Will my canon 100-400 is isl be redundant

den

Messages
9,608
Name
Dennis
Edit My Images
No
Hi, i have a canon 100-400 4.5/5.6 IS L , having finaly accepted that to get the best from the lens in low light i really need to up the iso ,in good light its pretty usefull in most cases ,however i have just purchased a 70-200 2,8 to give me a option in low light , and i have a canon x2 mk11 converter,i know what i will lose with the tele on the 2.8 but was wondering if this set up could allow me to trade the 100-400 for the prime lens version and gain that way as wildlife is 75% of my photography. I think what i am trying to say is my 100-400 would only come out on bright days when i know excactley what i am going out to shoot ,any advise on the canon 100-400 prime or any other options would be apreciated.Thank you
 
Hi, i have a canon 100-400 4.5/5.6 IS L , having finaly accepted that to get the best from the lens in low light i really need to up the iso ,in good light its pretty usefull in most cases ,however i have just purchased a 70-200 2,8 to give me a option in low light , and i have a canon x2 mk11 converter,i know what i will lose with the tele on the 2.8 but was wondering if this set up could allow me to trade the 100-400 for the prime lens version and gain that way as wildlife is 75% of my photography. I think what i am trying to say is my 100-400 would only come out on bright days when i know excactley what i am going out to shoot ,any advise on the canon 100-400 prime or any other options would be apreciated.Thank you

I'm not really understanding your question Den. With a 2x converter, your 70-200 2.8 will become 140-400 5.6, ie effectively almost identical to your 100-400L and if it's the Mk2 version of the 70-200 you've got, you'll be hard pressed to tell the difference in terms of image quality.

If you want lower than f/5.6 at 400mm, then that will cost you thousands.
 
I think you have asnwered my question the 70-200 2.8 is non is and the date code is 2006 ,i dont want the 100-400 sitting around doing nothing if the 70-200 with a x2 is more or less what i am getting with the 100-400 , i was thinking of the 300 f4 is for BIF , like you said going up is going to be thousands ,just looking for a trade for the 100-400 and i thought the 300 f4 prime would be more suited for the bird shots.Hope i have made sense this time.
 
What kind of low light are you talking about Den and what subjects? The 50D is pretty good with high iso.
 
Hi, mainly wooded areas ,under trees,...i find iso 800 on my 50d to be the limit for me, iso 1600 and i am working in lightroom for acceptable results.ps genral wildlife shots from squirrels ,bif wildfowl ,pets etc
 
Last edited:
I think you have asnwered my question the 70-200 2.8 is non is and the date code is 2006 ,i dont want the 100-400 sitting around doing nothing if the 70-200 with a x2 is more or less what i am getting with the 100-400 , i was thinking of the 300 f4 is for BIF , like you said going up is going to be thousands ,just looking for a trade for the 100-400 and i thought the 300 f4 prime would be more suited for the bird shots.Hope i have made sense this time.

People really do attribute mythical qualities to the 70-200 f/2.8L which it just doesn't possess. I have the 70-200 2.8L IS and did own the 100-400L. I did controlled testing of the two lenses side by side.

The 70-200 is very usable with the 1.4X converter, but there is an inevitable drop in IQ. You also lose one whole f stop with your maximum aperture becoming f/4.

Used with the 2X converter you lose two whole stops with your maximum aperture becoming f/5.6 and you absolutely need to stop down a stop or two to make up for the IQ loss from the 2XTC, which means working at f/8 or f/11. Focusing will be much slower and the lens will nowhere near match the quality of the 100-400L used wide open - regardless of whether you stop down or not.

The 70-200 2,8L is an excellent lens - but it's a zoom and should be used to it's strengths - fitting a converter behind a zoom is never a good idea.

If you forsake your 100-400L for the 70-200 I think it will be a big mistake you'll be bound to regret if it's wildlife you're interested in. The 100-400L still gives the best bang for your buck as far as wildlife and reach is concerned without spending a few grand! The only other lens I'd recommend in the same price range (Canon anyway) is the 400mm f/5.6L- it doesn't have IS but being a prime it's tack sharp - a mite sharper in fact than the 100-400L not that I ever had any complaints about the sharpness of my 100-400L.
 
Last edited:
The original 70-200 and 2x is woeful.
 
Hi, i have a canon 100-400 4.5/5.6 IS L , having finaly accepted that to get the best from the lens in low light i really need to up the iso ,in good light its pretty usefull in most cases ,however i have just purchased a 70-200 2,8 to give me a option in low light , and i have a canon x2 mk11 converter,i know what i will lose with the tele on the 2.8 but was wondering if this set up could allow me to trade the 100-400 for the prime lens version and gain that way as wildlife is 75% of my photography. I think what i am trying to say is my 100-400 would only come out on bright days when i know excactley what i am going out to shoot ,any advise on the canon 100-400 prime or any other options would be apreciated.Thank you

Hi Den

Ignoring the 2xTC, are you going to miss the 200-400mm range flexibility if you do decde to trade up for a prime, if not, then go for it -> which prime are you looking at getting ?

I've no experience with the TC, so can't say image wise what you'll get, I would suggest doing some trial shots comparing the 70-200, with TC and the 100-400, before you do anything, to make sure you are happy with the quality and speed of the lens.
 
I was looking at the 300mm f4 is , about the same price second hand as my 100-400 , to be honest i know the 100-400 is not good in low light but with the correct triangle settings you can get good results ,just shot a squirrel at 1/640 f8 iso 1600 and if i dont pixel peep i am quite happy with it (just to convince myself the reason why i purchased in the first place),...i think it's time i accepted that most of the time it's down to the user(me) more than the lens ,practise ,practise practise,and keep taking the photos ,if i look back when i started 11 months ago i now cringe at some of the shots i took,i think i am going to have to get to know my lens a bit better before i dismiss it.Thanks all for the replies.
 
Really? I don't find my 100-400 anything but pin sharp on my 50D

108016257.jpg


Handheld, 1/125s f/5.6 at 360.0mm iso800. At 100% you can make out every feather detail
 
Don't get me wrong , i aslo have some pin sharp shots from my 100-400 at 400 , alas it's always been in good light ,hence the 70-200 2.8 to give me a few more options out in the field with close subjects
lapwing by den9112, on Flickr this was handheld at 1/125 f8.0 100 320mm , i am not saying the lens is not sharp in the right hands ,this shot to me was fine ,exif shows loads of room for improvement as with this shot ,1/125 hand held iso 100 f5.6 at 400mm , again room for improvement , but i am not saying the lens is not sharp
robin a by den9112, on Flickr
 
Last edited:
i think i am going to have to get to know my lens a bit better before i dismiss it.Thanks all for the replies.

I think that is a wise move Den, I had a 300mm once before. Great lens and tack sharp even with the 1.4, I have not had my 100-400 that long really so I am still in the experimenting stage, the other thing I like about it is that it covers the distance I normaly shoot at, plus it still delivers a good image throughout the zoom range for candids etc.
 
den said:
I was looking at the 300mm f4 is ........Thanks all for the replies.

Hi I've the 300 F4 IS and really like it, get very nice results with it. I'm hoping to get a TC next year do looking forward to trying that with it.
 
If you have not seen this already Den then take a look at what can be achieved with the 50D in far from perfect light. The last Nuthatch shot by Stuarthttp://www.talkphotography.co.uk/forums/showthread.php?t=363965&page=2 This was down in the woods and from what I can remember about 15.30hrs so light was getting bad as we decided to pack it in a few minutes after.
 
Last edited:
I was looking at the 300mm f4 is
I've recently rented this lens and I'm blown away by the IQ even with a 1.4x TC (Kenko). I was considering it for our January trip to the Galapagos but I'll probably go with the 100-400 because of its versatility.
I think I'll try for the 300F4L next spring for flying insects.



The only other lens I'd recommend in the same price range (Canon anyway) is the 400mm f/5.6L- it doesn't have IS but being a prime it's tack sharp - a mite sharper in fact than the 100-400L not that I ever had any complaints about the sharpness of my 100-400L.
Have you tried this lens with a 1.4x TC?
 
Have you tried this lens with a 1.4x TC?

The 400mm f/5.6?

No, in fact I've not used the lens, but seen plenty of cracking results from it. I think the lens would be my choice if I was replacing that focal length today.

It will only retain AF with the 1.4X TC on a 1 Series body of course, but being a prime it should perform well.
 
I think i have decided what i want ,i am going to keep the 100-400 which with my 50D is fine especialy when i am shooting in continious mode,as said keep the 50d . I am looking now for a full frame that is suited for some landscape/portrait and the wildlife when it's close up ,for reach it will be the 50d and 100-400 , i don't mind carrying two cameras so i can then choose accordingly,what i want out of the FF is quality when close and i have the time to compose and shoot ,not bothered about bells and whistles just good close up quality. My searching sugest for around £1000 i may get a 5d2 , the 50d will get more use than a ff and it will be only for close still wild life (if that happens) and the odd portrait/landscape shots.Any advice would be apreciated .Thanks
 
I started pondering my options on Saturday when I had to stop shooting at a rugby match at around 15:30 because it got too dark for my 7D/100-400L combo even at ISO6400.

Had pretty much the same thoughts with regards to a 70-200L 2.8 but then realised without a teleconverter I'd be losing range so would probably need to crop and with a teleconverter I wouldn't be much better off with regards to aperture.

Seeing as I don't take pictures of Rugby for a living, I have no justification for spending thousands on a fast prime and in future will accept bad light light like heavy rain ;)
 
I think i have decided what i want ,i am going to keep the 100-400 which with my 50D is fine especialy when i am shooting in continious mode,as said keep the 50d . I am looking now for a full frame that is suited for some landscape/portrait and the wildlife when it's close up ,for reach it will be the 50d and 100-400 , i don't mind carrying two cameras so i can then choose accordingly,what i want out of the FF is quality when close and i have the time to compose and shoot ,not bothered about bells and whistles just good close up quality. My searching sugest for around £1000 i may get a 5d2 , the 50d will get more use than a ff and it will be only for close still wild life (if that happens) and the odd portrait/landscape shots.Any advice would be apreciated .Thanks

Wise choice I think. Your current 50D and 100-400L gives you good reach which you're not going to better without spending a lot of money on glass and a full frame body will give you the quality you need for portraits etc. :thumbs:
 
Hello Den,

I don't know if this will be of any use to you, but, whilst i don't have any experience with the 100-400L, I can tell you that the 400 f5.6 is a nice and sharp lens. I own this, in addition to the 70-200L II, and thought about ditching my 400 if i bought a 2x for my 70-200L II, however the image quality pretty much rivals that or the 100-400 (I saw the comparison in another thread on this forum!), so this would lead me to believe there's still a purpose for my 400 prime as at that length, it is still a sharper lens.

Here is a shot, wide open at f5.6 (Using the 400 f5.6) with no sharpening applied:


IMG_8068_2 by GraemeWilletts, on Flickr

Now I wonder if the NEW 100-400 IS II L will be better than the bare 400 f5.6 prime??

Anyway, hope I helped a little, just thought I'd take 5 mins out my break to write a response.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top