be.

Makes me all fuzzy inside!
 
Thanks Andrew :) but thats really my point, surely a lens costing £££'s should have a perfect focus point for Canon cameras but tbh I suspect it's more likely an issue with the cameras :thinking:

I'm afraid I argree. It's called Retroactive engineering, fixing a fault that shouldn't be there in the first place (like the firmware update to fix the black dots) With modern engineering it could be argued the the tollerances should be so fine as to make no need for this. Wayne
 
With anything that has a mechanical aspect there is always going to be an element of tolerances and there has to be a way of adjusting it for optimal use.

I would presume that lens producers pull a few samples from a batch of lenses and these are tested for QC. Unless each and every lens is calibrated, I think the solution that Canon provides is possibly the best, and testing every lens will have a knock on effect to the cost.
 
Like has been mentioned it's to do with tolerances of manufacture of both the lens and Camera.

Canon are likely no worse or no better than any other manufacturer. Tolerances aren't a fault they are just inerrant variances in the process of manufacture, to make something to smaller tolerances costs a lot more following an approximately exponential relationship and diminishing returns.

For Canon or any other manufacturer to manufacture their products to "0" with no need for user calibration would require massive investment in tooling and staff time to make the final product. The resulting products would be an order magnitude more expensive than they currently are. For this reason Canon have picked a point at which the balance of cost and accuracy are both acceptable. On the plus side engineering technology is advancing and tolerances are constantly being improved through new processes and equipment.

Even to simply calibrate all lenses and bodies to "0" would make the products more expensive due to the cost of man hours to do the calibration and the percentage of lenses that fail the calibration needing to be reassembled or remanufactured.
 
I've had no occasion to use this function on the 5D with any of my lenses. In fact Canon clearly state you shouldn't use it unless you have a problem, and mostly I think it's unlikely that you will. They're for very fine focus adjustments anyway, and I welcome the ability to be able to make these adjustments rather than have to send the camera and lens off for calibration.
Unless there's a hidden menu somewhere I'm otherwise oblivious to, you mean 50D, right?
 
i think it was introduced on the 1d3, then came in on the 50d, and is probably on the 5d2. I would expect the 1d3s to have it as well.

I would be surprised if it filtered down to the 1000D/450D level though.
 
... surely a lens costing £££'s should have a perfect focus point for Canon cameras ...
I have three Canon cameras (450D, 30D, 50D) and would expect my lenses to be perfect with all three! and if not then why? as I said I can't really understand the real reason for this?
... seriously not trying to be pedantic but this whole issue sounds like a quality problem with compatability of Canon lenses and cameras?
I'm afraid I argree. It's called Retroactive engineering, fixing a fault that shouldn't be there in the first place (like the firmware update to fix the black dots) With modern engineering it could be argued the the tollerances should be so fine as to make no need for this.

I'm always amazed at posts like this. People who seem to expect things to be absolutely perfect and still to be cheap as chips. :shrug:

Like has been mentioned it's to do with tolerances of manufacture of both the lens and Camera.

Canon are likely no worse or no better than any other manufacturer. Tolerances aren't a fault they are just inerrant variances in the process of manufacture, to make something to smaller tolerances costs a lot more following an approximately exponential relationship and diminishing returns.

For Canon or any other manufacturer to manufacture their products to "0" with no need for user calibration would require massive investment in tooling and staff time to make the final product. The resulting products would be an order magnitude more expensive than they currently are. For this reason Canon have picked a point at which the balance of cost and accuracy are both acceptable. On the plus side engineering technology is advancing and tolerances are constantly being improved through new processes and equipment.

Even to simply calibrate all lenses and bodies to "0" would make the products more expensive due to the cost of man hours to do the calibration and the percentage of lenses that fail the calibration needing to be reassembled or remanufactured.

Well said! I'm so glad that at least one other person out there gets it.
 
I'm always amazed at posts like this. People who seem to expect things to be absolutely perfect and still to be cheap as chips. :shrug:



Well said! I'm so glad that at least one other person out there gets it.

Stewart
I'd say a bit of selective quoting there :)
First, I never mentioned 'cheap as chips' or even implied I was bothered about cost! other than if I spend £££,s (thousands) of pounds on equipment (which I have) then I expect it to work as it should and actually if you look back at the posts I didn't knock the function at all, I was simply trying to understand if the accuracy was with cameras, lenses or both? to which I received some very good replies.

I should also say that I fully understand precision engineering and have done for many years.

Hope this clears up any mis-understanding :thumbs:

Steve
 
First, I never mentioned 'cheap as chips' or even implied I was bothered about cost! other than if I spend £££,s (thousands) of pounds on equipment (which I have) then I expect it to work as it should .....
But that's my whole point, Steve.

Just because a lens costs, say, £1000 - or even £5000 - doesn't mean we should expect it to be perfect. Col_M articulated it very well. Every engineering company has to make trade-offs between the cost of an item and the level of tolerance to which it's built, and they try to pick a point where the balance is acceptable. In consumer markets that point is never going to be at the zero-defect level, because it's simply not cost-effective. This applies just as much to £100,000 cars or £100,000,000 aircraft as it does to £1,000 lenses. The number of zeroes before the decimal point doesn't say anything about the level of precision to which it's built.
 
Back
Top