Comments - what people say, what people mean

Messages
9,521
Edit My Images
Yes
What people say – what people mean

Having recently been asked for comment on a series of photos I used commentary like… good composition - good tonal range – great use of negative space – etc. and was then asked to explain what these actually meant, and that got me thinking about how we interact with others on TP too. So here are a few of my interpretations of commonly voiced opinions – you need to imagine these are ALL in response to one image:


They said…

Nice shot

They meant…

BORING - or

I don’t know enough about photography to comment properly but felt the need to say something and ‘nice shot’ is all I can manage, please don’t take offence

They said…

Great shot

They meant…

I like it – or

I know even less about photography than him ^^^ so I’m even more wowed by this


They said…

Excellent composition

They meant…

I read somewhere that the subject isn’t supposed to be in the middle and as this one isn’t I thought this most appropriate to show I know something about photography

They said…

I like the way you’ve controlled the highlights


They meant…

It’s too dark!!!

They said…

Great retention of shadow detail

They meant…

OMG those highlights are blown!!!

They said…

I’m seeing a colour cast on my monitor

They meant…

Are you colour-blind or what !!!

They said…

Could do with a little sharpen

They meant…

Your lens is softer than a baby’s anal excretion - or - you can’t focus you pillock – or – at THAT shutter-speed, are you joking

They said…

I aspire to be as good as you one day

They meant…

I want to have your babies - or - yes I am taking the pee you moron - or - I am easily impressed by what is probably crap

They said…

Great tonal range, is that HDR???

They meant…

OMG, what the **** have you done to that image!!!


Feel free to add your own take, and yes I accept that all the above could be genuine face-value comments… or are they :suspect::suspect::suspect:

DD
 
"The focus is slightly off"

Your camera has AF - are you a complete imbecile????
 
"interesting depth of field"

her eye should be in focus ...not her damn ear..!
 
Nice shot

I'm trying to get my post count up to post in classifieds

Great shot

I'm trying to get my post count up to post in classifieds

Excellent composition

I'm trying to get my post count up to post in classifieds

I like the way you’ve controlled the highlights

I'm trying to get my post count up to post in classifieds

Great retention of shadow detail

I'm trying to get my post count up to post in classifieds

I’m seeing a colour cast on my monitor
I'm trying to get my post count up to post in classifieds

Could do with a little sharpen

I'm trying to get my post count up to post in classifieds

I aspire to be as good as you one day

I'm trying to get my post count up to post in classifieds

Great tonal range, is that HDR???

I'm trying to get my post count up to post in classifieds
 
That's a very profound observation you have made, Dave.

By which I mean:

What a clever, observant and analytical chap you are.

OR

Didn't you know that, thought eveyone did!

What you have commented on is very true of modern day communication fed by abrieviation for emails and texting until the meaning is open to many interpretations. I believe this is the cause of so many misunderstandings.

Happy New Year.

Ken
 
I particularly like 1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9 very sharp and crisp and great colours, very well done

I just copy and paste my replies
 
I realise that this was posted (somewhat) tongue in cheek, but it does make me wonder whether it's worth bothering to make comments if that is how they are perceived. Surely any comment means that at least someone has looked at your images which is better than not looking?
 
Is your surname Rockwell?

Nope - this Ken 'rocks' but he doesn't 'rockwell' ;)



How about...

I bet your clients will love them :)

Meaning...

What utter crap!!! Call yourself a Pro you should be shot at dawn (or the golden hour)

And the converse...

Well my clients love them

Meaning...

Ok - so you ALL tell me these are crap but its the best I can do and if the suckers who hire me don't know any better then they get what they deserve

There's been quite a few threads like that and I know one Pro personally who adopts that very approach :D

DD
 
I realise that this was posted (somewhat) tongue in cheek, but it does make me wonder whether it's worth bothering to make comments if that is how they are perceived. Surely any comment means that at least someone has looked at your images which is better than not looking?

It is very :p:p:p and there is some truth in your comment too, if anything I'd hope this mickey take would help those persons who recognise many of the above as their own posts to elaborate a bit...

i.e. Nice shot, what I particularly like is that I think the composition is one a 3rd which I feel works well here and the contrast is nice & punchy which suits the subject

DD
 
Nice shot

I'm trying to get my post count up to post in classifieds

Great shot

I'm trying to get my post count up to post in classifieds

Excellent composition

I'm trying to get my post count up to post in classifieds

I like the way you’ve controlled the highlights

I'm trying to get my post count up to post in classifieds

Great retention of shadow detail

I'm trying to get my post count up to post in classifieds

I’m seeing a colour cast on my monitor
I'm trying to get my post count up to post in classifieds

Could do with a little sharpen

I'm trying to get my post count up to post in classifieds

I aspire to be as good as you one day

I'm trying to get my post count up to post in classifieds

Great tonal range, is that HDR???

I'm trying to get my post count up to post in classifieds



89 Posts ;)
 
You've really captured his/her character

What an ugly child, and could you not have cleaned that snot of its face before taking a photo
 
Best thread of 2011.:thumbs:
 
Said: It's more of a snapshot

Meant: Why did you bother showing me?



Said: That's a subtle use of HDR

Meant: That's soooo much better than the overcooked crap I usually see
 
Nice shot, what I particularly like is that I think the composition is on a 3rd which I feel works well here and the contrast is nice & punchy which suits the subject.

It's total crap and if you believe this you'll be a friend for life. :D
 
Good eye for detail

you've photographed the wrong part of the scene
 
Anything that starts with

"If you were planning a reshoot I would....." (or words to that effect)

Means "it's a pile of turd, go do it again and don't come back till you have something worth showing us"
 
It's just what people say whenever I stick up a photo...............
 
They say:

My P&S has more pixels than that and is way better


What they are really saying:

I am a knob and know dick all about photography, but I wish I had a camera like that!
 
Nice shot

I'm trying to get my post count up to post in classifieds

Great shot

I'm trying to get my post count up to post in classifieds

Excellent composition

I'm trying to get my post count up to post in classifieds

I like the way you’ve controlled the highlights

I'm trying to get my post count up to post in classifieds

Great retention of shadow detail

I'm trying to get my post count up to post in classifieds

I’m seeing a colour cast on my monitor
I'm trying to get my post count up to post in classifieds

Could do with a little sharpen

I'm trying to get my post count up to post in classifieds

I aspire to be as good as you one day

I'm trying to get my post count up to post in classifieds

Great tonal range, is that HDR???

I'm trying to get my post count up to post in classifieds

nice post





;)
 
Back
Top