Can't get shallow DOF on my G5

Messages
2,816
Name
Patrick
Edit My Images
Yes
Hi guys, I've searched the forum and can't find an answer so I hope this isn't something you've already discussed ad nauseum...

I want to use my Canon G5 to do some indoor portraits using window light, but with a really shallow DOF. But no matter how wide the aperture I still get a deep DOF. When I do close-up shots (less than 50cm) I can get a shallow DOF, but not if I'm 2 metres from the subject. I thought the main thing affecting DOF was aperture, but I guess I'm missing something.

Thanks for your help. Feel free to get as technical as you like...I like to understand things thoroughly.
 
Hi Patrick,

well the way I understand it.

Compacts have smaller sensors than DSLRs, and don not have as much control over depth of field. Put this way, and image shot on a Nikon P5100 (compact) and a photo from a D5000 (DSLR) both at F4, the compact will be much sharper throughout the focal range than the DSLR. Because the DSLRs have much larger sensors. I don't think theres any way round it, short of using photoshop.

:)
 
I think most compacts use ND filters rather than a true aperture ring so getting DOF isn't possible. That said, if any did I would expect the G5 to...
 
The other factor to aperture is focal length and a compact camera has a very short focal length. Put 'depth of field calculator' into google and use one of the calculator sites to see how the depth of field changes as the focal length gets shorter.
 
Thanks for your replies. I've googled 'depth of field calculator' and looked at this http://www.dofmaster.com/dofjs.html. Now I'm really confused!

According to this calculator on my G5 at it's max zoom (28mm) and widest aperture (f.3.0) at a distance of 7 feet the DOF should be 0.72 feet. So at a distance of around 2 metres that's the shallowest DOF I'm going to get.

BUT...

On a DSLR (e.g. Canon 450D) with it's kit lens (18-55mm f/3.5-5.6) at 7 feet distance the shallowest DOF is 1.04 feet.

So does that mean that my G5 will be better for getting shallow DOF for portraits than a DSLR with a kit lens? Or am I doing it all wrong?
 
Thanks for your replies. I've googled 'depth of field calculator' and looked at this http://www.dofmaster.com/dofjs.html. Now I'm really confused!

According to this calculator on my G5 at it's max zoom (28mm) and widest aperture (f.3.0) at a distance of 7 feet the DOF should be 0.72 feet. So at a distance of around 2 metres that's the shallowest DOF I'm going to get.

BUT...

On a DSLR (e.g. Canon 450D) with it's kit lens (18-55mm f/3.5-5.6) at 7 feet distance the shallowest DOF is 1.04 feet.

So does that mean that my G5 will be better for getting shallow DOF for portraits than a DSLR with a kit lens? Or am I doing it all wrong?

Yes, I'm afraid you are. To make depth of field comparisons you have got to select the right focal lengths to give the same field of view. Just guessing, I would say that 28mm on a G5 is going to be similar to about 90mm on a 450D.

As stated above, the main problem is the tiny sensor of the G5. Depth of field is controlled by two parameters - f/number and magnification (image size). Magnification is controlled by focal length and subject distance, and obvioulsy limited by format. Compact formats are tiny, so the magniciation can never get very high.

Without going into detail, the crop factor is a shorthand way of estimating the difference in depth of field between formats. Canon 450D has a crop factor of 1.6x compared to full frame, which means at f/3 for example, it will deliver DoF equal to f/3.8 on full frame (about one and a quarter stops).

Most compacts have a crop factor around 5x and I think the G5 is about that, in which case f/3 will deliver DoF equal to f/15 on full frame. That's obviously massive depth of field, as you have discovered.

In practise, it is impossible to get shallow depth of field with a compact, even with the G5's f/2 lens, except at very close distance (when the image magnification becomes relatively higher).
 
To put it in its simplest form, due to the small sensor size compacts and bridge cameras have on average of 5 stops more DOF for a given angle of veiw (not focal length) compared to a DSLR.

So shooting at F2.8 on a small sensor will give you the same DOF as shooting at a aperture of F11 on A DSLR using the same angle of veiw (framing).
 
Hoppy's right, you won't create a defocused background for your portraits with a small sensor compact.

Even the DSLR with a kit lens (18-55mm) is far from ideal in this scenario because the maximum aperture at the kind of zoom setting you'll be using will be about f5.6. This is where the 50mm f1.8 (nifty fifty) comes in with it's very large max aperture.

Window light is fantastic, try creating a clean background and if you're into photoshop or elements you can add background blur at the editing stage.

John
 
Thanks for your replies. I think I'm starting to understand.
Can anyone suggest anyone suggest a good resource for explaining the technicalities of calculating DOF in detail?
 
Hi Patrick, you don't need to calculate DOF, learn it in the field by trying different settings and checking them on your lcd at a consistant magnification.

The digtal slr has a very short feedback loop of only a few seconds that enables you to quickly see the results of your test.

Turn the telly off and you can do it on the setee!!

All the best John
 
Back
Top