Do I always need to ask a permission for shotting a person who I don't know

Messages
16
Edit My Images
No
Hi everybody,

Today I met a situation which really confused me.

The story happened this morning. I went to Bristol Balloon Fiesta and I just wanted to take some photos of people. I want my photos could reflect people's life. When I took a photo for a man who was selling some interesting stuff, of course I didn't know this guy, he found I took his photo and then walked to me and said:"F*** u! r u gay? why did u take my photo?"
I didn't know what I could say at that moment. I just thought he was so rude and I did nothing wrong.

So I just can't stop thinking about this thing. Do you guys ask for a permission before you want to shot a strange every time or I just unfortunately shot a man with very bad temper?

I understand sometimes I need to ask person if I am allowed to take picture of him but sometimes if they know I am shotting them, they'll look at my lens that picture will lose the natural feature I want.

I am confused now. I hope you guys here could give me some reasonable answers.

Thanks,

Charlie
 
Legally you don't need their permission. Sometimes it is a good idea to ask though.

Legally, you can still take it if they say no but be prepared for a response similar to the one you received today.


Steve.
 
You can shoot who you want where you want when you want so long as the Law specifically does not allow it. There is no law which states you have to ask a person's permission to take their photograph in a public place. It might be polite to do so occasionally, but there is no law. So you met a guy with a bad attitude - it happens.
 
To be honest the only people who ever questions or tried to avoid having their photo taken by me were people who shouldn't have been doing what they were doing.
People selling glow sticks and stuff in Blackpool during the illuminations will literally run away if you bring your camera to your eye. Not suggesting this bloke you took a photo of was in anyway up to something he didn't want photographing, but you never know ;)
 
No you do not need to ask permission. There is always a chance though that someone will take exception to what you are doing. I find it's best just to be open about it. If someone confronts you just be honest. Say you are a photographer and that it was an interesting picture.

The more confidently you go about what you are doing the less likely some will be to take exception to it. That's been my experience anyway.
 
The art of taking a candid shot is to be discrete.
I've been caught out a couple of time where people have noticed me taking a shot and looked at the camera and smiled.
To date I've not had anyone have a go at me but no doubt my time will come.
 
The above post a few up rings true. Years back I shot a stall holder selling bicycle spares on a rough bit of ground not far from Brick Lane. He said he didn't want to appear in the picture I'd just taken. Tough, it was film shot on 17mm lens, he was in it even though he was to one side. I suspect he wasn't paying tax or was drawing benefits. If someone was as abusive as the guy in the original post, I'd of weighed him up and if confident would have verbally sorted him, there' no excuse to be like that.
 
On public property you can photograph who you want.

Best person I ever had the 'pleasure' of meeting was outside court a few years ago. I've always hate doing court snatches but it was part of the job, case was about a local thug, usual scum nicking stuff etc. The paper wanted a pic of him and I was in the wrong time wrong place and got sent to take his pic.
Out he comes I got a good pic of him, over he comes mouthing off, fking this and fcking that, don't you take my fcking picture.
Only way out of a good kicking was to tell him to hurry up and move out of the way as the person I'd been waiting for all day was about to come out and I'd get in big big trouble if I missed him :lol:

He didn't know what to say so he just walked off, pic was used page one next day, Oh happy days ;)
 
He was doing what he does in a public place and you were doing what you do in a public place, no prob's.

I would have ask him calmly if his intentions were violent, because if they were I could accommodate him, if they were not, I would have told him to **** off.

I don't suffer ignorance lightly and will respond, but this is just me.

Only way out of a good kicking was to tell him to hurry up and move out of the way as the person I'd been waiting for all day was about to come out and I'd get in big big trouble if I missed him
:lol::clap:
 
As others have said legally you are allowed to. Then again there are lots of things you are allowed to do legally that are morally questionable, so whilst it's good to know you are not breaking the law it should not be the sole basis for your decision.

Some people just don't like having their picture taken, and there are many possible reasons for this. Sometimes you can find out in advance (for example if visiting a remote tribe who believe you are stealing their soul when taking the picture), sometimes you might be able to tell from the situation, and sometimes as this time you find out afterwards and I guess that is the risk you'll face.

I don't really engage in Street Photography much for this reason. I don't know what I'd do in your situation, if I was there take another pic to capture some true emotion? I think really I'd probably explain what I was doing and if they were still unhappy I'd agree to delete the photo, though I'll be in the minority on here. I say probably as that is *** I'd do if someone approached politely, if someone reacted the way this person did I'm not sure, but for me that would be the right thing to do.

Better luck next time!
 
........and then sometimes it goes really well
an email i received after stalking a very chic couple in Germany

Dear Andrew,

I had this morning the luck to see the beautiful photos you have made in Celle last weekend. Unfortunately I can not find them anymore at your website andrew748.com (at photo.net) - you called the photo gallery "Celleprelim" or something similar.

Within this gallery you took very beautiful pictures from my husband and me while we were sitting in front of you in an italian Cafe in Celle and also by making sightseeing. I would be very happy if you can tell me where I can see these photos again, as my husband had not the possibility to see them. Further we are also very interesting in buying these pictures - as you have catch such beautiful moments with your camera. My Idea is to make a photo collage with them and to make him a present - as his birthday is next monday.

I would be very grateful for a short answer and look forward to hear from you.

Kind regards - also to your wife !

Thank you for all
P.S.: As a hint...we have both black hair (me more than my husband) and we wear a black leather jacked..

no money has changed hands, but we have a weekend in Hanover gratis :thumbs:

so move on from the grumps, have a ready smile and a pocket full of business cards.
 
no money has changed hands, but we have a weekend in Hanover gratis :thumbs:

so move on from the grumps, have a ready smile and a pocket full of business cards.
What a nice ending to some street shots, or should I say beginning :thumbs:
 
Tell him you work the for the dept of works and pensions as a Fraud Investigator, chances are he's "hobling" (working while unemployed) or something.
 
........and then sometimes it goes really well
an email i received after stalking a very chic couple in Germany



no money has changed hands, but we have a weekend in Hanover gratis :thumbs:

so move on from the grumps, have a ready smile and a pocket full of business cards.

That must have been a superb suprise?:thumbs:

As to the original post, you will get that from time to time.
He was out of order, but don't assume everyone will be like him.;)


Spence
 
Thank you guys for all your answers. :)

Probabley I just shot a "special" stranger with "special" temper today.

You guys:thumbs:
 
........and then sometimes it goes really well
an email i received after stalking a very chic couple in Germany



no money has changed hands, but we have a weekend in Hanover gratis :thumbs:

so move on from the grumps, have a ready smile and a pocket full of business cards.

Just another reason I still live here - what were you doing in Celle? Near my old stomping-ground in Bergen-Hohne...

For the OP: yes it happens and usually for the reasons others have stated above - mainly benefit cheats and wierdos - grow a thicker skin and move on...you did nothing wrong, though I agree it does leave a bad taste in the mouth, especially when most people will smile back and nod, even though they might wonder why you're photographing them...
 
Thank you guys for all your answers. :)

Probabley I just shot a "special" stranger with "special" temper today.

You guys:thumbs:

It happens, you will develop a sense of self preservation with this type of photography and good things will happen if you remain calm, pleasant and use a little bit of common sense.


minor hijack:bonk:

What a nice ending to some street shots, or should I say beginning :thumbs:

That must have been a superb suprise?:thumbs:

Spence

Very surprised and very happy :thumbs:

Just another reason I still live here - what were you doing in Celle? Near my old stomping-ground in Bergen-Hohne...

Brother is Ex ACC and never came home, and i can see why, will be planning a trip in November hopefully, maybe beer with you and Naboo32 is a possibility
:)
 
Most of the time I don't ask permission and don't have any issues. On occasion I will ask, but usually if I want a particular shot, posed etc.

A few weeks back in Oxford, a woman had a right go at me for taking her picture, she was sick of tourists photographing her. In this case, I was actually waiting for her to leave the frame, I think she just wanted to let off steam.
 
so move on from the grumps, have a ready smile and a pocket full of business cards.

This was going to be my approach to taking candid shots. If they confront you just explain what you do and hand them a card with your site/email, and if they would like to see the pics of themself then just get them to email you.
 
Back
Top