Do We Need Jeremy Clarkson To Road Test Cameras

Messages
5,161
Name
Nigel Cliff
Edit My Images
Yes
I have just finished reading Jezza's latest book and something crossed my mind,his and other motoring journalist's reviews don't pull any punches,if a car is a nail they say so be it a £10k Korean box or a £200,000 supercar.

Camera reviews however seem to be very bland in comparison in fact I can only ever remember 2 reviews over my 35 years of photography that really dissed equipment,the 50mm f 2.8 Domiplan widely regarded as the worst lens ever made and a Fuji Bride camera with a virtually unuseable EVF.

So is it a case of photography journo's so totally in thrall to the manufacturers that they dare not criticise or is there no such thing as a bad camera/lens etc made any more
 
I'm interested in hearing why the domiplan was such as bad lens! But I agree with you, there is a fine line between saying a lens is BAD and saying it doesn't do something very well..

Take the 85mm f/1.2 for example. People say that lens' auto focus is really slow, but really thats not the point. It's a super fast lens with the widest aperture available from Canon. Just because of the slow auto focus, doesn't make it a bad lens.
 
I'd imagine the magazines tend to rely on advertising from manufacturers, so it's probably commercial suicide to give a product a complete pasting. Also, i don't think every product gets tested - I'm sure some of the sub £100 stuff is pretty average but it probably doesn't get much attention as the target market for that sector isn't likely to be the 'enthusiast' who buys the camera comics.

That said, does anyone produce bad product these days? I don't know. The market is that competitive that I don't think complete dogs would survive, especially with the word of mouth recommendations and reviews that the internet provides.
 
Only if the Italians started making DSLR's.....
 
God no don't get Clarkson to review it, he is only intrested in how fast can it go, is it loud, can I blow it up....

May, might give a more rounded review.
 
Hammond would be the most suited since he's into his photography, he uses Canon though... lol
 
I'd imagine the magazines tend to rely on advertising from manufacturers, so it's probably commercial suicide to give a product a complete pasting. Also, i don't think every product gets tested - I'm sure some of the sub £100 stuff is pretty average but it probably doesn't get much attention as the target market for that sector isn't likely to be the 'enthusiast' who buys the camera comics.

That said, does anyone produce bad product these days? I don't know. The market is that competitive that I don't think complete dogs would survive, especially with the word of mouth recommendations and reviews that the internet provides.

Pretty how it is in publishing if you rely heavily on advertising revenue.

I've worked on consumer magazines for the past decade and have learned (sometimes the hard way) that there is a balance between integrity (i.e. telling it as it is) and slitting your own throat financially.

Some of the big players in publishing dictate to the advertisers, but in niche publishing and specialist magazines, more often than not the advertisers have to be kept sweet because every penny counts. It's not to say you bend over to get shafted every day, but you have to make allowances and treat people fairly and keep the customer happy.

The other thing is something my boss says a lot; there is a lot of good gear out there and it's now getting harder and harder to find really, really papp stuff. It's out there, no doubt, but if we slate something in our mags it does no-one any favours. I agree that consumer magazines should give honest reviews but if it's that bad then it really shouldn't be reviewed in the first place IMO.

I've done my fair share of honest reviews but it has to be backed up by fact, not opinion, if you want to be able to stand your ground. The worst thing that can be done with reviews is say "I think this is bad because...", as that is purely a personal opinion and it's worth nothing, even if you are an editor. I used to conduct a lot of pole tests, some costing upwards of £4,000. At that price you expect the best and 99.9% of the time, you got the best. Bu there would be occasions where a product fell short either in performance or in value for money. I put this in reviews but always made sure that I could argue my case.

It's the same with group tests; there's only one winner and lots of losers. We ditched group tests for this reason, although we did end up starting them again but with masses of in-depth info that the reader could easily use to see what products offered the best option in certain sectors.

To the OP, Top Gear isn't financed by advertising and Jezza doesn't rely on advertising to finance his (many) books, so he can say what he wants on-screen and in print; the magazine will be a different kettle of fish, but there are probably big budgets that need spending and the car manufacturers will pump lots into car mags regardless.... they'll generally try to cover over bad reviews with more exposure and marketing. They may also take on the journo's advice and make a revision to the product :)
 
Last edited:
Perhaps it would be a good idea.
Just not with my camera!!!:lol:
 
I'd imagine the magazines tend to rely on advertising from manufacturers, so it's probably commercial suicide to give a product a complete pasting. Also, i don't think every product gets tested - I'm sure some of the sub £100 stuff is pretty average but it probably doesn't get much attention as the target market for that sector isn't likely to be the 'enthusiast' who buys the camera comics.

That said, does anyone produce bad product these days? I don't know. The market is that competitive that I don't think complete dogs would survive, especially with the word of mouth recommendations and reviews that the internet provides.

I've never seen a bad review given to a guitar or an amplifier in a magazine, the same with airguns.
20 odd years ago, I was trying to get a product review done by a guitar magazine, and was told that I'd have to buy advertising first, then they give a nice review!

Bought some right dog headphones, and a rubbish telly that had 5 star reviews in a well known hi-fi mag. Should have known better I suppose.
 
Last edited:
God no don't get Clarkson to review it, he is only intrested in how fast can it go, is it loud, can I blow it up....

May, might give a more rounded review.

May would just start getting nostalgic for his box brownie which ran on paraffin :D
 
Having someone like Clarkson around is a very bad thing for the motoring world IMO. The Top Gear reviews carry a huge amount of weight in the motoring world, and I am absolutely sure that these guys are used to driving the best of the best, and most expensive all the time...this makes if difficult for them to provide reviews of everyday cars which are not, and will never be like, the best of the best. I have owned cars that the press have loved and binned them off..equally, I have owned very uncool cars and loved them. I do not rate any of the Top Gear car reviewers at all, and certainly would not trust or rely on them when selecting a car.
 
Top Gear isn't a serious car programme though, it's just big lads' entertainment. I can't believe anyone would take their "reviews" seriously enough to base a 20k+ buying decision on it.
 
Are magazine reviews to be relied on, or are they skewed by advertising considerations, perhaps better to rely on real world users opinions........... 7D is noisy, the focus is rubbish etc etc or maybe not :D
 
He didn't make much impact on the sales of Vauxhall Vectras, so why not have some entertainment on camera gear :D

The thing with V'halls and Fords and other brands that rely heavily on company car sales is that sometimes people have zero choice in the matter. I remember back in my computer days I was told that I had to have a company car and it had to be a V'hall, I didn't want it or need it but I was stuck with the thing. Bet tactics like that did wonders for sales figures.
 
Top Gear isn't a serious car programme though...

It used to be. Obviously not any more, but there was a time when Clarkson done serious reviews on cars. In his own way, of course...

Which I think you can do, if you have the personality to get away with it. Understandably difficult with magazines, but if you have the readership..
 
Pretty how it is in publishing if you rely heavily on advertising revenue.

I've worked on consumer magazines for the past decade and have learned (sometimes the hard way) that there is a balance between integrity (i.e. telling it as it is) and slitting your own throat financially.

in 30 years of reading all kinds of fishing mags ive seen 2 bad reviews, one when barney wright of total sea fishing snapped a beach caster mid cast,to be fair its hard to be positive in that situationi suppose saying that it wasnt even a well known name over here, and the second was for a seatbox, the next month there was a retraction and lo and behold there was a double page spread over the page from the retraction

it was the same when i was into mountain biking in a big way, never saw a bad review of a bike

maybe in cynical but i just take them all with a pinch of salt nowadays and im sure that a camera review in mags would be just the same, i dont blame the mags after all advertising revenue is the name of the game were they make the majority of their money so you cant blame them

clarkson for prime minister by the way:thumbs:
 
Brendan - I can remember that, think it was something like a Penn rod wasn't it? He still punishes rods but he's getting slow now from all the McDonalds I buy him when we go out :lol:

To be fair, a lot of reviews in fishing mags (and probably other sectors too) should come under the headline of 'first impression' rather than review. I prided myself on being able to write constructive, entertaining reviews but I had the space to do a DPS review; many of the mags don't have nowhere near that amount if space, which makes it hard to cover everything.
 
The thing is, sometimes people dont see past the numbers. You can tell them that flash B is better than flash B till you go blue in the face, but if flash A id 50W/s bigger than flash B, then it is perceived as better

long verbose real world tests are not sexy, interesting or snappy enough for most reviews

Cars are very much like cameras, you do need to learn to drive

Anyway, we have Ken Rockwell
 
As someone else pointed out; do we really get that many rubbish camera products released? I do see the occasional lens 'slated' universally on review sites, but I think the most telling reviews are the group comparison ones where it's easier to see which product would best suit our needs. That's also when we see some fact based 'criticism'.
 
The games industry is famous for trying to influence reviews with advertising money or threatening to withhold future titles, I'd imagine this applies to pretty much every industry and magazines struggling to exist don't dare stand up to it.

However I don't think I've ever heard of anything being a bad product from anecdotal comments either other than stuff that's seemingly broken (1D III focus issues and things like that) apart from the wave of Chinese strobist equipment like triggers and flashes that seem to vary wildly in quality and reliability. And the clue to that should be in the price and origin of it.

The Top Gear reviews carry a huge amount of weight in the motoring world, and I am absolutely sure that these guys are used to driving the best of the best, and most expensive all the time...this makes if difficult for them to provide reviews of everyday cars which are not, and will never be like, the best of the best.

Firstly this is false as they do review/feature normal cars (Fiesta, Twingo, 207, Vectra, Insignia, Legacy Outback, City Rover, MiTo, Roomster, IQ, those MPVs they did a while back and so on) and do a perfectly good job of it without making it dry, secondly if you want to know what a normal car is like you can go and test drive it and thirdly what a person who likes driving RWD sports/super cars quickly thinks of a 1.0 Corsa is largely irrelevant to the sort of person who's going to be considering buying a 1.0 Corsa and is utterly irrelevant to someone who'll never consider buying a 1.0 Corsa. At least if they're caning supercars around there's some aspirational element to it for people who wish they could do that sort of thing (it doesn't interest me personally but it does interest a lot of other people) and if they're concentrating on messing around and making an entertainment programme it's relevant to everyone whether they're interested in cars or not (I know a lot of people who would answer the question "What car have you got?" with "A green one" who enjoy watching Top Gear).

They could certainly use the influence they have better than they do (something like a quick winter tyre explanation would be nice and wouldn't have taken much longer than slagging off Mexicans) but suggesting they're out of touch with everyday cars is wrong.
 
Last edited:
As someone else pointed out; do we really get that many rubbish camera products released? I do see the occasional lens 'slated' universally on review sites, but I think the most telling reviews are the group comparison ones where it's easier to see which product would best suit our needs. That's also when we see some fact based 'criticism'.

Yep agree its probably impossible to buy a bad camera nowadays its all down to personal preference and what you can afford:)
 
HifiChoice lost musical fidelity as an advertiser as they slated some of their stuff. It is known... doesn't happen often though.

TG is entertainment around motoring. The challenges with the three of them is just an excuse for them to play around like those old chaps off last of the summer wine. I'm sure Clarkson said that Skoda thing was the best car in the world as it just did everything.
 
Ferrari apparently blacklist anyone who gives their products a poor review.

I read Clarkson's articles because they're usually quite entertaining and he'll often give the reasoning behind his verdicts. As much as I like him, I've never read his books or bought his DVDs. I get very bored of Top Gear's 'what can we blow up' and 'which cars can we mutilate/destroy' pieces.
 
Think most of the HiFi press is *very* in the pockets of the advertisers...I'd never trust the reviews in any of the UK mags.
 
Why use Clarkson for an example he's a total Gob******e

:lol::lol:

Trouble is if it wasn't his show he wouldn't play.........

Still he's got more money than I'll ever have, drives better cars than I ever will - and he'll always be an overbearing gear k**b.

Wait - familiar?
 
Ferrari apparently blacklist anyone who gives their products a poor review.

I read Clarkson's articles because they're usually quite entertaining and he'll often give the reasoning behind his verdicts. As much as I like him, I've never read his books or bought his DVDs. I get very bored of Top Gear's 'what can we blow up' and 'which cars can we mutilate/destroy' pieces.

Bit like in f1 then :lol:

Interestingly I have read more reviews of gear that I could ever remember - not one of them convinced me to buy a particular piece of equipment - mainly because the next review claimed something else was better. IMO reviews can give an insight into a product but all the photo mags seem to do is pander to the manufacturers incessant need to provide us with more features than we could possibly need along with more pixels than you'd need to print advertising hoardings.

More like convincing us to buy new products to keep all of them in business
 
Last edited:
Brendan Mulachy said:
it wasnt a Penn Pat it was a rod from somewhere like Belgium or France that ive not heard of before ...or since :lol:

Grauvell maybe? Think the Penn incident was Dave barham and Neil mckellow :)
 
Pretty how it is in publishing if you rely heavily on advertising revenue.

I've worked on consumer magazines for the past decade and have learned (sometimes the hard way) that there is a balance between integrity (i.e. telling it as it is) and slitting your own throat financially.

Some of the big players in publishing dictate to the advertisers, but in niche publishing and specialist magazines, more often than not the advertisers have to be kept sweet because every penny counts. It's not to say you bend over to get shafted every day, but you have to make allowances and treat people fairly and keep the customer happy.

The other thing is something my boss says a lot; there is a lot of good gear out there and it's now getting harder and harder to find really, really papp stuff. It's out there, no doubt, but if we slate something in our mags it does no-one any favours. I agree that consumer magazines should give honest reviews but if it's that bad then it really shouldn't be reviewed in the first place IMO.

I've done my fair share of honest reviews but it has to be backed up by fact, not opinion, if you want to be able to stand your ground. The worst thing that can be done with reviews is say "I think this is bad because...", as that is purely a personal opinion and it's worth nothing, even if you are an editor. I used to conduct a lot of pole tests, some costing upwards of £4,000. At that price you expect the best and 99.9% of the time, you got the best. Bu there would be occasions where a product fell short either in performance or in value for money. I put this in reviews but always made sure that I could argue my case.

It's the same with group tests; there's only one winner and lots of losers. We ditched group tests for this reason, although we did end up starting them again but with masses of in-depth info that the reader could easily use to see what products offered the best option in certain sectors.
I understand where you're coming from and I don't entirely disagree but...

In my experience most serious magazines do try to give honest reviews. The aren't likely to say "this is a bad camera", they're far more likely to say that they were surprised to find that the autofocus was slower than most cameras in that price range (for example) or that "I found that the depth of field preview was difficult to locate with my large fingers" - but they're saying the same thing, people just have to read carefully...

And let's face it, there aren't really any bad cameras any more, just as there are no really bad cars - just ones that suit individuals better or less well than others.

For those of us old enough to remember, there were the Wray and the Reid cameras (copies of the Leica, but the bright sparks who made them thought that metric measurements were filthy foreign things so they converted to imperial before making them:)) There was the Ilford Sportsman, known in the trade as the Ilford film tearing machine, and a couple of copies of the Hassie that dropped to bits - name a current camera that isn't fit for purpose!

That leaves us with 2 problems.
1. Magazine writers who seem to know little or nothing about the type of equipment they're reviewing. In my experience this happens A LOT in the beginner-level magazines.
2. Magazine writers who seem to have a vested interest. These people are easy to spot if you're in the trade, because every single review in a group test puts one particular supplier in front, regardless of merit. I've come across this with one particular publisher.

But I've never seen any evidence that whether or not a particular Company advertises in a particular magazine has any effect, in one direction or another.
 
Back
Top