Age is important to people, so even if it isn't to you there is a case for minding it if you think you might want to resell at some point.
Personally I've tried to buy any L lenses within warranty, though people have told me on here that Canon won't honour it, Canon told me they would.
I also judge value for money on the age, I know some lenses hold their price better than others, but I'm reluctant to buy something for considerably more than it cost new.
If, as has happened on ebay, several lenses are available, all in excellent condition and all around the same price, then I'll buy the youngest one.