"You can take photos, but no video" - Strathclyde Police

Messages
27,793
Edit My Images
Yes
As some may know they've been filming scenes for Fast and Furious 6 in Glasgow (doubling for London) lately, so naturally there has been a fair bit of interest from local photographers etc.

One of the scenes involved blocking off a section of Broomielaw, the street that runs along the side of the Clyde, where a large stunt, involving a specially-constructed building was planned.

On the Friday night a few of us turned up and snapped away with no problem, but come the Monday, when the stunt was due to take place everything had changed.

I first got an inkling that something was up when I started hearing reports of security guards entering the crowds and forcing people to delete video from their phones, however on arrival I encountered no problems myself, despite sporting a 300mm lens, 2xtc and a set of step ladders (to clear the fencing the film crew had set up). Even when a police officer did come over it was only to ask me to move slightly to the right to clear the film crew's line of sight.

So everything's good, until the cameraman from one of the national tv networks asked for a shot up my ladders. Suddenly the police were there, demanding he get down from the ladders and delete his footage. He remonstrated, but was told, in no uncertain terms, that if he videoed anything (bear in mind we were on a public street) he would be arrested.

At this point a local press photographer stepped up and asked if he was okay to take pictures, which the police said he was, just no video, anyone taking video footage would be required to delete it on the spot, or face arrest for Breach of the Peace.......
 
Maddness,I don't shoot video so would bother me,but feel the same as Gramps,I love to see what would happen,if someone did shoot video and was arrested,another paid out coming up :)
 
I don't see why the Police are involved in enforcing commercial rights issues for large corporations... oh hang on, yes I do...
 
I don't see why the Police are involved in enforcing commercial rights issues for large corporations... oh hang on, yes I do...

We were told, by one of their, admittedly junior,officers that Strathclyde Police were being paid to provide security for the film set.
 
Maybe talking out of turn here but............

If the film company had set up a barrier of some sort to try and keep them PRIVATE from everyone else and prying eyes would setting up a ladder a looking over be deemed as invasion of privacy blah blah blah ok photos allowed as they don't run the sequence as such.
If people had video footage then that would go viral before the film was released.

Just a thought

spike

P.S I have read enough on here about photo on public streets and private property just throwing in another slant
 
Maybe talking out of turn here but............

If the film company had set up a barrier of some sort to try and keep them PRIVATE from everyone else and prying eyes would setting up a ladder a looking over be deemed as invasion of privacy blah blah blah ok photos allowed as they don't run the sequence as such.
If people had video footage then that would go viral before the film was released.

Just a thought

spike

P.S I have read enough on here about photo on public streets and private property just throwing in another slant

That was pretty much what I reckoned was the case, I was just puzzled that they allowed the use of DSLRs, which could have video, at all. They (the film crew) obviously knew some DSLRs have video as they were using a 7D mounted on an octocopter to film parts of the chase sequence.
 
I know a few DSLRs have video mode, maybe they did not tell the police that, we all know phones have it of a certain description so target them sort of thing.

spike
 
I wonder how the police will feel when all the boy racers start copying the film.....
 
From the film producers POV, I guess, it's like a wedding photogapher setting up a shot and an uncle Bob getting the picture.
 
The recent revelations about the Hillsborough cover-up have finally shown to the general public that we have a police force that can neither be trusted to do their job, or trusted not to cover for their own inadequacies.

Your average police officer, in my experience, is someone of relatively low intellect with little concept that they are meant to serve the public, not to criminalise them at ever opportunity.
 
Steelmagnet said:
The recent revelations about the Hillsborough cover-up have finally shown to the general public that we have a police force that can neither be trusted to do their job, or trusted not to cover for their own inadequacies.

Your average police officer, in my experience, is someone of relatively low intellect with little concept that they are meant to serve the public, not to criminalise them at ever opportunity.

Sorry but that's harsh, unnecessary and certainly over the top.
 
Steelmagnet said:
The recent revelations about the Hillsborough cover-up have finally shown to the general public that we have a police force that can neither be trusted to do their job, or trusted not to cover for their own inadequacies.

Your average police officer, in my experience, is someone of relatively low intellect with little concept that they are meant to serve the public, not to criminalise them at ever opportunity.

That's a bit of a sweeping statement. There's bad eggs in every large organisation, but there are also good honest people. Generally I dislike the police and avoid any interactions with them due to some bad experiences, but I don't tar them all with the same brush as I have met officers who go the extra mile to help you when you have problems.

Your statement seems more relevant if you're describing pcsos. As i have met a far greater proportion of them whom after being a fluorescent jacket seem to let the concept of power go to their head despite them having no real additional powers compared to the general public. Even so, it is still a harsh statement as I've met pcsos who haven't gone power mad and ended up in a fantasy world.
 
The recent revelations about the Hillsborough cover-up have finally shown to the general public that we have a police force that can neither be trusted to do their job, or trusted not to cover for their own inadequacies.

Your average police officer, in my experience, is someone of relatively low intellect with little concept that they are meant to serve the public, not to criminalise them at ever opportunity.

It's interesting that you say that, one particular officer stated that it was illegal to take photographs in the street and that it was also illegal to go up a ladder in a public place (:suspect:) and that if she, as a police officer, saw someone using ladders on the street she would ask them to dismount because she, again as a police officer, would be held responsible if the person fell off the ladder and she had done nothing to prevent it.

My retort of "you must be really popular with window cleaners" didn't go down well at all.... :D
 
Flash In The Pan said:
As some may know they've been filming scenes for Fast and Furious 6 in Glasgow (doubling for London) lately, so naturally there has been a fair bit of interest from local photographers etc.

One of the scenes involved blocking off a section of Broomielaw, the street that runs along the side of the Clyde, where a large stunt, involving a specially-constructed building was planned.

On the Friday night a few of us turned up and snapped away with no problem, but come the Monday, when the stunt was due to take place everything had changed.

I first got an inkling that something was up when I started hearing reports of security guards entering the crowds and forcing people to delete video from their phones, however on arrival I encountered no problems myself, despite sporting a 300mm lens, 2xtc and a set of step ladders (to clear the fencing the film crew had set up). Even when a police officer did come over it was only to ask me to move slightly to the right to clear the film crew's line of sight.

So everything's good, until the cameraman from one of the national tv networks asked for a shot up my ladders. Suddenly the police were there, demanding he get down from the ladders and delete his footage. He remonstrated, but was told, in no uncertain terms, that if he videoed anything (bear in mind we were on a public street) he would be arrested.

At this point a local press photographer stepped up and asked if he was okay to take pictures, which the police said he was, just no video, anyone taking video footage would be required to delete it on the spot, or face arrest for Breach of the Peace.......

In England that would be a straightforward contravention of PACE 1984 Sect 9 (13 & &14), they'd get roasted for it in court.

Private companies (especially film studios) paying for the local force acting as security isn't new (it's common for footy clubs to pay for policing as well), but they can only act within the law- not as private security guards.
 
In England that would be a straightforward contravention of PACE 1984 Sect 9 (13 & &14), they'd get roasted for it in court.

Private companies (especially film studios) paying for the local force acting as security isn't new (it's common for footy clubs to pay for policing as well), but they can only act within the law- not as private security guards.

I'd be interested to know if the police, in addition to the security guards, were demanding members of the public delete footage. I wouldn't think they would have any legal rights whatsoever to do so, particularly on public property, outwith the screened-off filming area.
 
The payment to the Police Authority (Not the police as such) is called special services of police, and is very common. Football, and other sporting venues pay, as do Airports and airshows. It ain't cheap either!
Anyway, as for this? I can't see anything in criminal law that would cover it, aprt from a very stretched Breach of the Peace. But it is stretching the point, a lot. Then again, Scots law is different to England and Wales, so who knows maybe there is something in Scots law, or case law that alows them.

Steelmagnet
Brady, Fred West and Peter Sutcliffe were all members of the public. Therefore all members of the public are perverted murders? No, of course they aren't. Just as not all Police are bent, in fact in reality a very small miniority possibly are. Clearly you didn't read the Hillsborough report, I think you need to before you make silly comments.
 
The payment to the Police Authority (Not the police as such) is called special services of police, and is very common. Football, and other sporting venues pay, as do Airports and airshows. It ain't cheap either!
Anyway, as for this? I can't see anything in criminal law that would cover it, aprt from a very stretched Breach of the Peace. But it is stretching the point, a lot. Then again, Scots law is different to England and Wales, so who knows maybe there is something in Scots law, or case law that alows them.

Steelmagnet
Brady, Fred West and Peter Sutcliffe were all members of the public. Therefore all members of the public are perverted murders? No, of course they aren't. Just as not all Police are bent, in fact in reality a very small miniority possibly are. Clearly you didn't read the Hillsborough report, I think you need to before you make silly comments.

Oh oh common sense :) that will make you popular :D:D


Joking aside well said Sir :thumbs:
 
It's interesting that you say that, one particular officer stated that it was illegal to take photographs in the street and that it was also illegal to go up a ladder in a public place (:suspect:) and that if she, as a police officer, saw someone using ladders on the street she would ask them to dismount because she, again as a police officer, would be held responsible if the person fell off the ladder and she had done nothing to prevent it.

My retort of "you must be really popular with window cleaners" didn't go down well at all.... :D

You can we told to remove them if you are causing an obstruction. Well she may have been right, but she didn't give a valid reason.
 
If you're outside the fences, there is no law against videoing, none whatsoever. That's Police corruption, being paid on the side of their actual jobs. That is illegal. I would report to the Police ombudsman in this incidence.
 
If you're outside the fences, there is no law against videoing, none whatsoever.

If you're in a public place you are allowed to record what you can reasonably expect to see into a private place. Using ladders/climbing trees/using an 800mm lens to shoot into someone's private property is not allowed.

Given that the land is fenced/segregated I'm assuming that for the duration of recording the land is deemed private


That's Police corruption, being paid on the side of their actual jobs. That is illegal.

That is clearly rubbish - sporting teams regularly pay the police to attend (in fact Leeds United recently took the police to court as they were being overcharged) and they often attend other events like gay pride marches or cultural festivals which they get paid for.


I would report to the Police ombudsman in this incidence.

Could be a long list from soccer alone, let alone rugby, music festivals....
 
If you're outside the fences, there is no law against videoing, none whatsoever. That's Police corruption, being paid on the side of their actual jobs. That is illegal. I would report to the Police ombudsman in this incidence.

Wrong side of the water. As for the rest - corruption? Seriously? :lol:
 
That's Police corruption, being paid on the side of their actual jobs

What are you talking about?
No one has suggested the Police officers are being paid 'on the side'!
I'll try and explain it in simple terms.
People pay taxes and rates/council tax. That pays for many things, one of which is Police.
However, private events and premises sometimes need policing in addition to that which they are entitled to get from thier business rates. Also events in public may need additional policing.
So take an airshow, for example, the public wouldn't be there in such numbers if there wasn't the event taking place. It is taking place so additional police are required, not just to prevent crime and keep order, but for contingency planning, and response (recalling of course that the controlling authority for any major incident are the Police).
So why should the council tax payers fund that additional requirement? They shouldn't. Therefore a charge is levied on the organaisers so they take the cost of addtional police.
That charge is paid to the Police Authority, not to Police Officers.
I do hope that was simple enough for you, and perhaps a lesson that instead of jumping to conclutions based on doubtful knowedge and reasoning, read what has already been written....
 
Cagey75 said:
If you're outside the fences, there is no law against videoing, none whatsoever. That's Police corruption, being paid on the side of their actual jobs. That is illegal. I would report to the Police ombudsman in this incidence.

The police weren't being paid "on the side", Strathclyde Police, as a force, were being paid to provide security and nowhere have I stated, or inferred that.

At best there was a lack of basic legal knowledge being displayed by (junior) officers, which was being backed up by that old catch-all, Breach of the Peace....
 
swanseamale47 said:
I wonder how the police will feel when all the boy racers start copying the film.....

What's that got to do with them?

There's 5 other fast and furious films they can already "copy".
 
Last edited:
gramps said:
Except that generally speaking 'Uncle Bobs' don't get arrested for breach of the peace.

They should be though...
 
Steelmagnet said:
The recent revelations about the Hillsborough cover-up have finally shown to the general public that we have a police force that can neither be trusted to do their job, or trusted not to cover for their own inadequacies.

Your average police officer, in my experience, is someone of relatively low intellect with little concept that they are meant to serve the public, not to criminalise them at ever opportunity. .

Probably not too dissimilar to you then?
 
Last edited:
Back
Top