Worth buying film SLR to get used to settings?

Messages
4
Edit My Images
No
This question seems very basic for this forum but I hope you can help?

The OH is just getting really interested in his camera, and is swiftly becoming frustrated with his compact. He's looking into more technical equipment, but needs to learn what everything means!

I've seen old Canon A1 type of things on ebay for around £20. Is it worth picking up one of these just to fiddle with?
Would the settings translate to the more modern varieties?

To the beginner it seems like a great way to have a play without spending hundreds/thousands of pounds.
 
Yes, the fundamentals remain the same from a 1970s amateur Film SLR to a 2009 Pro DSLR.

IMO when you are learn on a fully manual camera you learn far quicker as you have to do things more slowly and you can't "cheat". The only downside is that unless you make a note of every shot and the settings used as you take them you won't always be able to work backwards to identify why a certain shot is particularly good or particularly bad as you won't have the luxury of EXIF.
 
To the beginner it seems like a great way to have a play without spending hundreds/thousands of pounds.

As a beginner I'd advise against it.

I have a compact, and borrow my partner's gear for messing about, I'm getting to the stage I'd like my own.

The trouble with film is I've got used to seeing immediate results. I used to do film years ago, even developing and printing my own black and white, but the time between shot and print wasn't conducive to speedy learning. We knew no better then but now he is used to the instant feedback of digirtal I can't see film being the way forward.

I've been playing today with Macro using my partner's old 350D and one of his lenses with a close up filter added. I learned quite quickly what everything did because I could see the difference it made.

How about going down that route, an older entry level DSLR and borrowing your lenses?
 
For £20, you cant really go wrong. Its a good way to learn,

And its a nice camera ^^
Canon-a1-top-web.jpg
 
yes and no

yes get old gear while you can because it will only go up in price
no because film is so expensive to get wrong
 
Thanks Simon for confirming that the fundamentals are the same.

Trapper - very good point about the delay between shot and print, that would be especially relevant if you're having to note your settings as Simon mentions.

Good idea about borrowing lenses too. Body only can be bought quite cheaply, but then I guess if you're gonna get someone to lend you the lens they could lend the whole thing as the body seems to be the cheapest part!


Daft question - 35mm SLR just means the bog standard 35mm film you'd buy in the shop for your compact camera, yes?

Of course with the amount of money you'd spend on purchase and processing of 35mm film, it seems daft not to put money away and wait for a bargain DSLR to come up, even with a basic lens. That's the best way really isn't it...
 
Bear in mind that any FD lenses for the A1 won't be usable on a current Canon. That makes them cheaper, and the best value option is usually to buy an outfit with body, two or more lenses and a flash.

A 2nd-hand dSLR would be more sensible though more expensive initially, and Canon aren't noted for having the best ergonomics. The first Pentax dSLR, the *ist D, is quite old-school in layout, but in its case menus work better than knobs if you need to frequently change white balance and ISO (e.g. for ambient light or flash) and anyway it's difficult to find 2nd-hand.

If going the film route you'll want a processor who's consistent and will develop and provide a CD with/without prints, and half a dozen different films to try. The costs will soon add up, but are spread over however long the OH's interest is maintained and any investment in film can be small, now 7dayshop are doing free postage.
 
Daft question - 35mm SLR just means the bog standard 35mm film you'd buy in the shop for your compact camera, yes?

35mm SLR means a Single Lens Reflex camera (like the A1) which uses 35mm film.

The film itself may be labelled 135-36 or 135-24 or even 135-12. They're all 35mm films, but with 36, 24 or 12 exposures (though you can often get 39 from a 36 exp).

C-41 process film is for normal colour prints (and the new B&W films which use the same chemistry).

E-6 process films are for colour slides (also called reversal film).

DSLR or dSLR means digital SLR.

SLRs are also available for medium format 120 and 220 size films.
 
Don't be confounded by the waves of nostalgia for film seeping out here. I've done film for decades and the time taken to learn it runs in to years and never stops. And have you seen the price of film developing and printing these days? You cannot beat the day to day running costs of digital, the instant reviews, the exif info to study, the ability to manipulate your photos on a pc. Yes, film may well teach you the nuts and bolts of photography. But the chances of disappointment, disillusionment, and eventually giving up are far greater. Get to know it digitally first, then, if he really wants to, get a film camera.
 
I reckon for learning use digital, I'm getting into film but it's the ability to review a shot and see how it looks that makes you learn quickly

also the fact that I can get bored and shoot 70+ frames of my room with different settings to experiment then format the card and no harm done

also digital can let you be a whole lot more creative on almost any given budget as you can try a crazy idea and see then and there if it works and is worth carrying on with or not.

just my 2p, film however is fun....
 
I've recently started out in DSLRs, and would advise that you try and pick up a second hand DSLR. I will often read about a setting or a technique, then go outside and fiddle with the camera and take a load of photos, reviewing each one and seeing instantly what effect your last fiddle had on the shot. I can't imagine that taking the shot, remembering to write the settings down, taking the film into town, waiting however long, then looking at the (expensive) prints would be very conducive to prompt learning. Remember, £20 spent on a film SLR would otherwise be a 10% discount off a £200 D40.
 
I think that for learning digital is better -

you will get immediate feedback
you can take thousands of shots to experiment & play
a cheap older dslr isn't *that* expensive.

I dont know the *ist that Photon mentions, but I can only suggest you have a look at them.

Photon - do the ists take the older film lenses? I presume so? Pentax K fit?
 
For learning I would think that a dslr offers much more benefits than a film body - you can afford to experiment, to make mistakes and to fire off a sequence of shots with different apertures to see the effects of DOF and so on.

Being frugal with your shots is a good lesson, one forgotten in the days of 16gb+ cards which will store thousands of pictures.
 
I'd say have a go! Everything that has been said is right but shooting on film is great fun. If you take it seriously you can become a much more proficient photographer but this is also true of digital technology. I still shoot film on an old Mamiya 645 1000s. I shoot about 10 films a year (150 pics) and thoroughly enjoy the nostalgia. Don't risk serious money and enjoy it!
 
in a word no

film costs too much and takes too long to get processed.

with digital slrs costing under £300, your OH will be able to shoot, review and change just by looking at the LCD. They will learn much quicker with digital.

a good book and practice plus reading advice online is much quicker.



This question seems very basic for this forum but I hope you can help?

The OH is just getting really interested in his camera, and is swiftly becoming frustrated with his compact. He's looking into more technical equipment, but needs to learn what everything means!

I've seen old Canon A1 type of things on ebay for around £20. Is it worth picking up one of these just to fiddle with?
Would the settings translate to the more modern varieties?

To the beginner it seems like a great way to have a play without spending hundreds/thousands of pounds.
 
I would suggest going digital straight away. Using film to learn the fundamentals is expensive and frustrating. You'll have to write down the settings you used for every shot you take and then match the developed photos with the noted settings. You'll also spend a lot of cash developing photos you're never going to keep.

Get a cheapish digital compact with manual controls, such as a Canon G9 or G10. I've got a G9 I no longer use which I'd think about selling to you. You can change every setting yourself and all the settings are recorded in the EXIF data inside the photo. It also takes incredible photographs!

I've also got a Canon A1 with a couple of lenses (can't remember which) and, I think, also a teleconverter if you decide to go film!

George.
 
I think everyone should shoot film on a fully manual SLR, it forces you to think about the shots. You can always note down the settings.

If you shoot slide film, you don't need to get them printed (and looking at slides is so much more satisfying than looking at images on a screen).
 
you trying to say people don't think before they shoot with digital:shrug:


I think everyone should shoot film on a fully manual SLR, it forces you to think about the shots. You can always note down the settings.

If you shoot slide film, you don't need to get them printed (and looking at slides is so much more satisfying than looking at images on a screen).
 
in a word no

film costs too much and takes too long to get processed.

with digital slrs costing under £300, your OH will be able to shoot, review and change just by looking at the LCD. They will learn much quicker with digital.

a good book and practice plus reading advice online is much quicker.



I'm with him :agree:

But for another reason too - yes you can take notes of your shots' exposure settings, but film has a wide latitude to making errors and the lab you drop your film off with will always try to correct such errors; so you could always be a full f-stop or more out and never realise it with film (unless of course you shoot slides which is even more expensive & slow to get a print from)

Any modern digi SLR and a decent 'How to take photos' book will get you progressing far quicker than experimenting with film will :)

Oh - and I once lusted badly for that Canon A1 but couldn't afford anything like it at the time :(

DD
 
Back in the early `80s a friend with a Pentax K1000 told me to stop thinking about the Canon A1 and AE1, as they were too automatic.

You can simulate the film experience to some extent with dSLRs and manual focus lenses. It's like PCs or any other capable tool that can have its auto settings disabled and let you get under the "hood". Custom settings for washing machines, anyone? ;)

Just for information: The Pentax *ist D, like all Pentax dSLRs, can use any K-mount lens and any M42 screwmount or Pentax medium format lenses with adapters. It's not a quick camera (slow file write times) but fans like it for the two control dials. The follow-up *ist DS was cheaper though improved in several ways, but has only one control dial which operates for the other function with the simultaneous press of a button. Both have pentaprisms for a better viewfinder and are quite rare 2nd-hand, due to their age and popularity. They're certainly nowhere near perfect designs, but don't bother with most of the reviews, which just don't get the Pentax ethos. The more recent K10D and K20D are more available, more capable and more expensive. The forthcoming K-7 harks back in some ways to the MZ-5n film camera which was old-school after the Z-1p (or PZ-1p) for which you needed to carry the manual most of the time.

The film experience though, because it involves more senses and skills, is bound to imprint itself more. You've got the aroma of the film and the camera itself. Judging which opportunities to sacrifice to eek out your film. The satisfaction of changing rolls in time. Realizing your lack of care can ruin everything and how to handle the situation when someone at the lab makes a cockup. The Christmas-like mix of excitement, disappointment and surprise when you get to see the results. Taking pleasure in imperfection e.g. grain.
 
B

The film experience though, because it involves more senses and skills, is bound to imprint itself more. You've got the aroma of the film and the camera itself. Judging which opportunities to sacrifice to eek out your film. The satisfaction of changing rolls in time. Realizing your lack of care can ruin everything and how to handle the situation when someone at the lab makes a cockup. The Christmas-like mix of excitement, disappointment and surprise when you get to see the results. Taking pleasure in imperfection e.g. grain.


"more sense and skills" - :thinking: can't see that one being true :shake:

"aroma of the film and the camera itself" - so your camera smells? :lol:

And I love the idea that finding out you've made a cock-up when it's too late to do anything about it is somehow romantic :nuts:

The question is really which is best to learn from - film or digi - and the answer MUST be digi

That doesn't mean he shouldn't then buy a film camera too and enjoy whatever smells you think they make, and all the other good reasons for enjoying film's use, but to learn from - digi is quicker & simpler - surely there's no argument in that :shrug:

DD
 
Being an old fogie I had no choice and learnt on full manual with sparate meters.

Glad I did but nowadays would have to say go digital. You can review instantly and therefore learn more efficiently.

Also have a read of "Understanding Exposure" by Bryan Peterson.

A good read.
 
Just picked this thread up, have in the past used most things from 35mm to sheet film cameras. What film teaches you is a discipline, making each shot count so you begin to learn what makes a good shot. A problem with digital is that you keep shooting until you get a good shot, but you might take 20 rubbish ones before getting the good one. A couple of thoughts, I use Minolta (Sony) equipment mainly because I used it in the past and my older lenses still fit the Sony cameras. If you buy Canon if you want several lenses then you will have to re buy if those lenses are not compatible with later equipment, however older lenses might be quite cheap. Things like the hot shoe on the Sony are the same as those from the latter film Minoltas so some of the older flash guns might work, you would always have to take advice on that though.

Film will teach you to make sure you do not waste shots because it will cost you money and you can't see the results until later. My 13 year old daughter was a little gob smacked when talking to a person on a train with a 645 film camera when he told her he only went out that day with 3 films 48 shots, her digital had 300 shots on it!

What might be helpful would be to look around for a cheap digital slr especially if its lens mount is the same as the current models. Hopefully then any additional lenses will fit later models.

My advice, if you can pick up an old film camera with a fairly basic zoom lens on it really cheaply then the experience of running some films through it won't go a miss. If finance is really tight then go for an older DSLR but try and pick up the habits that film taught us, try and make each exposure count!

Chris
 
"more sense and skills" - :thinking: can't see that one being true :shake:

I said senses. The skills include manual dexterity. Kids don't fiddle with Meccano these days.

"aroma of the film and the camera itself" - so your camera smells? :lol:

Older cameras smell of metal, paint, adhesive, lubricant etc.

And I love the idea that finding out you've made a cock-up when it's too late to do anything about it is somehow romantic :nuts:

Just a life skill. Many of us will lose all our work due to hard drive crashes and think we can't recover. Some bad stuff you have to put up with; others you learn from the experience or, hopefully, before the calamity. If everything is easy and given on a plate it loses its value and importance.
 
you trying to say people don't think before they shoot with digital:shrug:

Not at all, but you have the option not to, with film you have to make the shots count ;)
 
Film SLR`s are only fun if you do your own developing, enlarging and printing. I remember years ago when I had the full range of Canon SLR`s AV1 to the F1N I enjoyed going out on Sunday for the day then home to do the spadework. Going to bed that night leaving my 10 * 8 shots to dry. You know if I were to buy a S/H SLR it would be a Praktica, built like a tank and last for years. Not like the Canon rubbish shutter system.
 
Film SLR`s are only fun if you do your own developing, enlarging and printing. I remember years ago when I had the full range of Canon SLR`s AV1 to the F1N I enjoyed going out on Sunday for the day then home to do the spadework. Going to bed that night leaving my 10 * 8 shots to dry. You know if I were to buy a S/H SLR it would be a Praktica, built like a tank and last for years. Not like the Canon rubbish shutter system.

We used to do all of that, I had an agfa camera where the front flipped down bringing the lens out on a short bellows, and an enlarger that folded up into a suitcase. I'm sure it was russian but don't recall the make.
 
I had an agfa camera where the front flipped down bringing the lens out on a short bellows.

I have and still use one of those.

and an enlarger that folded up into a suitcase. I'm sure it was russian but don't recall the make.

I have one of those too (but I don't use it). I can't remember the make either but it is definitely Russian (could be Zenit).


Steve.
 
Film SLR`s are only fun if you do your own developing, enlarging and printing.

They are only fun if you enjoy using them. You can still have fun with them if you get someone else to do your processing and printing.

Digital also is only fun if you enjoy using it..... I don't.


Steve.
 
Do both
Be scientific about it

Explore 1 setting at a time on the digital camera - ISO, apeture, shutter speed etc. etc.. analyse and understand the results - come back when you dont understand the results.

Pop the camera on autom, and expore the relationship between noise and ISO

Pop the camera on apeture prioritory, and see how depth of field changes with apeture.. Does the image deterioate at any point - look at fringing and edges

Pop the camera on shutter prioritory - learn what you can hand hold, and what needs a tripod. Learn how quick the shutter has to be to stop movement

Look at the EXIF data for a well exposed shot - pop the camera on manual, and reshoot the shot, adjusting the shutter 1 step. How far in what direction do you need to change the apeture to get a well exposed shot again. Repeat through the range. write all the settings down. Does a patern develop?

At this point read up online about equivelent exposure and depth of field



Then when you understand the results, test your new knoledge on the film camera

to change ISO on film you need a new film, so choose 2 extreeme ones (100, 1000 etc.. )
on a roll of 36, you can explore a few of the settings easily. Tesco's can develop and whack them onto a DVD easily and cheaply - so side by side comparisons are easy

How does film compare to digital.. What about colour rendition?

Now would be a good time to expore the white balance function on a camera - use all the settings - what happens. Can you set it to suit the environment?

Remember - learn using small deliberate steps and measure and analyse the results
 
Don't be confounded by the waves of nostalgia for film seeping out here. I've done film for decades and the time taken to learn it runs in to years and never stops. And have you seen the price of film developing and printing these days? You cannot beat the day to day running costs of digital, the instant reviews, the exif info to study, the ability to manipulate your photos on a pc. Yes, film may well teach you the nuts and bolts of photography. But the chances of disappointment, disillusionment, and eventually giving up are far greater. Get to know it digitally first, then, if he really wants to, get a film camera.

:agree:Absolutely!

I started in the 60's with a 35mm rangefinder, no meter, obviously no autofocus, A notebook to jot down my settings etc etc. And it took ages and cost a relative fortune to get any sort of feel for what I was doing.

It makes way more sense to go digital and get instant feedback to the changes you're making to the camera settings. Buy a cheap obsolete DSLR and go with that, forget the latest all bells and whistles models for now, amateurs really tend to mollycoddle their kit and you can often pick unfashionable kit up quite cheaply. No insult intended to anyone but (say) a Canon 300D in silver won't have a lot of resale value, or even a D30 or D60 or 10D would be fine. Slow to start up and so on, but so what...

You can always go for film later if you want to. But if you want to learn the basics quickly I think digital has the edge here.
 
I say make film compulsory..

No but really, don't all students have to begin studies using an all manual film camera, there's obviously a reason for that, it has my full support...:lol:

On the other hand, how many got interested in photography because it was digital, and how many fall by the wayside during study because they are too flakey to hack film and give it up altogether ?

I think if you want a foreign holiday most years, the film camera is worth a shot, ya never know, he might give it up..:D
 
WOW :thumbs: Thanks for all the replies!

He'd send me a link today for a Nikon Coolpix L100, but for £200 I'm sure you can get a reasonably decent second hand dSLR... I'm thinking to do that for myself now!

I understand the love of film, and only switched to digital relatively recently when my last film compact broke. I prefer the hue of the pictures, the fact that I can't see every single blemish on a person's skin!

However, for a practicing beginner, digital seems to be far more practical. Simply because you can take a picture, download it onto the laptop, not be happy, adjust settings, take picture again, all within 5 minutes.


So, next step...... what's the best old dSLR to go for?
*can open, worms everywhere ;) *
I'll definitely be checking to see the old camera will be compatible with new lenses.

Minolta aka Sony will be out, simply because OH has bad luck with Sony products... they just break in his hands! :lol:


Thanks again - what a brilliant and welcoming forum! :clap:
 
Just pointed OH in the direction of this thread and he's asked me to convey a seriously big thanks to everyone from him. :)
 
Def go down the DSLR route.

I was thinking of getting a film SLR, there are plenty of old minoltas that I can use my lenses on for less than £20.

I am still gonna get one for a blast, but i know that from my hundreds of snaps (mostly rubbish) :) I prob would of thrown the film SLR in the bin
 
Back
Top