- Messages
- 8,193
- Name
- Pat MacInnes
- Edit My Images
- Yes
Garry - that's a very good summary 
The problem that faces many publishers is (those who want to stay in business anyway) balancing the ability to draw in advertising spend but without compromising the magazine (and by extension, its staff). My boss takes great care to make sure we conduct ourselves accordingly. We are taught to work with the advertisers to keep them advertising without giving them too much control over how we run our mags. Those who can't grasp this concept are soon shown the door, or at least, shown the error of their ways and put on the right path.
The magazine has to have worth to both the readers and the advertiser. Integrity, knowledge and experience are what I prided myself on. I very rarely got drawn by a narked advertiser over what I knew or how I could qualify my statements. Those that did challenge me either has a case (and if wrong, I'd admit it) or were told to go away. Thankfully, I kept advertisers for a long time and I had a pretty good editoriship.
This isn't the ethos of everyone though. Some publishers take, take, take and that only benefits one person - them. The advertisers get nothing and the reader is left to question the views of those writing the magazines. These mags usually don't last that long and if they do, they have a rich backer.
In relation to the camera market, you're spot on; there aren't bad cameras, just ones that have a better set of features or suit a particular user more.
Whether all advertisers get benefits from advertising in magazines, I don't know. But I know that my mag, along with several of our other titles, have pretty much helped shape the angling industry in one way or another. We have made companies (and celebrities) and people trust that about us.
The problem that faces many publishers is (those who want to stay in business anyway) balancing the ability to draw in advertising spend but without compromising the magazine (and by extension, its staff). My boss takes great care to make sure we conduct ourselves accordingly. We are taught to work with the advertisers to keep them advertising without giving them too much control over how we run our mags. Those who can't grasp this concept are soon shown the door, or at least, shown the error of their ways and put on the right path.
The magazine has to have worth to both the readers and the advertiser. Integrity, knowledge and experience are what I prided myself on. I very rarely got drawn by a narked advertiser over what I knew or how I could qualify my statements. Those that did challenge me either has a case (and if wrong, I'd admit it) or were told to go away. Thankfully, I kept advertisers for a long time and I had a pretty good editoriship.
This isn't the ethos of everyone though. Some publishers take, take, take and that only benefits one person - them. The advertisers get nothing and the reader is left to question the views of those writing the magazines. These mags usually don't last that long and if they do, they have a rich backer.
In relation to the camera market, you're spot on; there aren't bad cameras, just ones that have a better set of features or suit a particular user more.
Whether all advertisers get benefits from advertising in magazines, I don't know. But I know that my mag, along with several of our other titles, have pretty much helped shape the angling industry in one way or another. We have made companies (and celebrities) and people trust that about us.