Best all round lens 5d mark II - for rental

Messages
1,488
Name
D
Edit My Images
Yes
Ok, so looks like i've finally got me a 2nd hand 5d mark II - however, as the kit lens i've used previously wont fit this as its full frame and the kit lens i have with my 40d I dont really like that much I was thinking of renting a lens for my 'vacation' next month. A good all rounder - so i can get the best out of the camera now that im Mark II land.

I will be using lensfettish as I have a credit voucher - and i think my choices will be 24-70mm f2.8 or the 24-105mm - Ive used the former, for gigs, not as a 'kit' choice so i know it does the business, but wondered if for very slightly less money i should try out the other lens. Ive read a few things saying it isnt that super - but im not really sure what thats based on. Thinking maybe should rent something i've not had before.

Just wondered if owners of both these lenses had some advice?
 
Both a great lenses.

The 24-105 f4 is a cracking general purpose lens. Very sharp, quiet and fast AF.
If f2.8 is a must though for your purposes then I would look at the 24-70.
 
For me, I would have to say the 135L. Sold my 24-105 and 24-70 after using one.
 
i dont think that lensfettish carry that lens (135L), or at least i cant find it, thats not to say its not there :-)
 
Both a great lenses.

The 24-105 f4 is a cracking general purpose lens. Very sharp, quiet and fast AF.
If f2.8 is a must though for your purposes then I would look at the 24-70.

I have the 24-70 and can do without the reach but the f2.8. If I want the reach chances are I can crop to obtain it.

Still don't think you can go wrong with the 24-105 but by the sound of you using it for gigs the f2.8 sounds like it will be needed more.
 
on this occasion it wont be used for gigs, just for my holiday so i can do without the f2.8 on this occasion. if i was gigging I'd def go for the 24-70mm. So maybe go for the 24-105mm maybe as its more of an all rounder?
 
24-105 is a brilliant all-rounder, wonderfully versatile walkabout range, plus IS. I use it for about 75% of everything.

It has its fair share of vignetting, barrel distortion and CA at the wide end at f/4, but they're gone with a mouse-click in DPP or Lightroom.
 
did you sell because of the issues HoppyUK mentioned? I think i had assumed the 24-70mm was a better lens for some things - but wanted to get some more opinions on all round views as Ive been quite gig focussed until now, and trying to widen the use of the lens i choose to rent.
 
Matt989 said:
I sold my 24-105 and bought a 24-70, nuff said.

Well I sold my 24-70 and got a new 24-105 and it's seriously just as good for me. It maybe down to myself getting better or the micro adjustments being slightly out, but I love the 24-105 it's sharp.
 
I've used both, for me personally I like the 24-105, they are both great lenses, but u prefer that little extra reach, and it is slightly smaller. I've not really noticed a great difference in IQ either. Both amazing lenses, if I were to shoot low light I would go for the 24-70 but for nearly everything else it is the 24-105.
 
Back
Top