I'd imagine the magazines tend to rely on advertising from manufacturers, so it's probably commercial suicide to give a product a complete pasting. Also, i don't think every product gets tested - I'm sure some of the sub £100 stuff is pretty average but it probably doesn't get much attention as the target market for that sector isn't likely to be the 'enthusiast' who buys the camera comics.
That said, does anyone produce bad product these days? I don't know. The market is that competitive that I don't think complete dogs would survive, especially with the word of mouth recommendations and reviews that the internet provides.
Pretty how it is in publishing if you rely heavily on advertising revenue.
I've worked on consumer magazines for the past decade and have learned (sometimes the hard way) that there is a balance between integrity (i.e. telling it as it is) and slitting your own throat financially.
Some of the big players in publishing dictate to the advertisers, but in niche publishing and specialist magazines, more often than not the advertisers have to be kept sweet because every penny counts. It's not to say you bend over to get shafted every day, but you have to make allowances and treat people fairly and keep the customer happy.
The other thing is something my boss says a lot; there is a lot of good gear out there and it's now getting harder and harder to find really, really papp stuff. It's out there, no doubt, but if we slate something in our mags it does no-one any favours. I agree that consumer magazines should give honest reviews but if it's that bad then it really shouldn't be reviewed in the first place IMO.
I've done my fair share of honest reviews but it has to be backed up by fact, not opinion, if you want to be able to stand your ground. The worst thing that can be done with reviews is say "I think this is bad because...", as that is purely a personal opinion and it's worth nothing, even if you are an editor. I used to conduct a lot of pole tests, some costing upwards of £4,000. At that price you expect the best and 99.9% of the time, you got the best. Bu there would be occasions where a product fell short either in performance or in value for money. I put this in reviews but always made sure that I could argue my case.
It's the same with group tests; there's only one winner and lots of losers. We ditched group tests for this reason, although we did end up starting them again but with masses of in-depth info that the reader could easily use to see what products offered the best option in certain sectors.
To the
OP, Top Gear isn't financed by advertising and Jezza doesn't rely on advertising to finance his (many) books, so he can say what he wants on-screen and in print; the magazine will be a different kettle of fish, but there are probably big budgets that need spending and the car manufacturers will pump lots into car mags regardless.... they'll generally try to cover over bad reviews with more exposure and marketing. They may also take on the journo's advice and make a revision to the product
