will you ever go back to your photographic roots

  • Thread starter Thread starter ditchdigger
  • Start date Start date
D

ditchdigger

Guest
ive only been away a year from black and white film

how i miss it and how simple a F3 now seems compared to my d700

i hate all the manipulation and false images [ime guilty as well]

on Friday night i took 800 pictures its ridiculous isn't it?.

so today went into Blackwell's S/H photo section to look for old books and inspiration

i came away with a Ansel Adams book with great images and short stories on how he worked...its very hard to put the book down!

also a Edward Weston book in English,French and German

both books show the beauty of tonal ranges,form and composition that i personally find much more appealing than the glossy,bright, clean, digital images that somehow feel soulless in my eyes.

now ime deciding how far to go back A/F or M/F

ive kept my Nikon f3,301 [preferred at night] my 801s [which i thought i had to buy]

how solid and reliable the old M/F lens feel 28mm,50mm and 105mm all i ever needed in the old days

anyone else feel the same,want to slow down,think, want to try film again?
 
ive only been away a year from black and white film

how i miss it and how simple a F3 now seems compared to my d700

i hate all the manipulation and false images [ime guilty as well]

on Friday night i took 800 pictures its ridiculous isn't it?.

so today went into Blackwell's S/H photo section to look for old books and inspiration

i came away with a Ansel Adams book with great images and short stories on how he worked...its very hard to put the book down!

also a Edward Weston book in English,French and German

both books show the beauty of tonal ranges,form and composition that i personally find much more appealing than the glossy,bright, clean, digital images that somehow feel soulless in my eyes.

now ime deciding how far to go back A/F or M/F

ive kept my Nikon f3,301 [preferred at night] my 801s [which i thought i had to buy]

how solid and reliable the old M/F lens feel 28mm,50mm and 105mm all i ever needed in the old days

anyone else feel the same,want to slow down,think, want to try film again?

would like to go back to my Bronica ETRSi days in the eighties ... one of the best cameras i ever owned in my opinion ... but thats as far as going back goes compared to todays very versatile digital stuff. Ive been taking pics since the mid seventies but certainly love my Fuji S5 and Nikon D3 ...
 
I never left it, my 350D is great but it's not the real thing.
 
Didn't discover film until after doing a fair bit of digital photography but have totally been bitten by the film bug. Going to do a bit of home developing although at present the home printing thing may be difficult due to space!

Pop on over to the film part of the TP forums. Extremely friendly and helpful bunch!!!
 
I love film cameras in a way I never can love a DSLR, which I know is just a transient tool from the moment I buy it, with a shelf life getting shorter all the while. I'm not knocking digital, I'm the biggest digital whore on the block, and I've been in love with the whole concept from since when digital cameras and printers didn't even begin to hack it. Nowadays they certainly hack it as serious photographic tools, there's no doubt of that, but there's certainly some magic gone out of the whole process.

I'll plead guilty to getting a bit jaded with the whole samo, samo digital process and I'm going to be shooting a lot more film in the very near future - it's just more fun and there's more of a sense of achievement.

I'm still wearing two hats though - shooting birds with film doesn't make a lot of sense given the bin to keepers ratio, so I wont be forsaking digital for that, and I have to confess never really getting my rocks off on darkroom work, particularly printing, so scanning negs or trannies and dealing with them digitally gives me the best of both worlds.
 
now ime deciding how far to go back A/F or M/F
Well for me given the amount of EF lenses I have it makes sense to get an AF body, the EOS 3. Curiously, I hate manual focus now on a 35mm body, while I find it a pretty essential and enjoyable part of the process on the RB67. Daft innit? Perhaps it's that big ground glass screen which makes the difference.
 
I started photography centuries ago. We had to meter separately, focus manually, and on some lenses stop down manually prior to exposure. I didn't shoot as many pictures cos film was not as cheap as it is today.

Would I go back. Possibly. I do miss my Bronica. I sometimes get the urge to go and buy another one.

As far as PP is concerned. I used to do a lot of darkroom work both B&W and colour. It's a lot easier on the computer now. Wouldn't really want to go back to a darkroom.

Like many people I used to take loads of pictures when I first started with digital. Now I try to keep it simple, and only take multiples if I am trying to get the exposure just right on a difficult shot, or get that perfect wave breaking against the rocks.
 
My photographic roots were on an Instamatic then I went to a p&s, so I hope I will not be going back there!!
 
Why go backwards? Shouldn't you be working with film and digital together? After all it's about the process of getting your vision into a form other people can enjoy looking at. Does it matter how you get there?
 
Why go backwards? Shouldn't you be working with film and digital together? After all it's about the process of getting your vision into a form other people can enjoy looking at. Does it matter how you get there?

Absolutely spot on!
 
I started out of luck rather than judgement, as I was doing a wildlife illustration course and I needed photos to draw and paint from. It just kind of started from there with an old Praktica that was as simple as cameras came.

I did my degree in photography and loved every minute of the D&P, in addition to working on medium and large format cameras. ther was something great about taking meter readings, doing a Polaroid and then taking the shot before I put them through the dev and saw my handy work. I loved the printing too.

However, I couldn't go back to film. The costs and the timescale of D&P are just too prohibitive and I do feel that I've naturally progressed through learning Photoshop.

It's not like the actual art of photography has changed – I still use my eyes and more often than not, get a shot I'm pleased with. It's only the technology that has changed and improved.

I would love to use a 5x4 camera again just for the lens effects but for general photography, I can't ever see me moving back to film full-time.
 
I think some people are confusing quality cameras with the qualities of film. I don't doubt that the F3 is a quality camera, possibly better and more reliable than any digital camera (I wouldn't know), but my 'film roots' are an entry-level Praktica, a Ricoh that weighed a ton and a budget Nikon. None were as reliable as my current camera which has enabled me, by virtue of not having to burn through film, to develop my skills in low-light and sports photography in a risk-free environment.

There's a lot to love about film but I find that's more evident when talking about medium format film than 35mm.
 
My roots (in proper photography at least) were a Nikon FM2, which I dug out and put a few films through before buying my 20D. We still have it at my parent's house, but I've not had a chance to use it recently. I have since bought an EOS 5, as that works with my EF lenses and try to shoot film fairly regularly, certainly most of the landscape shots I do are on film.

Holding a slide is so much better than looking at an image on a computer screen and no matter how many rolls of film I shoot I still love the anticipation of seeing how the shots have come out.

I want to go even further back and get into MF, but want to get my digital/35mm kit sorted first!
 
if you read this book Ive got

Ansel Adams examples 40 pictures

you would be truly inspired to use film.the whole process from vision to printing is so brilliant it its another world altogether from digital.

i have been unable to put the book down ive also notice he dosent use rule of thirds much,but what images he produced.
 
Why go backwards? Shouldn't you be working with film and digital together? After all it's about the process of getting your vision into a form other people can enjoy looking at. Does it matter how you get there?

Whilst I can sympathise with this view and indeed use both digital and film, I have to take issue with the first and last sentences.

Of course photography would be a pointless exercise if nobody ever saw the results but there are a large number shots that I make for my own pleasure and so it does matter how I get there.

It is better to travel hopefully than to arrive. (R. L Stevenson)

Or to put it another way, the journey is as important as the destination. The craft element of film photography is extremely important to me and gives me enormous satisfaction which I am afraid is almost completely lacking in the business of digital PP.

I'm afraid that to say that using film is a step backwards, or even that film and digital are the same shows a complete lack of understanding of the capabilities and limitations of the media and of the processes involved.

Both have their place and part of the art today is knowing which one to use.

To answer the original question, I have never really left my photographic roots. The kit that I use is better but the essentials remain the same.
 
my roots and the start of photography was a D40X, i couldnt go back that far now let alone film stuff that others started with
 
On the Gadget show last week they tested a Nikon F5 against an Nikon D300 and then blew both sets of pictures up to 17m x 5m and attached them to the side of a building.
When viewed it showed that the digital print was categorically more detailed etc than the film print.
 
On the Gadget show last week they tested a Nikon F5 against an Nikon D300 and then blew both sets of pictures up to 17m x 5m and attached them to the side of a building.
When viewed it showed that the digital print was categorically more detailed etc than the film print.

I wonder which would have been more detailed between a Nikon D300 and a large or even medium format film camera? :lol:
 
i have only ever done photography as digital largely as i was unable to afford film and processing. That said however i try to do as little processing as possible, mainly cropping and raw processing :)
 
Hi

I started, at school in 1975. By 1978 I was working as a trainee staff photographer on a local newspaper. We shot on Nikon FM2s, totally manual, totally black and white. To this day I can look at light and tell you what you need to set the exposure for. We printed all our own photographs, using a superb leica enlarger. Again I can still look at a negative and tell you what grade paper and how many seconds to expose for.

I then worked for the nationals for a few years and it was more about getting a shot rather than what we shot.

I then left newspapers and moved into commercial photography. We were over equipped, Sinar P2 5x4, Haselblad ELX, Nikon F4s. A darkroom with 5x4 to 35mm enlargers and an Ilford dry to dry processor.

I was one of the first in Essex to go digital and I love it. Never do I hanker for the darkroom. Its fantastic working on screen and seeing what is possible and then pressing the button in qimage to get fantastic prints. My only sadness is I earn my living at it and by the time I have finished taking and printing for customers I rarely get out to take photos for me.

I can still remember the very first photo I had published. It was a group of lads playing in the snow at a place called Wilsons corner in Brentwood. I was a lad myself - so much so that after working at the paper for a week I asked for a day off so I could pop into school and tell them I was not returning - I had started the job in the easter holidays thinking that if I did not like it I would just carry on at school.

that was my first photo but my favourite is the next one I take :):) so no I do not look to return to my roots, although they were a great time

stew
 
if you read this book Ive got

Ansel Adams examples 40 pictures

you would be truly inspired to use film.the whole process from vision to printing is so brilliant it its another world altogether from digital.

I went to see the Ansel Adams exhibition at The Hayward a few years ago.

It was alright.

I was far more inspired by the William Eggleston exhibition that was on at the same time.
 
On the Gadget show last week they tested a Nikon F5 against an Nikon D300 and then blew both sets of pictures up to 17m x 5m and attached them to the side of a building.
When viewed it showed that the digital print was categorically more detailed etc than the film print.

I didn't see it, but I heard about it. I think if they'd tested against a MF camera it would have been fairer, not to mention more useful.
 
On the Gadget show last week they tested a Nikon F5 against an Nikon D300 and then blew both sets of pictures up to 17m x 5m and attached them to the side of a building.
When viewed it showed that the digital print was categorically more detailed etc than the film print.


Wait what...eh ?

I would love to see the enlarger they used for a 17 x 5 meter film print...:lol:

They scanned the film neg and printed a digital file, that type of test is not worth the 4 oak trees it was printed on.
The film image produced is only as good as the scanner used to convert it to a digital file.
Its not really feasible or easy to convert a 35mm film neg to a 17 x 5m image, they spent more time talking about the printer and made no mention whatsoever of the origins of the scan, which renders the test completely useless.
I don't think you need to go that big to see a difference anyway, check with a loupe an 8x10 print from a d700 file using any printer on Earth, and compare that with an 8x10 enlarger print of a 35mm frame.

The Gadget Show (not to be taken seriously):)
 
Aha!! That paints a different picture altogether Watson. ;)
 
I've only ever shot with digital but recently at college we've been doing some developing. I do enjoy it and would love a dark room of my own but the way I see it is unless you're processing your own film in a dark room, then sending your film to boots/jessops/max spielmann - you might as well shoot digital. I can't see any real benefit of shooting film now unless you're processing it yourself. If you want the "film look", it's not that difficult to achieve in photoshop and being able to do that is more a craft than dropping off your film at Boots.
 
I had a Zorki 4 and Zenit E and loved them both :D I also developed my own B&W films and Prints and it was much more enjoyable than using my current gear :D don't get me wrong I love the simplicity of digital but it's a completely different skill set :) and i just long for those darkroom smells (:lol: if you know what I mean)

Steve
 
When I began professional photography; I shot with sheet film, a press camera and flashbulbs. I also mixed my chemicals from scratch using the basic ingredients, rather than just disolving a pre-mixed chemical in water.

I don't miss my roots one bit. I just LOVE the freedom and relative ease of digital photography.
 
Back
Top