- Messages
- 1,323
- Edit My Images
- No
A fact according to who?It is a fact that terrorists do not carry around SLR's and tripods to photograph their targets.
Is there a sub forum where terrorists discuss what gear they use, I must have missed that.
A fact according to who?It is a fact that terrorists do not carry around SLR's and tripods to photograph their targets.
A fact according to who?
Is there a sub forum where terrorists discuss what gear they use, I must have missed that.
Yep, you are right. That post proves without doubt that no terrorist anywhere in the world has taken a photo of anything with a DSLR, ever.See post no. 22 on this thread.
And anyway, use your common sense. Why would they?
I think you should protest respectfully
To be clear again, I'm not talking about being asked to stop taking pictures when you are within your right to do so. I'm talking about just being asked to prove who you are - to make sure there is nothing suspect going on, perfectly reasonable. And exactly what was going on in this story.
It's not anyone, it's the police. It's not like a random stranger is asking you who you are. Being asked to give details by the police, and nothing more, is not something that should get anyones back up and I can't see why it does.
To be clear again, I'm not talking about being asked to stop taking pictures when you are within your right to do so. I'm talking about just being asked to prove who you are - to make sure there is nothing suspect going on, perfectly reasonable. And exactly what was going on in this story.
Same reason police do random checks of motorists to make sure they are the owner of the car and driving legally etc. You may be insured and driving your own car but that doesn't mean the guy at the lights next to you is...so would you rather just run the risk of having more illegal drivers on the road to smash in to you or have something done about it?
It's not like the police can just hold up signs saying 'if you are doing something bad please stop', so spot checks have to be done - it's for your own safety.
All police officers whether in uniform or plain clothes carry a warrant card and MUST produce it on request to a member of the public, unless it's impractical in the circumstances.
It will contain a photo of the officer and his/her name, rank and number, be signed by the officer and his/her Chief Constable and must be carried at all times.
You shouldn't expect the officer to hand over the card for inspection but he/she is obliged to let you examine it sufficiently to ascertain the details from it.
I've never known a case of two officers in the same force having identical numbers - the whole point is that the number is unique to that officer.
No probs Adam. Officers are identified by their collar number for everything from all operational matters to payroll listings. Duplicate numbers would cause untold problems. While you could obviously have several PC Smiths in a large force or division, each would have a unique collar number.Thanks for that confrim CT.
As far as I'm concerned this is a free country (apparentlyIt's not anyone, it's the police. It's not like a random stranger is asking you who you are. Being asked to give details by the police, and nothing more, is not something that should get anyones back up and I can't see why it does.
Sounds all a bit 'Eastern Bloc'/Police state to me, how much longer till we have to show our papers at checkpoints :nono:so spot checks have to be done - it's for your own safety.
All police officers whether in uniform or plain clothes carry a warrant card and MUST produce it on request to a member of the public, unless it's impractical in the circumstances.
It will contain a photo of the officer and his/her name, rank and number, be signed by the officer and his/her Chief Constable and must be carried at all times.
You shouldn't expect the officer to hand over the card for inspection but he/she is obliged to let you examine it sufficiently to ascertain the details from it.
I've never known a case of two officers in the same force having identical numbers - the whole point is that the number is unique to that officer.
As far as I'm concerned this is a free country (apparently) & unless I'm under arrest or have been asked to be a witness then I don't see why the Police or anyone else for that matter should know my details.
Try this if your stopped in your car and asked for your details I think you come unstuck. Any officer can ask you for your details at any time
Try this if your stopped in your car and asked for your details I think you come unstuck. Any officer can ask you for your details at any time
I haven't got a car
They have to have good reason to stop a vehicle in the 1st place & that doesn't apply to this thread
They can ask for your details/ID but you are not obliged to tell them......& I for one would be asking a fair amount of Q's as to why they wanted my details if I was just wandering around with my camera.
Whats to worry about though? Who cares if you are out with your camera and they ask who you are etc? Unless you have something to hide (ie you're wanted or actually ARE a terrorist) be polite, answer politely and they'll be on their way. Argue and you'll be there a lot longer and it could ruin your day!
I have, but that doesn't mean that I want this country or my freedom to be curtailed in the same way.Honestly, some of you should try spending time in other countries. You'd get hit with a baton in most places for not complying in the most minor way, we have it pretty good here!!
I would rather be stopped 100 times than to lose friends because nothing was been done.
All police officers whether in uniform or plain clothes carry a warrant card and MUST produce it on request to a member of the public, unless it's impractical in the circumstances.
It will contain a photo of the officer and his/her name, rank and number, be signed by the officer and his/her Chief Constable and must be carried at all times.
You shouldn't expect the officer to hand over the card for inspection but he/she is obliged to let you examine it sufficiently to ascertain the details from it.
I've never known a case of two officers in the same force having identical numbers - the whole point is that the number is unique to that officer.
Thanks for that confrim CT.
I have been stopped in the past and all i did was keep calm give them my details and offered to show them the pictures i had been taken. i would rather be stopped 100 times than to lose friends because nothing was been done.
Bringing emotion into the discusion doesn't really further the debate. ID checks or cards haven't stopped a terroist attack yet.......NI, Spain, Afghan, Iraq?Could someone please explaine to me what a terrorist looks like. The last i knew they didn't walk around with a mask on or a big sign saying i'm a terrorist stop me now. Just think to yourself how would you feel if you lost some of your family to a terrorist attack and it could have been avoided the week before for just simply asking a few questions. Dont forget when they are asking them they are not just recording what you say but how you say it. Everyone gives a slight indication when they are lieing this is an involentary thing the human body does.
I presume that's aimed at me? I haven't said that I would never give my details, but that I don't have to.As for you would never give your name and address to anyone. I take it that you don't vote then as you give them details to the voters regestary and you won't have a bank account then as you need to give them for that. You trust the people behind a counter with all your money but not the people that look after you.
Fair enough, my appologiesRVF
no that wasn't aimed at you it was aimed at people in general saying they wouldn't give there details if asked. It was a point about people saying they wouldn't give there details to people they don't know but do it every day without giving it a second thought.

A warrant card will not neccessarily be signed by an officer (they aren't in Scotland, I doubt they would be in England and Wales either but I haven't seen their warrant cards before) but everything else is correct although, not all uniformed officers may be in possession of their warrant card whilst on uniformed duty. It's not a legal requirement.
Bringing emotion into the discusion doesn't really further the debate. ID checks or cards haven't stopped a terroist attack yet.......NI, Spain, Afghan, Iraq?
Yes when someone is lying they do give off tell tale signs, but I believe that it takes time & a few more questions to uncover than a quick chat in the street.
I presume that's aimed at me? I haven't said that I would never give my details, but that I don't have to.
I don't really trust either to be honest, but I have to give certain info if I want a bank acc.