Did CC's suffer at the intro of digital?

Messages
3,391
Edit My Images
Yes
Juat a question out of interest really.

I was an enthusiastic member of the Hornchurch in Havering Photographic Society in the days of film.

Competitions, exhibitions etc. were made up of colour and B&W prints up to 16"x20" and of course transparencies.

Just wondering what goes on in todays CC's, prints to these sorts of sizes I expect are prohibitively expensive and slides...well.

As I say, just a question out of interest really but I would have thought that digital did CC's no favours.

D in W
 
In our club, it's just the same as in the days of film - large prints are still pretty much the same cost to produce in relative terms, especially if printed yourself. A 16 x 20 colour print done at home had similar set up costs (if not more) to digital prints by the time you consider the enlarger, enlarging lenses, printing dishes, easels, timers and chemicals, and mounting those prints was a different ball game. I do remember also having a mounting press and sheets of adhesive print mount, and the problems associated with trying to get a nice evenly mounted print.

Some club members only have selected images printed, so the cost of viewing the rest on the pc are negligible. The only way to find the quality of a print from negative was to print it, so images were more difficult to assess.

PDI's directly replace slides and have the same following, but again are considerably cheaper to produce. poor quality images are simply deleted, but a lot can be done to pdi's to improve the quality, if only simply changing contrast and colour balance.

Entries to print and pdi competitions are fairly evenly balanced, a good number of entries to each with a few extra entries in the pdi competitions.

As an example, our club has about 100 members, probably 75% regularly entering competitions, and the last couple of competitions each had entries of about 90 images.

David.
 
Last edited:
I would have thought that digital did CC's no favours.
I'd disagree totally.

Digital cameras have made photography much more accessible than it was in pre-digital days, for two main reasons that I can see.

Firstly ease of reproduction. Printing from a digital file is easier than printing from a negative or transparency. In the film days you needed a mini chemistry lab to do it yourself. Nowadays you just route it from your PC to the printer. Many many people have printers which can produce decent quality photos. And if you want a big print, there's usually someone at the club who has a big printer and will stick your file through it for a nominal charge. (After all, it's not like he has to do any real work.) And of course projecting a digital image is MUCH easier than projecting a transparency.

Secondly the ability to experiment and innovate. Before digital, once you'd pressed the shutter button that was about it. You had to be really committed to want to muck around with improving the image in the darkroom. But with digital you can take lots more shots, because that doesn't cost anything, and you can post-process to your heart's content.

Result: More people can produce better images than they could in the pre-digital days. If that's not good for clubs then I don't know what is.
 
I agree with Stewart. Undoubtedly there are some in camera clubs who hang on to the 'old' ways, who talk about their 'real' camera (film) and who are dinosaurs reluctant to admit they can't get to grips with a computer. However, for the most part my experience is of amazing innovation and creativity and a new 'breed' of photographer who can use these new tools at their disposal with flair and sensitivity. Slide competitions are now PDI competitions and although there are undoubted pros and cons for both, its the way forward. Clubs unable or unwilling to embrace digital, especially now its firmly established and within reach of most pockets, will die an unmourned death! There will always be a place for the 'wet worker' but not in the way it used to be.
 
I agree with Stewart. Undoubtedly there are some in camera clubs who hang on to the 'old' ways, who talk about their 'real' camera (film) and who are dinosaurs reluctant to admit they can't get to grips with a computer. However, for the most part my experience is of amazing innovation and creativity and a new 'breed' of photographer who can use these new tools at their disposal with flair and sensitivity. Slide competitions are now PDI competitions and although there are undoubted pros and cons for both, its the way forward. Clubs unable or unwilling to embrace digital, especially now its firmly established and within reach of most pockets, will die an unmourned death! There will always be a place for the 'wet worker' but not in the way it used to be.

:shake:

jebus, you're attitude is as bad as the loons you think you describe, and as usual with these things, has FA to do with the op's question.
 
:shake:

jebus, you're attitude is as bad as the loons you think you describe, and as usual with these things, has FA to do with the op's question.

Pardon mois, I'm sure. Mind your manners!

Dave in Wales, if you're that interested, go and visit a local cc and see for yourself.
 
Back
Top