Critique: Opinions on a photo competition

Status
Not open for further replies.
Messages
521
Name
Matt
Edit My Images
Yes
Staff Edit : Presenting others' photos for critique when the photographers are not here to defend them and have not requested critique is not allowed.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
None of the images strike me as being particularly brilliant, after all it is an amateur competition but i think one is a better overall shot than two even if it is a tiny bit wonky. sorry :(

Think the reason this got voted first is it's probably completely different from most of the other entries and stood out?
 
Based purely on personalvisual appeal, rather than technical aspects... my order of preference:

1, 4, 3, 5 & 2

There are minor tweaks that might improve some images but overall that is my list.

I appreciate the difficulty you probably had combining 2 buses and a train in a single shot but if I didn't know the image was specifically for Arriva, the shot would not have caught my eye like the others did (particularly the first 3).

Perhaps a panoramic crop of #2 would have had more impact on me.

I think you do No1 a disservice calling it a turkey :nono:
 
You're right about calling #1 a turkey, oops. I guess I feel its got too large a part of it that seems dark or underexposed as well as the colour cast which is easily correctable from RAW these days.
 
I think a panoramic crop would have really helped your image, whilst it's technically better than #1 on the exposure, the dull, empty sky really dilutes any impact you had. #1 and #4 are the pick of the bunch for me. I'm really not a fan of #3, and #2 edges it over #5.
 
Number 1 is by far the best imo. Whilst I haven't considered the "technical" aspects of any of the shots in terms of exposure etc 1 is the only one which I could envisage on arriva weekly magazine or whatever whilst the others are a bit snapshotty.

Sorry!
 
Number 1 is definitely the most interesting of the bunch as it's different to the rest. The timing's good on your shot to get all three together but it's boring to me, number 1 has a sense of movement to it.
 
I don't think it's very polite to call the winning entry a "Turkey", and if the author should be a member here, how would he or she feel?

I think the winner is the best of the five, followed by number 4. You definitely have too much empty foreground in your image, in my opinion of course, and were probably a tad too soon pressing the shutter - a second later and the buses would be closer together and the train would be more dominant in the frame.

I wouldn't normally have given criticism on the image, Matt, but I think in this case the winner was the best image, and I don't think that you should have put the other entries on here for a second judging.

Again, all in my humble opinion.
 
Sorry, but I too think that the selectors got it right (on the assumption that there was nothing better in their pool). Number one at least had some moody lighting, although the bright building in the background spoiled things a bit. Alaistair comment about there being too much empty sky in your photo was quite correct, and cropping would have improved it a lot. Your sense of timing was pretty good though.
 
I like 4 but it needs a bit more punch on the train? I also like 1, although a little warm. Really like the way the building top left is lit and the train draws your eye into the frame.

For your shot, I agree a crop off the bottom would have really helped.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top