Brand Dilemma... Should I switch to Canon?

Messages
1,241
Name
Bal Sanghera
Edit My Images
Yes
Ok since 2008 I have been using Sony gear as that was the first DSLR I bought and when I upgraded I natrually went for Sony again.

Now heres the problem... a very unique opportunity has come up where I can be trained by a group of international photographers and work with them on various projects in the UK and abroad which is great... Only problem is they all use Canon and said they dont mind me using Sony but the reason they all use Canon is so they can switch lenses/flashes/batteries between each other share equipment which makes life a lot easier especially if on a long shoot or something goes wrong.

So should I sell all my Sony gear and switch to Canon or stick with what I am comfortable and hope I stay lucky and never have problem with my equipment :thinking:

I think I have answered my own question but would appreciate any input. I guess if they are going to spend the time training me, I might as well get trained using the same equipment as everyone else is using right?
 
Last edited:
If it's for 'work' and will last a decent amount of time - buy the rubbishy cameras...
and the sooner the better so you can familiarise yourself with the rubbishyess of them fully...
 
If it's for 'work' and will last a decent amount of time - buy the rubbishy cameras...
and the sooner the better so you can familiarise yourself with the rubbishyess of them fully...

I aggree
 
If it's for 'work' and will last a decent amount of time - buy the rubbishy cameras...
and the sooner the better so you can familiarise yourself with the rubbishyess of them fully...

Agreed, it's a no brainer really.
 
Unless you really need to use their lenses then it's a waste of money. A camera is a camera.
 
I wouldnt with all the equipment you have. Once you have learnt you will be better with the camera you already know and love. One less thing to learn if still using your camera. If they are good they wont have any issue showing you how to do the same thing on your camera.

I can understand the swapping situation, but its a lot of hassle and expense to go to just for 'just in case it happens'.
 
I think the point they are making is we all use Canon because it fits in with the way we work kinda thing. Iv seen them in action and they are always switching between cameras etc and thats probably the main reason... If im using Sony and they are all using Canon I wont be able to work effectively within the group.

The other issue would be cost not having to buy the same lens for Sony fit etc... the job and training offer iv been given is amazing (without going into detail everything is paid for except main body and lens)

Guess im just worried about not being able to sell my Sony gear to get Canon with decent glass and which one to get for that matter!
 
On the plus side, nobody is going to nick your current gear.
 
Can you not just get something like a 40D body only and take that with you as well as your Sony stuff?
 
If this will mean you can work closer with this team go for it, what an oppertunity.

If it's for 'work' and will last a decent amount of time - buy the rubbishy cameras...
and the sooner the better so you can familiarise yourself with the rubbishyess of them fully...

Rob I thought he said Canon not Nikon :lol:
 
I didnt want to reveal too much info as it is all still being finalised but the group are also doing a lot work doing multi-cam video shoots... I could get a budget Canon to begin with but I dont want to have to upgrade a few months later because I cant do certain porjects.
 
I think I might get rid of the A350 and a few lenses and invest in a Canon with decent Glass that way I got the best of both... I actually really love my A700 but for some reason if you got Sony gear your not a professional :cuckoo:
 
How much is the training worth to you in the long term? There's no doubt you will lose money switching brands but only you will know if you will make this money back in the long term by switching for the training.

You might have to suffer some short term pain to get long term benefits.
 
I, unlike many here, would switch to Canon. This is because Canon really have their heart in photography (like Nikon) whereas Sony does not. Whilst Sony do a lot of imaging products etc. their real core business lies elsewhere. You may also find, in due course, find that their models and levels of compatibility between them, may change more than Canon (or Nikon).
My recommendation is therefore to go with the group and switch to Canon.
 
I, unlike many here, would switch to Canon. This is because Canon really have their heart in photography (like Nikon) whereas Sony does not. Whilst Sony do a lot of imaging products etc. their real core business lies elsewhere. You may also find, in due course, find that their models and levels of compatibility between them, may change more than Canon (or Nikon).
My recommendation is therefore to go with the group and switch to Canon.

not really, Sony are a digital company and so there heart is with digital stuff such as camera's, Sony love photography and its a big seller for them and that's why I went Sony. screw Canon, Sony are just as professional as canon and Nikon and it wouldn't hurt whether you were shooting a700 or 40. stick with what you've got and go along and don't swap lenses etc. be prepared.
 
The training and experience is invaluable... I dont have to pay anything for the training... I just need to make sure my equipment and photography is of equal standard.
 
The training and experience is invaluable... I dont have to pay anything for the training... I just need to make sure my equipment and photography is of equal standard.

Then sell up and go to Canon. It won't make you even slightly better as a photographer, probably worse if anything as changing has that effect, and it certainly won't make you more professional but you need to do whatever it takes to make this training work if it is so worthwhile.

It'll be a pain (and definitely don't sell anything until you are 100% confirmed) but if that is how the cookie has crumbled you've got to go with it.
 
same with Nikon TBH :lol:


I think I might get rid of the A350 and a few lenses and invest in a Canon with decent Glass that way I got the best of both... I actually really love my A700 but for some reason if you got Sony gear your not a professional :cuckoo:
 
Will have to have a chat with them, if they will insure all my equipment and happy with my shots after the training I will stick to Sony... If they say its not working for what ever reason then I will just switch to Canon... But then again I could just switch staright to Canon and save all that hassle... Lol thats the Dilemma!
 
Will have to have a chat with them, if they will insure all my equipment and happy with my shots after the training I will stick to Sony... If they say its not working for what ever reason then I will just switch to Canon... But then again I could just switch staright to Canon and save all that hassle... Lol thats the Dilemma!

Its more hassle changing to canon than it is sticking with what you have. carry on as normal and if for whatever reason it doesn't work out then swap your equipment.
 
Why switch?

Why not invest in the minimum of Canon kit to fit in, then you've the choice later of which to sell.

Could you setup a small business and get a startup grant/loan?
 
In all honesty if i were you would sell up and go Canon. It'll remove any technical differences in your gear so you're all on a level playing field (they'll be able to demonstrate techniques easier) and it'll be a sign to them that you're willing to adapt and that you're taking the training seriously. I'm sure they're attached to their gear too so they'll understand the sacrifice.

Think of it this way: If it really is the photographer that makes the photo then you should have no problems switching cameras.


a very unique opportunity has come up where I can be trained by a group of international photographers

I think that says it all really. Once in a lifetime opportunity....... plus..... imagine how much gear you'll have access to??

Go for it!
 
Last edited:
In all honesty if i were you would sell up and go Canon. It'll remove any technical differences in your gear so you're all on a level playing field (they'll be able to demonstrate techniques easier) and it'll be a sign to them that you're willing to adapt and that you're taking the training seriously. I'm sure they're attached to their gear too so they'll understand the sacrifice.

Think of it this way: If it really is the photographer that makes the photo then you should have no problems switching cameras.

:plusone:

Good point... There is no major rush to make a decsion... So will have a good think about it and check out the prices of Canon Gear... If after the training I eventually get to do some international shoots it would be a dream come true...
 
Last edited:
tbh if you want to do this for a living canon/nikon are the way to go because they supply most pros

which means the stuff is quick and easy to rent if you fall into trouble, there is a big S/H market, there is a bigger new market so its easier to find what you need quickly

and do not under estimate the sharing aspect, for my first year of paid work my backup kit was my buddys kit
 
I don't see the issue here, sell your kit, buy yourself a decent canon body and a few bits and pieces. It sounds like you won't need to replace most of the lenses straight away if everyone shares and it will really just make things easier in the long run,
 
Forget all the stupid brand thing - the flexibility is what you need if you are doing what you describe.

It wouldn't matter what you think of their choice of kit, get the same, plays swapsies - its worth far more than any perceived advantage.

Unless of course you introduced them to the friendly Nikon UK rep and got them a proper set of gear :thumbs:
 
If they're investing this much in you does it not make sense to show commitment and invest something in them. Their knowledge is with Canon, they can train you to use that as it is what they know and their tool of choice, if you're stuck they can show you how but if you're on sony then they don't know the camera and you're on your own.
Plus you can borrow their kit and by the sound of it they've got top quality stuff and all the tools for the job.

It's not a "brand" thing, it's a "tool for the job" thing and their tool happens to be a Canon, at the end of the day it's your decision. I'd switch if it were me and get used to the camera as soon as possible.
 
I think I might get rid of the A350 and a few lenses and invest in a Canon with decent Glass that way I got the best of both... I actually really love my A700 but for some reason if you got Sony gear your not a professional :cuckoo:

It's not that you're not a professional if you shoot Sony, but if you're shooting with a bunch of other people offering you the use of high end lenses and other equipment, it makes sense to be using a system that can take advantage of them.

MANY professionals shooting in these types of environments with gear shares have made the switch from Canon to Nikon, and vice versa, and even back again, with MUCH MUCH more cash invested than you have in your current kit, because it's what the job demands, and you need to be able to keep up.
 
If I was in a similar position with my Nikon setup, I'd do the swap, I would see it is a part of the investment needed to get the job done. The benefits of having a free resource of lenses and accessories would be a significant factor in this decision.

However, I would make the swap 100% regardless how much I love my D3s and the Nikon Wireless Flash, I couldn't justify keeping them.
 
Back
Top