BBC News used one of my photos

Agree - well done for a great shot. The truth is any editor would run a story with a shot like that to back it up had they had it submitted.

The free use thing and you not caring....OK so after you submit it, it turns out to be HRH Prince Charles, or some other famous person on board, and that picture and story goes round the world and would have earned you £2,000,000 ....would you still feel the same about having given it away for free?

The £2m thing - the guy that got the pictures of Diana and Jodi on the yacht in the Med - the final tally was closer to £3m, so not a stupid amount to be talking about.

Or is the free thing only relevant depending on the actual worth of the pic? In that a £50 pic is OK to give away, but one that will generate £1 million isn't......discuss.
 
Agree - well done for a great shot. The truth is any editor would run a story with a shot like that to back it up had they had it submitted.

The free use thing and you not caring....OK so after you submit it, it turns out to be HRH Prince Charles, or some other famous person on board, and that picture and story goes round the world and would have earned you £2,000,000 ....would you still feel the same about having given it away for free?

The £2m thing - the guy that got the pictures of Diana and Jodi on the yacht in the Med - the final tally was closer to £3m, so not a stupid amount to be talking about.

Or is the free thing only relevant depending on the actual worth of the pic? In that a £50 pic is OK to give away, but one that will generate £1 million isn't......discuss.
 
And it doesn't stop there, it's not just press stuff for the BBC that shouldn't be done for free. NO photography should be done for free, even for friends and family for the exact same principles.

I don't agree with that. This picture used by the BBC should be paid for, automatically, at the Beeb's normal commercial fee. They are a commercail media company (I know they are license fee funded, but they work by the same rules) and words and pictures are their core business. They know better, and they surely can do better.

This is not the same as other uses, even commercial uses, where there is no money to be had so there is no use pretending you're ever going to get paid, not in cash at any rate. But you should always get a credit as a minimum. That 'costs' nothing, but often has a high perceived value to the snapper.

Photographers always put a high value on their pictures, but this concept is outdated. Photography generally has a low value in the minds of the public today, and certainly stuff posted on line is widely regarded as free. It's not right, but that's how it is, and if you don't like it, then don't post. Where you draw the line between being paid and not being paid is a personal decision, and I'm sure we all have different ideas there ;)

As an aside and as a general comment, if you want to be paid for your pictures, then get somebody to pay you to take them. A commission. Once the picture is taken, its value plummets and making any real money out of 'stock' photography is hard - the internet has seen to that. Some people need to wake up to that fact.
 
Agree - well done for a great shot. The truth is any editor would run a story with a shot like that to back it up had they had it submitted.

The free use thing and you not caring....OK so after you submit it, it turns out to be HRH Prince Charles, or some other famous person on board, and that picture and story goes round the world and would have earned you £2,000,000 ....would you still feel the same about having given it away for free?

The £2m thing - the guy that got the pictures of Diana and Jodi on the yacht in the Med - the final tally was closer to £3m, so not a stupid amount to be talking about.

Or is the free thing only relevant depending on the actual worth of the pic? In that a £50 pic is OK to give away, but one that will generate £1 million isn't......discuss.


Didn't the photo's of the terrorist attack on Glasgow airport get syndicated all around the world, yet the tourist who took them gave them to a paper. Morgage paying shots those, but a whole different case to photo's I've had in our local paper. I'm usually grateful for the publicity of the event/sports team :)
 
Lensflare - Having a sent a photo that would earn whoever you sent it to millions after you sent it in for free would be ridiculous. It's not about what the picture is of, that would come down to your inefficiency as a photographer (i.e. realising what you actually took a photo of, and putting a price on it).
 
Oh look, it's this old chestnut again! :suspect:

How many of the 'only if it's paid for' photographers got the shot in question? Answer: None.

Even if the OP got paid for the shot, the 'only if it's paid for' photographers still wouldn't have gotten paid.

It doesn't put you out of business that the picture was given for nothing, in any more of a way than it does if it were paid for, but you weren't the one getting paid.

For god's sakes, stop turning every thread like this in to the same tired arguement and just congratulate the bloke fo getting his photo on the website, eh?

Well done to you Neil :thumbs:
 
The BBC will pay for some contributions, or else they wouldn't have included this snippet in their FAQ:

Does the BBC pay for user generated content? No, the BBC does not pay for any user generated content except in exceptional circumstances for BBC News.
 
Cheers Simmotion.

I didn't realise the huge debate this would cause. It is intresting read everybodys point of view on the subject.
 
Cheers Simmotion.

I didn't realise the huge debate this would cause. It is intresting read everybodys point of view on the subject.

Nor me, it does seem to be a subject that raises a few hackles.

I'm glad to see that I'm no longer so heavily outnumbered.

I think you should be entitled to do what you want with your picture. It would be interesting to know how the BBC decides when the exceptional situation occurs, and whether or not that is done when they realise the value of the picture they have been sent or only by prior negotiation.
 
It would be interesting to know how the BBC decides when the exceptional situation occurs, and whether or not that is done when they realise the value of the picture they have been sent or only by prior negotiation.

Yep. I'd like to know that too, and I haven't found it on their website yet... Anyone have any first hand experience of this scenario?
 
Oh look, it's this old chestnut again! :suspect:

How many of the 'only if it's paid for' photographers got the shot in question? Answer: None.

Even if the OP got paid for the shot, the 'only if it's paid for' photographers still wouldn't have gotten paid.

It doesn't put you out of business that the picture was given for nothing, in any more of a way than it does if it were paid for, but you weren't the one getting paid.

For god's sakes, stop turning every thread like this in to the same tired arguement and just congratulate the bloke fo getting his photo on the website, eh?

Well done to you Neil :thumbs:



I cant find the round of applause icon so.... clap clap :)
 
Oh look, it's this old chestnut again! :suspect:

How many of the 'only if it's paid for' photographers got the shot in question? Answer: None.

Even if the OP got paid for the shot, the 'only if it's paid for' photographers still wouldn't have gotten paid.

It doesn't put you out of business that the picture was given for nothing, in any more of a way than it does if it were paid for, but you weren't the one getting paid.

How on earth do you know if any other photographers got this shot? For all you know, there could have been a pro nearby who was sent on an assignment by a news agency and who's photo wasn't used becuase it was given away for free by someone else.

It doesn't matter if you are the only one to get a shot, you should still get paid for it. If that was the case, you'd have an exclusive meaning you are more likely to get money out of it (and in this instance, it's likely the BBC would have paid).

Every thread like this needs to be turned into an argument amount payment becuase there are so many people on this forum who are completely unaware about how much damage it does to the industry.
 
Every thread like this needs to be turned into an argument amount payment becuase there are so many people on this forum who are completely unaware about how much damage it does to the industry.

I would have thought more damage was done to the industry by people like the one that got £3M for the Dodi/Diana shot.

Professional photographers run the risk of being as popular as estate agents.
 
It doesn't matter if you are the only one to get a shot, you should still get paid for it.
Why, because you say so?

If you've got a beef with the BBC using pictures without paying for them, take it up with the BBC, not the OP. If he wants to give his pictures away for free, good on him.
 
My counselling is paying off! I'm somehow managing to resist getting dragged into this same old same old debate.
 
Why, because you say so?

If you've got a beef with the BBC using pictures without paying for them, take it up with the BBC, not the OP. If he wants to give his pictures away for free, good on him.

No becuase it damages the industry, are you blind? Have you even read what i've been saying this whole topic?

I don't have a beef with the BBC, I have a beef with people giving away photos for free. The BBC accept free photos purely becuase they know people submit them and will give them away for free. If noone submitted them, the BBC would have to pay. That attitude of 'if he want's to give stuff away for free then good on him' is adding to the reason the industry has been so hardly hit recently.

trapper501 - Why would someone (we are talking about paparazzi here more than press photographers) making obscene amounts of money hurt the industry? Whoever it was would have sold the same set of shots to many different magazines all over the world.
 
The BBC accept free photos purely becuase they know people submit them and will give them away for free. If noone submitted them, the BBC would have to pay.
Exactly, and if they had paid Neil then you STILL wouldn't have made any money!

You have your dog barking up the wrong tree I'm afraid. It's not people like Neil that are 'hurting the industry', it's sites like the BBC who choose to use free images if one is to subscribe to your belief that it does damage in the first place.

If you honestly think that Harold, 91 from Whitstable, should be charging the BBC for the picture of his grandson riding his bike for the first time without stabilisers so that the photojournalistic industry doesn't come crashing to it's knees, then you needn't worry - you have a perfect fall back career as a fantasy writer ready to go.

As it is, well done to Neil for getting his image used, and getting what he wanted for it.
 
trapper501 - Why would someone (we are talking about paparazzi here more than press photographers) making obscene amounts of money hurt the industry? Whoever it was would have sold the same set of shots to many different magazines all over the world.

You hit the nail on the head by using the word obscene.

The definition of obscene is abhorrent to morality or virtue, tending to incite corruption.

Perhaps that is how you want your industry to be described.

It certainly isn't the mark of a profession of any standing.
 
Exactly, and if they had paid Neil then you STILL wouldn't have made any money!

It's not about me, it's about the industry. If they had paid Neil then good, they should be doing so.

You have your dog barking up the wrong tree I'm afraid. It's not people like Neil that are 'hurting the industry', it's sites like the BBC who choose to use free images if one is to subscribe to your belief that it does damage in the first place.

Why do the BBC choose to use free images? Because people are happy to give them to the BBC for free. Get that into your head and maybe you will stop posting comments like that.

If you honestly think that Harold, 91 from Whitstable, should be charging the BBC for the picture of his grandson riding his bike for the first time without stabilisers so that the photojournalistic industry doesn't come crashing to it's knees, then you needn't worry - you have a perfect fall back career as a fantasy writer ready to go.

If Harold from Whitstable wants his photos published, he should be getting money from it. It doesn't matter who they are, what their age is, where they are from or what the photo is of. The fact of the matter is that if you provide a service to someone (or organisation), no matter how small or insignificant, you should be paid.

You don't get free stuff in this world, why should photography be any different?

trapper501 - Don't compare me to a pap. I'm not a pap and never will be. There is a BIG difference between paparazzi and press.
 
trapper501 - Don't compare me to a pap. I'm not a pap and never will be. There is a BIG difference between paparazzi and press.

Oh I didn't realise you defined "The industry" so tightly.

Are they in a different Industry then?
 
Simmontino - Yes.

trapper - We were specifically talking about the press / photojournalism industry. Paps and press are pretty much in the same industry, but I regard paps as pretty much a different industry all together (as do any photojournalists/press photographers). It's like comparing motorbikes to cars, they are both use the same roads but are completely different.
 
Well done on getting the picture used and being there to take it.

Re payment. I think if one of the big news agencies sent this picture in, they would be paid for it. However, as already mentioned, is it a story that they would have been prepared to pay for a picture. If not, then it would have just had words and no picture, but with a free picture, then add one to the story. Personally, for a picture like that, I think you should be paid. It's not like its a shots of a car with snow covering it, which we saw a whole barrage of last week.
 
Simmontino - Yes.

trapper - We were specifically talking about the press / photojournalism industry. Paps and press are pretty much in the same industry, but I regard paps as pretty much a different industry all together.

I'm sure you would want to distance yourself from the behaviour, but the sad fact is the distinction is yours rather than a general view of your Industry.

After all, it wasn't me that brought up the dodi/diana case as an example of how much money could be made from a picture.
 
It's not about me, it's about the industry.

8utters, I'm not sure I buy all this self-righteous indignation. It sounds pretty much like it's all about you and how amateur photographers are stealing you livelihood. That's understandable, but it is the way of the world and unless you are very good at pushing water up hill, then you had better get used to it.

And with respect mate, I don't think it's got much to do with photography either. A press man's greatest skill is getting to the right place at the right time, before anybody else with a camera. The actual picture taking isn't usually too tricky.

Unfortunately for press photographers today, the general public will always beat you to a note-worthy event, and today they are always armed with mobile phones at least. That's a battle you cannot win and I honestly suggest you stop trying to spoil the party for those people that do stumble across a good snap as it will give you ulcers.

The fact of the matter is that if you provide a service to someone (or organisation), no matter how small or insignificant, you should be paid.

You don't get free stuff in this world, why should photography be any different?

There is free stuff in this world. Lots of it. This website is free and provides a great deal of information and pleasure to me, and to everyone else on here. It's run by willing volunteers who do it because they can, and presumably because they enjoy it too. I don't want to stop them doing that, and I don't want to pay for it either. Perhaps you do.
 
You charge all your relatives for photos at the going rate as well?

Yeah i'd charge friends and relatives if I photographed their event and have done in the past. I'd probably do it a bit cheaper, but still would charge.

HoppyUK said:
8utters, I'm not sure I buy all this self-righteous indignation. It sounds pretty much like it's all about you and how amateur photographers are stealing you livelihood. That's understandable, but it is the way of the world and unless you are very good at pushing water up hill, then you had better get used to it.
No, that's rubbish. I'm all for amateur photographs getting their work published. I never said they shouldn't, all i'm saying is that they should get paid for it. I never said amateur photographs were taking away anything from me, i'm simply saying that if you provide a service, you should charge for it like any other work you would do.

HoppyUK said:
And with respect mate, I don't think it's got much to do with photography either. A press man's greatest skill is getting to the right place at the right time, before anybody else with a camera. The actual picture taking isn't usually too tricky.
No, it's not just about getting to the right place at the right time, you have to get the shot that noone else gets and make sure it's on the picture desk as quick as possible. Even the simplest of events can turn out to be very difficult to photograph even before you've thought of getting them back fast.

We arn't really even talking about photography here anyway, charging for photos is more business and experience related than anything else.

HoppyUK said:
Unfortunately for press photographers today, the general public will always beat you to a note-worthy event, and today they are always armed with mobile phones at least. That's a battle you cannot win and I honestly suggest you stop trying to spoil the party for those people that do stumble across a good snap as it will give you ulcers.
This is not about good snaps and me being sour at the fact that someone got a shot, as I said before, i'm all for people having their work published, but they should claim the money they are entitled to.

I'm not trying to battle anyone, I know that there are plenty of people out there armed with DSLRs at the same events I go to. So what? Does that mean they should give all their stuff away for free?
 
Yeah i'd charge friends and relatives if I photographed their event and have done in the past. I'd probably do it a bit cheaper, but still would charge
I was asking about photographs you've given to friends/relatives.

You charge for every one of those (if, for example, your Mum wanted a picture of your Sister)?
 
For something a relative would otherwise pay a photographer to do (for example if my mum wanted shots of my sister, and would hire a tog to do it) then yes I would charge. Infact I did a job for my dad which I charged him for (portrait shots of people in his office).

Just giving a photo that you took of your sister to your mum isn't really a service, it's just something you had and gave to her just like her cooking you dinner when you were a kid, she's not providing you a restaurant service, it's just family. You can't compare giving photos to the BBC to giving photos to your own mother.

When I said 'no matter how small or insignificant, you should be paid.' I meant in the context of that even if it's just one small photo that my seem insignificant you should still charge for it if you are selling it in an industry.
 
Got to say after reading this thread with much appreciation for both sides of the coin, I'm siding with 8utters on this one. It's not really a matter of does one detract from the other. Just a simple case of economics. I happen to believe if a commercial organisation uses your photo then they should reward you for it. Heck, we have charities paying photographers for their work, why not the beeb?
 
I can also see 'both sides of the coin' However if your an amateur taking photos You do get a real buzz from seeing your shots published, or at least I did :D I had one on local ITV and a set in the local paper :) TBH If I wanted paying for them then they wouldn't have been published! I didn't even see the shot on TV :( but it's still very motivational when others tell you they've seen it :D

Steve
 
TBH If I wanted paying for them then they wouldn't have been published!
Only because others will be happy to be giving a commercial operation some free material?

But I'm probably one of those less than sympathetic to the gang of ******s that sponge a living in the media by scavenging other people lives.
 
Back
Top