Are manual controls a waste of time on compacts?

Messages
3,739
Name
John
Edit My Images
Yes
I have just sold my Panasonic travel zoom TZ8 and came to the conclusion there was no point in having manual controls as you may as well leave it on full auto. Unless I am missing a point? I am keen on aperture priority but it made no difference after testing it at all apertures.

So not sure what to get next and looking at Panasonic G3 (difficult for me to use as need to walk with a stick) or Fuji X10 (can use one handed) but on the latter wonder if the excellent manual controls will be just an expensive gimmick.

Any help would be good?
 
It depends on what you want to do. I find the manual controls on my Canon S90 really useful if I want to take an arty shot.
 
I borrow my OH's camera for concerts, and it would be useless without manual controls owing to the extremmes of lighting fooling the meter.

I wouldn't want one without a manual option, although I agree that auto will suit for most general purposes.
 
I have a Fuji bridge camera and because it has a small sensor, like most other compacts, it's difficult to get a blurry background by using a wide aperture. Most of the aperture settings make no difference on a compact. The best way I found of getting the subject in focus and a blurry background was to use macro and place the subject as close to the camera as possible. So I agree, aperture priority is not much use but manual and shutter priority is useful for light trails and night shots.
 
The trouble with 'auto' is the settings were designed by a technical department and the camera has no idea what you are trying to take a picture of. Sometimes its fine, sometimes its not. The trickier the lighting, the less effective auto becomes. If you are happy with your pics, may be the sort of pictures you take are what the camera's settings do well. If you are not happy with your pics, may be its time to take it out of auto. Personally, I can't think of a situation recently that I've even thought of using auto. Everyone is different.
 
the manual controls allow the slightly more adventurous user to move away from auto and try controlling the settings etc. Results may not be fantastic, but allow some experimentation before splashing out for a more expensive camera
Worked for me!
 
Just as with an SLR, manual controls are good for FIXING the exposure. The difference with a compact is that the small sensor means you don't really get much in the way of shallow depth of field effects to play with.
 
If you mean the aperture control is no good for creating a shallow depth of field then yes you are missing a large part of the point of being able to directly set the exposure controls and you need to be looking at cameras with a larger sensor if you want to be able to create that effect.
 
If all you think manual control means is being able to blur a background then you haven't grasped the concept of full manual control yet.
 
I hadn't thought about this before, but although I would never dream of having my DSLR on auto, it would never occur to me NOT to have my compact on auto! I suppose I use the compact for quick grab photos when there isn't the time etc for the 7D, and having to set manual controls would negate the whole point of using it.

Interesting - it has got me thinking!
 
You won't see massive differences in aperture values on a compact as the sensor is so small.

Try the same with a dslr or APS c mirrorless system and you'll see a massive difference.

Compacts are designed really to be used in a pretty much fully automated way as the output will be limited by the sensor and lens, which is why they rely heavily on clever software gimmicks.
 
Thanks all for your replies.

Over Christmas I managed to get my hands on my sons Canon 550D with kit and prime lens. Also a Panasonic G3 with kit lens. Both of these cameras were good fun but I found the G3 was the most fun and in my case, with my limited mobility and arm problems, made more sense.

However even the G3 presented problems hence the reasons I am looking at compacts but one that is better in low light than the TZ8. The new Canon G1X looks perfect but way beyond my spending power.

So a common sense buy would be the compact, such as the Fuji X10, but I may get carried away and end up with a G3.

Decisions decisions ---- if I were rich I would buy one of each:clap:
 
I borrow my OH's camera for concerts, and it would be useless without manual controls owing to the extremmes of lighting fooling the meter.

I wouldn't want one without a manual option, although I agree that auto will suit for most general purposes.

Same here, I'd rather catch the artist than the flash bouncing off the heads infront of me :)
 
I have a Fuji bridge camera and because it has a small sensor, like most other compacts, it's difficult to get a blurry background by using a wide aperture. Most of the aperture settings make no difference on a compact. The best way I found of getting the subject in focus and a blurry background was to use macro and place the subject as close to the camera as possible. So I agree, aperture priority is not much use but manual and shutter priority is useful for light trails and night shots.

Stand back and zoom in:thumbs:

Does the job on my old Fuji S7000:
DSCF1319-1.jpg
 
Last edited:
My own experience of using manual mode on a compact is that it is very tricky to actually change the settings compared to my SLR - it's the result of fewer buttons.
 
I guess a fully manual compact would be pretty cool, but it would definitely be a "niche" market product. It would have a 28mm equivalent lens, a shutter speed dial, an aperture ring, a focus ring, and iso dial, and a dial to set the power of the built in flash. Basically every setting is directly controlled by the user rather than the camera.
 
I guess a fully manual compact would be pretty cool, but it would definitely be a "niche" market product. It would have a 28mm equivalent lens, a shutter speed dial, an aperture ring, a focus ring, and iso dial, and a dial to set the power of the built in flash. Basically every setting is directly controlled by the user rather than the camera.


So basically the Canon G series then?
 
So basically the Canon G series then?

If you mean the G12, I have checked a photo of it and can only see an iso dial, I can't see a marked shutter dial, marked aperture ring or marked focus ring.

The Fuji X100 is probably the closest to what I mean but it does not have a marked focus ring. Manual focus is "fly by wire" only. And it's 35mm equivalent only.
 
I haven't used a recent G series, but my S90 has 2 control rings, which I use for Aperture/shutter speed. I also have a button set up that gets me to aperture change mode in one press. You can also set the front ring to be manual focus.

It has pretty much the same controls as an SLR, the don't have separate dials for Aperture/Shutter speed/ISO...
 
I Had the Panasonic FZ18. Which I used the aperture control most of the time. It does make a difference, but depending on what you are shooting as the aperture of the lens was f2.8-f8. this was great for close up photos with background blur but landscapes were all similar.
 
I use a Ricoh GRD which is not only fairly manual, the main controls are at press of button, turn of wheel and seems to have been designed by a person who would use the manual control a lot.
I generally set Aperture and ISO and let the camera control the shutter speed. I can then ensure that shutter speed is suitable/fast enough while deciding what ISO I want to live with.
For this camera in particular auto mode will tend to go to widest Aperture but limits ISO to 164 so shutter speed is too slow at times (but guess that is a 'fault' particular to this model)
Manual control is not just the ability to set wide Aperture for low DOF and as we know low DOF is not really possible anyway...
 
I haven't used a recent G series, but my S90 has 2 control rings, which I use for Aperture/shutter speed. I also have a button set up that gets me to aperture change mode in one press. You can also set the front ring to be manual focus.

It has pretty much the same controls as an SLR, the don't have separate dials for Aperture/Shutter speed/ISO...

It's a pity in some ways that the advent of the DSLR saw the general removal of the shutter speed dial. Just been looking at older Nikon pro bodies and notice that the F4 did have a shutter dial but the F5 was the first pro body to do away with a shutter dial.
 
Manual controls are good on a compact camera for the same reasons as a DSLR imho. First it can give full control to the user, which can then be biased for effect. It can give a feeling of being more involved in the process, which is important to some. You can also set an exposure and be sure that changing light levels won't affect the exposure as may happen in Aperture or Shutter Priority.

The user interface will dictate how easily it is to be used, and so how often it will be used. I've always bought my DSLRs with two control wheels to make changing the Aperture and Shutter easy, finger and thumb, on the rare occasions I use the camera in Manual mode. One of the reasons I bought a Canon S95 was for the user interface allowing to change things easily as has been mentioned previously.

Where the compacts fall down for me, and this is not just in Manual, but also Aperture Priority, is in the number of Apertures available, which limits the control the user has. This is more noticeable when at full zoom, and the available apertures decrease even more. The first digital camera I bought was a Fuji S602 ProZ, which was a bridge camera which along with having the PASM modes, also had an Aperture that went to f11, rather than the f8 which was more common then, as now, for compact cameras.

I had read in the previews of the Canon G1X that it 'could' be a DSLR replacement, (hype I know) and thought that they may have hampered the camera with a smallest f8 aperture, the same as the G12 (though that at least had a built in ND filter) but it seems to have lens that goes to f16 which gets closer to the hype, but at least makes it more versatile.
 
Back
Top