I've learned my leasson posting examples here only for someone viewing on some crappy mobile device to tell me I'm wrong
We will no doubt disagree on and what makes an image have that certain special value and I suppose it is a personal thing and personally although great light can make an image striking, and I do like that, personally I often look for and seek to capture something... more, different...
This guy says it better than I can...
http://theonlinephotographer.typepad.com/the_online_photographer/blog_index.html/page/2/
"The poster taught me a lesson, too. That many photographs (many advertising images, for instance) are deliberately intended to catch the eye and provide immediate gratificationbut their appeal is often quickly exhausted; and some of the best photographs grow on you slowly , and yet continue to reward long familiarity. I still like photographs that have staying power, and it's something I look for in photographs."
For me... some of my favourite shots are the ones I very nearly binned, or very nearly didn't take