BBC News used one of my photos

Messages
59
Edit My Images
No
This was last week now but I thought I'd share it. I was visiting Portland Bill in dorest as a boat was sinking 1 mile of the coast.

BBC had a news story on it but no picture, so I emailed mine and they used it on there news artical :)

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/dorset/7884808.stm

This isn't the same picture, I prefer this one. Taken at 300mm F5.6 cropped abit.

sinking800.jpg
 
Well done. Right place, right time. And good clean pics.

Love the spray from the down-draught. I think the one on the Beeb is good, because the figure on the line is against the sky, so more defined. But this one has the guy being lifted off, as opposed to a single figure. Swings and roundabouts.

One for the portfolio though. :thumbs:
 
I didn't say a word, honest, guv.....

LOL Jerry ;)

Dare I say that I think this pic should definately be paid for. It's horses for course, but here we have a large professional news organisation. They know all about copyright, and business.

The OP should be paid their usual fee (they will have scale, even if it's modest). If there's no fee involved, they should have made that absolutely clear at the start.

With news pics like this, the BBC will quite likely sell it on either internally within the BBC or even externally with an international story. They know the score on rights better than anybody and if they're not paying, or trading on people's ignornace of how big media operations work, then they need a slap.
 
The BBC won't pay but the CG or even the owner of the vessel might. This is the CG's latest helicopter, there was a lot of criticism it was going to be too small.

I much prefer the shot you posted to the one the BBC used.
 

Well I don't think that is cricket at all. Was the OP made aware of these terms before handing over the pic, or did they 'forget' to mention it? If they did, fine - maybe they offered some other kind of 'payment' like a credit. Then the OP can make an informed choice.

Sadly, there's probably somebody in the Beeb who is bonused on how far they can get their freelance photogaphy bill in under budget. Sign of the times.
 
I don't think the terms are particularly unusual. In fact many internet forums have similar rules.

I think it is often to protect the company/organisation that receives the material as they don't have to guard it to prevent liability.
 
Well I don't think that is cricket at all. Was the OP made aware of these terms before handing over the pic, or did they 'forget' to mention it? If they did, fine - maybe they offered some other kind of 'payment' like a credit. Then the OP can make an informed choice.

Sadly, there's probably somebody in the Beeb who is bonused on how far they can get their freelance photogaphy bill in under budget. Sign of the times.

someone got a soapbox for xmas... ;)

would of thought it'd be common knowledge that submitting pics to anywhere carries terms like this, i think facebook for example has small print that lets them reuse your photos you upload unless you opt out.
 
I wasn't paid anything for the picture. Just happy that my photo was used and my name mentioned.
 
I wasn't paid anything for the picture. Just happy that my photo was used and my name mentioned.

That's fair, and the BBC only grants itself rights by this, it doesn't mean you can't use it elsewhere yourself, and this might create demand for it.
 
Quote from BBC T&C's -


6. By sharing any contribution (including any text, photographs, graphics, video or audio) with the BBC you agree to grant to the BBC, free of charge, permission to use the material in any way it wants (including modifying and adapting it for operational and editorial reasons) for BBC services in any media worldwide (including on the BBC's site accessed by international users). In certain circumstance the BBC may also share your contribution with trusted third parties*.

There was a long "discussion" about this last week.

The BBC don't pay but they do reserve the right to sell your photo on to someone else.....
 
at least I can't be acused of starting it this time, congrats op ignore the money grabbers and penny pinchers.
 
There was a long "discussion" about this last week.
Sorry I missed that but I am bothered they expect 'free' material to fill their TV programmes that they are paid (by us) to make.It's a pretty good newsworthy picture, if they want to use it it is 'worth' something.

It is a scandal that people are 'encouraged' to send pictures in and then lose any rights over them too! :eek:
 
how is it scandal? if youre expecting money from taking shots for use in the media then youre probably a professional tog and youll go through the relevent press channels.. its more for "joe public" that are happy just to get their pics on an international site so they can tell their friends (no offence OP).

if it bothers you then you should be reading the t&c's at all times before submitting.
 
That's fair, and the BBC only grants itself rights by this, it doesn't mean you can't use it elsewhere yourself, and this might create demand for it.

No it's not fair. This is not facebook or whatever, it's the BBC. This is not the same as a small local ice hockey team (debate on another thread ;) ) but a huge international media company. The OP's pic is central to their business, and what's more it's a good pic which frankly makes the story. And I don't suppose there was a line of photographers there, all with big lenses, queuing up to donate quality pictures.

What they have taken by default (as Jerry as posted in their Terms) is a right to do what they want with any submissions, even to pocket revenue from third parties. Maybe they will sell the picture on to the helicopter manufacturer as suggested above - they'll get paid and the pic will probably appear 'courtesy of the BBC' :eek: What if this was a major international story, and the pic was beamed around the globe through the Beeb's syndication facility? Sorry, what might be unfortunate but 'acceptable' behaviour from other people that abuse copyright (either because they have no money or don't know better) does not apply to the BBC.
 
how is it scandal? if youre expecting money from taking shots for use in the media then youre probably a professional tog and youll go through the relevent press channels.. its more for "joe public" that are happy just to get their pics on an international site so they can tell their friends (no offence OP).

if it bothers you then you should be reading the t&c's at all times before submitting.
Why should anyone be expected to give them free material that they can profit from?

They are being paid (quite well) to make and transmit the programmes. The viewers are paying for a licence, through advertising or subscription to watch it.

Contributions (of all sorts) should be paid for. I've turned down the 'chance' to appear on TV more than once because the leeches would not pay me an appearance fee.
 
I said it was fair, because the chap that own's the copyright, the one you are so busy defending, said he was happy with the arrangement.

That's the basis of the deal, and if he wasn't happy I'm sure he would have said so.

I'm not convinced that the BBC have given themselves the right to sell it to anybody else either, but to share on reciprocal arrangements they may have in place with other broadcasters.

As I said before, I believe these terms are to protect themselves more than anything else.
 
I'm more interested in why the brand new boat sank!
 
I'm more interested in why the brand new boat sank!


Maybe they accepted a free plug rather than paying for a professional one:nono:
 
Maybe they will sell the picture on to the helicopter manufacturer as suggested above - they'll get paid and the pic will probably appear 'courtesy of the BBC'

Whilst I agree with the views in this thread regarding payment, to be fair, they have given a credit below the picture.
 
The coast guard that was there at the time emailed me, they do not know why the boat sank, but it was clearly taking on water at the bow. Could of hit the bottom on the reef that lies just off Portland, it was low water at the time, or could of been a problem with the bow thruster. It wasn't a new boat either, you'll find close up pictures of it on the Weymouth RNLI website and on the Dorset Echo Website, If your interested.
 
because the chap that own's the copyright, the one you are so busy defending, said he was happy with the arrangement.
Me? I'm not defending anyone. I'm just not that impressed that a commercial organisation (that we have no real alternative other than to contribute to) advertises for free materials for its own gain.
 
Me? I'm not defending anyone. I'm just not that impressed that a commercial organisation (that we have no real alternative other than to contribute to) advertises for free materials for its own gain.

Well you can go without TV if that is your real wish.

the point here is that those are their terms and conditions and somebody has happily tied up to those. He seems very pleased to have got his pic onto the TV and I'm sure only expected people to congratulate him.

I think the shot is good (though I prefer the one that they didn't use) and all the people involved from photographer to those being rescued seem to have got what they wanted out of it.

I can see that it wouldn't suit a lot of photographers, particularly those used to being paid for their work, but it also suits a lot of others.
 
This is not a question of how you make a living, or how you like to earn money from photographs. This is not about how good it makes you feel when you see your photos on the BBC's website.

It's about the entire principle of photography and the importance of payment to the photojournalism / press photography industry. The fact of the matter is, if your work is published, you should be paid whether you want to be or not. The BBC is a huge organisation which is perfectly capable of paying someone even a small amount for a photograph...but they are slowly destroying the industry which I am trying to get into by taking free photos.

I swear half the people on this forum are completely oblivious to all of this.

However, i'll be the first to admit I have done it once before, I offered some snow photos to them - they didn't pay and didn't even credit me. Disgraceful, i'm never going to give the BBC anything for free ever again. Noone should.
 
Well you can go without TV if that is your real wish.
That is not my point. I pay for the BBC. In the same way they should pay for contributions that they use.
the point here is that those are their terms and conditions and somebody has happily tied up to those. He seems very pleased to have got his pic onto the TV and I'm sure only expected people to congratulate him.

I think the shot is good (though I prefer the one that they didn't use) and all the people involved from photographer to those being rescued seem to have got what they wanted out of it.
And I think even you will be able to read that I already said it was a 'pretty good newsworthy picture'.
I can see that it wouldn't suit a lot of photographers, particularly those used to being paid for their work, but it also suits a lot of others.
Well, I think those that earn a living from selling pictures will disagree with you for a start. And those that are giving away work are also losing out - they just don't realise it.

I (and most of us in the UK) pay for the BBC. I don't see what is so contentious in thinking that they should also pay for things that they use. They pay their staff. They pay for their equipment. But they take and then sell back to us contributions they get from the public for nothing - be it mugs being interviewed on TV, muppets buying homes at auction and being cajoled showing them round the house they just bought or photographs from members of the public.

There are agencies who would take these sorts of pictures and pay money for them. Why feed the BBC (or anyone else) for free?
 
It's about the entire principle of photography and the importance of payment to the photojournalism / press photography industry. The fact of the matter is, if your work is published, you should be paid whether you want to be or not. The BBC is a huge organisation which is perfectly capable of paying someone even a small amount for a photograph...but they are slowly destroying the industry which I am trying to get into by taking free photos.

I swear half the people on this forum are completely oblivious to all of this.

.

Absolutely right. Well said.
 
I suspect that Neil sent it in just hoping it would be broadcast, I have done the same with local newspapers and had photos go into print.

Yes commercial photographers would know the ins and outs of selling pictures because thats their job. The ordinary man in the street who is in the right place at the right time doesn't.

The one thing gained is that you can claim your photos are good enough for publication by whatever media, and for me and I suspect Niel, is that it is a great boost to gaining confidence and pride in your photographic skills.

By going on photographic web sites can help immensely with technique - composition and the like, and have other members talk about your photos is ok within itself, but the thrill of having a picture accepted (and broadcast) by the BBC is something else , a definate one for the portfolio.

As for the money side of things, even if a company did pay for a picture the amount wouldn't generally be that much I guess .

So congratulations on getting your photo on the tele Neil, it is something to be very proud of.

Realspeed
 
Typical, this great photo FOC, abuse down the phone line by Mr J Ross £18 million a year. Where have we gone wrong?
 
I suspect that Neil sent it in just hoping it would be broadcast, I have done the same with local newspapers and had photos go into print.

Yes commercial photographers would know the ins and outs of selling pictures because thats their job. The ordinary man in the street who is in the right place at the right time doesn't.

The one thing gained is that you can claim your photos are good enough for publication by whatever media, and for me and I suspect Niel, is that it is a great boost to gaining confidence and pride in your photographic skills.

By going on photographic web sites can help immensely with technique - composition and the like, and have other members talk about your photos is ok within itself, but the thrill of having a picture accepted (and broadcast) by the BBC is something else , a definate one for the portfolio.

As for the money side of things, even if a company did pay for a picture the amount wouldn't generally be that much I guess .

So congratulations on getting your photo on the tele Neil, it is something to be very proud of.

Realspeed

It doesn't matter how much experience you have in charging for photos, it's easy to say in your email 'I'd like to be paid for my work if it is featured'

The only real plus side of having a shot featured on the BBC is becuase it feels good to you it's highly unlikely it will do you any favors at all. The downside? In essence, it's putting photographers out of work.

Maybe 1 shot to 1 person doesn't seem significant at all, so most people just think "It's just my shot, surely it won't have any effect at all" but it's now snowballed so fast and quick (with DSLRs being so cheap and easy to use) that the BBC doesn't need to bother paying for shots anymore. They just claim the rights, build their library and make a ton of money from it. And it cost them nothing.

I've had shots on the BBC on numerous occasions (managed to get paid for one of them as well) and none of it will be included in my portfolio, or mentioned on my CV. And i'm a trainee photojournalist. It's something no editor will care about.

And it doesn't stop there, it's not just press stuff for the BBC that shouldn't be done for free. NO photography should be done for free, even for friends and family for the exact same principles.

Not to put a downer on anything (and i'm not saying anything about the quality of the photograph, it's besides the point) but it's just the truth.
 
OK.... I know it's been said before..... :shrug: But enjoy getting your photo published with the credit it deserves :clap: At the very least it's something to brag about with your mates at work or down the the pub :D

Well done for being there and getting published :thumbs:
 
Back
Top