- Messages
- 9,521
- Edit My Images
- Yes
What people say what people mean
Having recently been asked for comment on a series of photos I used commentary like good composition - good tonal range great use of negative space etc. and was then asked to explain what these actually meant, and that got me thinking about how we interact with others on TP too. So here are a few of my interpretations of commonly voiced opinions you need to imagine these are ALL in response to one image:
They said
Nice shot
They meant
BORING - or
I dont know enough about photography to comment properly but felt the need to say something and nice shot is all I can manage, please dont take offence
They said
Great shot
They meant
I like it or
I know even less about photography than him ^^^ so Im even more wowed by this
They said
Excellent composition
They meant
I read somewhere that the subject isnt supposed to be in the middle and as this one isnt I thought this most appropriate to show I know something about photography
They said
I like the way youve controlled the highlights
They meant
Its too dark!!!
They said
Great retention of shadow detail
They meant
OMG those highlights are blown!!!
They said
Im seeing a colour cast on my monitor
They meant
Are you colour-blind or what !!!
They said
Could do with a little sharpen
They meant
Your lens is softer than a babys anal excretion - or - you cant focus you pillock or at THAT shutter-speed, are you joking
They said
I aspire to be as good as you one day
They meant
I want to have your babies - or - yes I am taking the pee you moron - or - I am easily impressed by what is probably crap
They said
Great tonal range, is that HDR???
They meant
OMG, what the **** have you done to that image!!!
Feel free to add your own take, and yes I accept that all the above could be genuine face-value comments or are they


DD
Having recently been asked for comment on a series of photos I used commentary like good composition - good tonal range great use of negative space etc. and was then asked to explain what these actually meant, and that got me thinking about how we interact with others on TP too. So here are a few of my interpretations of commonly voiced opinions you need to imagine these are ALL in response to one image:
They said
Nice shot
They meant
BORING - or
I dont know enough about photography to comment properly but felt the need to say something and nice shot is all I can manage, please dont take offence
They said
Great shot
They meant
I like it or
I know even less about photography than him ^^^ so Im even more wowed by this
They said
Excellent composition
They meant
I read somewhere that the subject isnt supposed to be in the middle and as this one isnt I thought this most appropriate to show I know something about photography
They said
I like the way youve controlled the highlights
They meant
Its too dark!!!
They said
Great retention of shadow detail
They meant
OMG those highlights are blown!!!
They said
Im seeing a colour cast on my monitor
They meant
Are you colour-blind or what !!!
They said
Could do with a little sharpen
They meant
Your lens is softer than a babys anal excretion - or - you cant focus you pillock or at THAT shutter-speed, are you joking
They said
I aspire to be as good as you one day
They meant
I want to have your babies - or - yes I am taking the pee you moron - or - I am easily impressed by what is probably crap
They said
Great tonal range, is that HDR???
They meant
OMG, what the **** have you done to that image!!!
Feel free to add your own take, and yes I accept that all the above could be genuine face-value comments or are they
DD
